Finding the right faces for a beloved book series is a nightmare. Honestly, it’s a thankless job. You have millions of fans who have spent two decades picturing a specific version of Percy, Annabeth, and Grover in their heads. When Disney+ announced the Percy Jackson series casting, the internet basically imploded. Some people were thrilled; others were, well, less than kind.
But now that we’re deep into the second season, The Sea of Monsters, the dust has mostly settled. We’ve seen the trio grow up. We’ve met the new heavy hitters like Tyson and Thalia. Looking back at the process, it’s clear that Rick Riordan wasn’t looking for a Xerox copy of the book covers. He was looking for a "vibe."
The Core Trio and the Chemistry Gamble
Walker Scobell was the first piece of the puzzle. If you saw him in The Adam Project, you already knew he had that signature Percy Jackson sass. He’s got the comedic timing of a kid who has spent too much time in detention. During the chemistry reads, Walker actually read with 11 different potential Grovers. That’s a lot of satyrs.
Aryan Simhadri eventually landed the role of Grover Underwood. Aryan brings a sort of nervous bravery that the show really needed. He’s not just a sidekick; he’s the emotional glue. Then there’s Leah Sava Jeffries as Annabeth Chase.
The backlash to Leah’s casting was, frankly, exhausting to watch. A vocal slice of the fandom was obsessed with the fact that she didn’t have blonde hair. Rick Riordan had to step in personally to remind everyone that he was looking for the soul of the character—Annabeth’s intellect, her steel, and her "Wise Girl" energy. Watching her in Season 2, especially her dynamic with Percy during the Siren scene, it’s hard to imagine anyone else in the role now.
Season 2: New Faces in the Family
If Season 1 was about establishing the world, Season 2 is about expanding the family tree. The biggest addition? Daniel Diemer as Tyson, Percy’s Cyclops half-brother.
📖 Related: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post
Casting Tyson is tricky. In the books, he’s described as this massive, somewhat clumsy presence. Daniel Diemer plays him with a heartbreaking sweetness. He manages to make Tyson feel like a genuine "little" brother despite being a mythical creature. The show decided to portray his Cyclops eye through a mix of practical effects and CGI, and it’s surprisingly grounded.
Then there’s the big one: Thalia Grace.
Thalia Grace and the Punk Rock Rebellion
We waited a long time to see Thalia in the flesh. Since she spent most of the first book as a pine tree, the casting for Season 2 had to be perfect. Enter Tamara Smart.
There is a really poetic layer to Tamara’s casting that most people don’t know. She actually played the daughter of the late Lance Reddick (who played Zeus in Season 1) in a previous project (Resident Evil). So, when she was cast as Thalia—the daughter of Zeus—it felt like a tribute.
Tamara brings that "rage-against-the-machine" energy that Riordan always talked about. She’s got the leather jacket, the spiky hair, and the "don’t mess with me" attitude. She’s the perfect foil to Percy’s more chaotic, fly-by-the-seat-of-his-pants style.
👉 See also: Austin & Ally Maddie Ziegler Episode: What Really Happened in Homework & Hidden Talents
Recasting a King: The Zeus Dilemma
The passing of Lance Reddick was a massive blow to the production. He brought a regal, terrifying stillness to Zeus. For Season 2, the production had to find someone who could carry that weight without simply imitating Lance.
Courtney B. Vance took over the mantle of the King of the Gods. It’s a different energy—maybe a bit more traditional in his "godly" aura—but he commands the screen. It’s a tough spot to be in, stepping into a role under those circumstances, but Vance has handled it with a lot of grace.
The Gray Sisters and the Weirdness Factor
One of the highlights of The Sea of Monsters casting is the Gray Sisters. These are the three ladies who share one eye and one tooth while driving a supernatural taxi. The show went for comedy legends here:
- Sandra Bernhard as Anger
- Kristen Schaal as Tempest
- Margaret Cho as Wasp
It’s inspired casting. It leans into the "weirdness" of Greek mythology that the movies often smoothed over. This show isn't afraid to be a little gross or a little bizarre, which is exactly why the books worked in the first place.
Looking Ahead: The Titan's Curse
Because the show was renewed for Season 3 early, we already have a glimpse into the future. The casting of the di Angelo siblings is the next major milestone.
✨ Don't miss: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
Levi Chrisopulos has been tapped to play Nico di Angelo, with Olive Abercrombie as his sister Bianca. Fans are already dissecting every interview to see if they can handle the heavy emotional lifting that comes in The Titan's Curse.
We’re also getting Dafne Keen as Artemis. If you saw her in Logan or The Acolyte, you know she can play a warrior who doesn't take any nonsense. Pairing her with Saara Chaudry as Zoë Nightshade is going to make for a very intense Season 3.
Why This Casting Actually Works
The reason the Percy Jackson series casting succeeds where the movies failed isn't just about age—though having actual teenagers play teenagers helps a lot. It’s about the fact that these actors actually like the source material.
Walker and Aryan are self-proclaimed nerds. They play God of War. They read the fan theories. They’re "plugged in." When you have a cast that actually cares about the lore, it shows up in the performances. They aren't just saying lines; they’re living in Camp Half-Blood.
What to Watch For Next
If you're following the series, pay attention to how the "found family" dynamic shifts in the coming episodes. The introduction of Tyson changes the chemistry between Percy and Annabeth in a way that sets up the romance (Percabeth) for years to come.
- Watch the background: The show loves to hide Easter eggs in the cabin casting.
- Listen to the dialogue: A lot of the best lines from the trio are actually ad-libbed or adjusted to fit their real-life friendship.
- Check the credits: Look for the new demigods being introduced in the background of Camp Half-Blood; many of them are hints for future book plots.
The best way to appreciate the casting is to stop comparing it to the 2005 character art and start looking at the performances. These kids are doing the work. They're bringing a 20-year-old story into a new era, and honestly? They're nailing it.