Honestly, if you have a toddler or an elementary-aged kid, you've probably spent at least one October evening staring at a lumpy orange gourd wondering how to make it look like a cool, blue, shoe-loving feline. Pete the Cat is basically the king of book character pumpkin contests. He’s simple. He’s groovy. But somehow, parents often overcomplicate the process and end up with a mess of wet blue paint and sagging whiskers.
I’ve seen a lot of "perfect" DIYs online that look like they were done by a professional sculptor. Real life isn't like that. Most of us are working with a sticky kitchen table and a kid who wants to "help" by dumping an entire jar of glitter on the stem.
The trick to pete the cat pumpkin ideas that actually look like the character is focusing on the geometry. Pete isn't a realistic cat. He's a vibe. If you get the eyes right, you’re 90% of the way there.
Why the No-Carve Pete the Cat Pumpkin Wins Every Time
Carving is a nightmare. Let’s be real. It rots in three days, it smells like a swamp, and a blue cat with a hole for a face just looks... creepy.
If you want your pumpkin to last until Thanksgiving, go the no-carve route. Most of the successful Pete projects I’ve seen, including those inspired by James Dean’s actual illustrations in Pete the Cat: Five Little Pumpkins, rely on a solid blue base.
The Blue Paint Dilemma
Don’t use washable kids' paint. It will flake off the waxy surface of the pumpkin the second it dries. You need acrylics. Specifically, a bright, primary blue. Some people swear by spray paint for a smooth finish, but if you’re doing this with kids, a big foam brush and a bottle of Apple Barrel acrylic paint is the way to go.
It might take two coats. Let the first one dry completely. If you’re impatient and do the second coat too early, you’ll just peel the first layer off and end up with a patchy, sad-looking cat.
Those Iconic Yellow Eyes
Pete’s eyes are almond-shaped and yellow. That's his signature. Instead of trying to paint them—which is hard to do over wet blue paint—use yellow cardstock or craft foam.
📖 Related: Finding Your Xavier Final Exam Schedule Without Losing Your Mind
- Pro Tip: Cut out two large yellow football shapes.
- Use a black Sharpie or black paint to put a vertical slit in the middle.
- Glue them on once the blue paint is bone dry.
It gives the pumpkin a 3D pop that looks way more "pro" than a shaky hand-painted eye.
Beyond the Basics: Groovy Variations
If you want to move past the standard "blue head" look, you have to look at the books for inspiration. Pete is always wearing something or doing something.
Pete the Cat and His Four Groovy Buttons
This is a fan favorite for school contests. You paint the pumpkin blue, but you don't stop there. You find four large, mismatched buttons—red, green, light blue, and yellow—and hot glue them down the "chest" of the pumpkin.
Wait. A pumpkin doesn't have a chest.
Basically, you just glue them in a vertical line below the face. It’s an instant storyteller. If you want to get really fancy, you can use a second, smaller pumpkin painted yellow to act as his shirt.
The "I Love My White Shoes" Version
This one is hilarious because it’s so literal. You paint the pumpkin blue, do the face, and then you actually put the pumpkin inside a pair of tiny white sneakers. Or, if you don't want to sacrifice a pair of shoes, you can mold some "shoes" out of white Model Magic clay at the base of the pumpkin.
✨ Don't miss: Why True Food Kitchen Plano is the Only Legacy West Spot That Actually Matters
I’ve seen people use actual dirty sneakers for the "I Love My Brown Shoes" (mud) version too. It’s gross, but kids love it.
Five Little Pumpkins Theme
Since the book Pete the Cat: Five Little Pumpkins is a staple, why not make a scene? Instead of one big Pete, get five tiny "pie" pumpkins. Decorate each one with a different expression from the song.
- The first one (getting late).
- The second one (witches in the air).
- The third one (we don't care).
- The fourth one (let's run and run).
- The fifth one (ready for some fun).
Then, sit a larger Pete the Cat pumpkin behind them like he’s the conductor. It's a bit more work, but it fills up a porch nicely.
The Materials Nobody Tells You You Need
You’ve got the pumpkin. You’ve got the blue paint. What else?
Pipe Cleaners for Whiskers: Don't paint the whiskers. They get lost in the blue. Use black or white pipe cleaners. Poke three small holes on each side of the "nose" area with a toothpick, then jam the pipe cleaners in. They stay put, and they give the cat that scruffy, lived-in look.
The Nose: Pete has a tiny black inverted triangle for a nose. A black pom-pom is the easiest fix here. It adds texture.
Hot Glue is Your Best Friend: Don't bother with Elmer’s glue. It won't hold the buttons or the ears on the pumpkin’s skin. A low-temp glue gun is essential.
White Duck Tape: If you’re doing the "White Shoes" or the "Magic Sunglasses" version, white tape is great for making clean lines on the blue background.
💡 You might also like: Why the blow up sofa 90s trend was actually a nightmare (and why we still want one)
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Most people mess up the ears. Pete’s ears aren't round like a bear; they’re tall, pointy triangles that sit right on top of his head.
I’ve seen people try to use the pumpkin stem as a nose. It almost never works. It makes the face look lopsided. It’s better to treat the stem as "hair" or a hat and keep the face on the smoothest side of the pumpkin.
Another big fail? Forgetting the tail. If you're displaying this in a spot where people can see the back, use a long, blue tinsel garland or a thick blue wire wrapped in felt to create a curvy cat tail.
Actionable Steps for Your Pete Project
If you're starting this today, here's how to actually get it done without losing your mind:
- Prep the surface: Wipe the pumpkin down with a mix of water and a little vinegar. It removes the wax and helps the paint stick.
- Sketch first: Use a pencil to lightly trace where the eyes and nose will go before you touch the paint. You can erase pencil on a pumpkin; you can't erase blue acrylic.
- The "Sunglasses" Trick: If you really mess up the eyes, just make Pete's Magic Sunglasses out of black cardstock and glue them over the mistake. Suddenly, he’s not a "failed pumpkin," he’s just "Pete with his magic sunglasses."
- Seal it: If this is staying outside, hit it with a quick coat of clear matte sealer spray. It keeps the rain from turning your blue cat into a blue puddle.
Pete always says, "It's all good." Even if your pumpkin ends up looking more like a blue blueberry than a cat, your kids are going to think it's the coolest thing on the block. Just keep the blue bright, the eyes yellow, and the attitude groovy.
Next Steps:
Go grab a bottle of "True Blue" acrylic paint and some yellow craft foam. Start by painting the pumpkin and letting it dry overnight before you try to add the face—this is the single most important step for a clean finish.