When you think of the Cincinnati Bengals, names like Joe Burrow, Ja’Marr Chase, or maybe Chad Johnson probably pop into your head first. But if you walk into a sports bar in Cincy and start talking about the most unstoppable force in franchise history, the older guys are going to mention a man who looked like a linebacker but ran like a freight train.
Pete Johnson.
Honestly, if you saw his 6-foot, 250-pound frame today, you’d assume he was a modern defensive end. But back in the late '70s and early '80s, Pete Johnson was the sledgehammer that the Cincinnati Bengals used to flatten the AFC. He wasn't just a "big back." He was the big back.
Pete Johnson: The Human Goal Line Cheat Code
Most people don't realize that even with all the modern stars, Pete Johnson still holds the Bengals' franchise record for total touchdowns. He found the end zone 70 times in a Bengals uniform. That's more than Corey Dillon. More than Rudi Johnson. More than A.J. Green or Chad Johnson.
Think about that for a second. In an era where players didn't have the benefit of modern sports science or pass-heavy schemes, Pete was just inevitable. If the Bengals were at the three-yard line, everyone in the stadium—from the nosebleeds to the opposing defensive coordinator—knew who was getting the ball. And usually, it didn't matter.
🔗 Read more: Why Seeing a Blue Marlin Jumping Out of Water Is the Most Violent Event in the Ocean
Pete was a second-round pick out of Ohio State in 1977. He had spent his college years at Ohio State blocking for Archie Griffin, which is kinda hilarious when you realize Pete ended up outscoring almost everyone anyway. When he got to Cincinnati, he didn't wait around to make an impact. He led the team in rushing every single season he was there. Every. Single. One.
Breaking Down the 1981 Season
1981 was the year it all clicked. The Bengals went 12-4, and Pete was the engine. He put up 1,077 rushing yards, but the real story was the 16 total touchdowns. He was a Pro Bowler and a Second-team All-Pro that year. People forget he wasn't just a diver; he caught 46 passes that season. Imagine a 250-pound man coming at you in the open field after a screen pass. No thanks.
But then came the Super Bowl. Super Bowl XVI.
The Goal Line Stand That Changed Everything
If you want to understand the legacy of Pete Johnson and the Cincinnati Bengals, you have to look at the "Goal Line Stand." It’s one of the most famous sequences in NFL history.
The Bengals were down 20-7 against the San Francisco 49ers. They had the ball at the one-yard line. This was Pete Johnson territory. This was what he was built for.
✨ Don't miss: NBA Finals 2026: When is Basketball Championship Glory Decided?
- First Down: Pete tries to plunge in. No gain.
- Second Down: A pass to Charles Alexander. Stopped at the one.
- Third Down: Alexander again. No dice.
- Fourth Down: This was it. The game was on the line.
Coach Forrest Gregg gave it to his big man. Pete took the handoff and tried to leap over the pile. But Dan Bunz and the 49ers' defense met him in the air. He was stopped inches short.
It’s one of those "what if" moments that haunts Bengals fans. If Pete gets six inches more, maybe the Bengals have a ring decades before the Burrow era. But football is a game of inches, and that afternoon in the Pontiac Silverdome, those inches belonged to San Francisco.
What Most People Get Wrong About Pete
The narrative usually paints Pete Johnson as just a "bruiser." That’s a bit lazy.
He was a surprisingly competent receiver and a devastating blocker. You don't lead a team in rushing for seven straight years just by running into people's backs. He had vision. He understood leverage.
And let's talk about that 1984 trade. The Bengals traded Pete to the San Diego Chargers for James Brooks. At the time, it felt like the end of an era. Pete was the Bengals' all-time leading rusher at the time with 5,421 yards. While Brooks became a legend in his own right, seeing Pete in a Chargers (and later a Dolphins) jersey just felt wrong.
Interestingly, in his final season in 1984, Pete played for three different teams if you count the preseason transition. He ended up scoring 9 rushing touchdowns for the Miami Dolphins that year despite only rushing for 159 yards. Talk about a specialist. He finished his career with 76 rushing touchdowns, which at the time of his retirement, put him 6th in NFL history. As of 2026, he still sits at 25th all-time. That’s some serious staying power.
Life After the Stripes
Life after football wasn't always a highlight reel for Pete. In 2008, he dealt with some legal trouble regarding a bad check for a pickup truck. It was a tough headline for a guy who was a hero in Columbus and Cincinnati. But for the fans who watched him, that's not the defining story.
The defining story is #46 lowering his shoulder in the "Freezer Bowl" against the Chargers. It's the way he made 1,000-yard seasons look like a casual Sunday stroll.
✨ Don't miss: Wide Receiver Rankings Week 3: Why Trusting Your Gut Might Be a Mistake
How to Appreciate the Pete Johnson Legacy Today
If you’re a younger Bengals fan, you should go back and watch the 1981 AFC Championship game. The "Freezer Bowl." It was $−9°F$ with a wind chill that made it feel like $−32°F$.
Pete ran for 80 yards and a touchdown in conditions that would make most people quit life. He was built for the cold. He was built for Cincinnati.
Practical Takeaways for Bengals Historians:
- Check the Record Books: Pete still holds the franchise record for total touchdowns (70) and rushing touchdowns (64).
- The "Fullback" Myth: Don't let the position title fool you. In the 80s, the "fullback" was often the primary ball carrier. Pete was the RB1 in every sense of the word.
- The Trade Impact: The trade for James Brooks is often cited as one of the best "challenge trades" in NFL history—both teams moved on from productive veterans to change their offensive look.
Pete Johnson was the physical identity of the Cincinnati Bengals before the "Ickey Shuffle" or the "Who Dey" chant really took over the national consciousness. He was the thunder before the lightning.
If you ever find yourself at Paycor Stadium, take a look at the Ring of Honor. Even if he isn't the first name mentioned in the national media, the dirt and grass of Riverfront Stadium remember exactly who Pete Johnson was.
Next Step: Watch the NFL Films highlights of the 1981 "Freezer Bowl" to see Pete Johnson operating in sub-zero temperatures. It puts modern "toughness" into a whole new perspective.