You remember the 1980s, right? If you don't, ask your dad about the November "war." For a solid decade, the Penn State vs Notre Dame game wasn't just a matchup; it was basically a national title eliminator played in the mud and snow.
It's weird.
Two of the biggest brands in the history of the sport essentially stopped playing each other for nearly 20 years. They went from being the only two "Independent" titans left on the East Coast to strangers. Then, just recently in 2025, we finally got the massive payoff everyone wanted: a College Football Playoff semifinal in the Orange Bowl. It lived up to the hype, ending in a 27-24 heartbreaker that reminded everyone why this series is so special.
Honestly, the history between these two is a mess of near-misses and bad timing.
The 12-Year War and Why it Ended
Back in 1981, Joe Paterno and the Notre Dame administration inked a deal to play every single year in late November. It was genius. At the time, Penn State wasn't in the Big Ten. They were an Independent, just like the Irish. This meant they could schedule whoever they wanted, and they chose violence.
From 1981 to 1992, they met 12 times.
Penn State actually dominated this stretch, winning eight of those games. People forget that. They think of Notre Dame as the "gold standard," but the Nittany Lions were the ones clinching national titles through South Bend. In 1982, Penn State beat the Irish 24-14 on the way to their first consensus championship. In 1986, they did it again, surviving a 24-19 nail-biter against a young Lou Holtz squad to stay undefeated for the Fiesta Bowl.
But then, money and conferences ruined the fun.
👉 See also: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
Penn State joined the Big Ten in 1993. Suddenly, their schedule was packed with Midwestern trips to West Lafayette and Bloomington. There wasn't room for a non-conference heavyweight every November. Meanwhile, Notre Dame signed that massive NBC deal. The "12-Year War" died not because the fans lost interest, but because the logistics became a nightmare.
The Snow Bowl: A Ending No One Forgot
If you want to understand the soul of Penn State vs Notre Dame, you have to look at 1992. It was the final game of that annual series. It’s known as the "Snow Bowl," and it’s basically a religious text in South Bend.
The weather was miserable.
Penn State led 16-9 late in the fourth. Notre Dame's Rick Mirer led a frantic drive through the slush, hitting Jerome Bettis for a touchdown with 25 seconds left. Lou Holtz, being Lou Holtz, didn't want a tie. He went for two. Reggie Brooks caught the conversion, the Irish won 17-16, and the rivalry went into a deep freeze for fourteen years.
The 2025 CFP Semifinal: Breaking the Deadlock
Fast forward to January 9, 2025. The Orange Bowl.
Coming into that game, the all-time series was deadlocked at 9-9-1. You couldn't write a better script. It was the first time James Franklin and Marcus Freeman faced off, and the stakes were a trip to the National Championship.
Penn State looked dead.
✨ Don't miss: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
They fell behind 17-0 early. The Irish defense, led by Al Golden—who, ironically, played for and coached at Penn State—was suffocating. But Drew Allar found a rhythm in the second half. The Lions stormed back with 14 straight points, eventually taking a 24-17 lead. It felt like Happy Valley south.
Then, the Irish magic happened.
Notre Dame clawed back, and with only seven seconds on the clock, they drilled a field goal to win 27-24. It was a brutal way for Penn State's best season in decades to end, but it proved that the "independent" spirit of this rivalry still exists. The all-time record now stands at 10-9-1 in favor of the Fighting Irish.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Matchup
A lot of younger fans think Penn State and Notre Dame have always been conference rivals or that they play every few years. Nope.
Before the 2025 playoff game, they hadn't met since 2007.
That 2007 game was actually the "White Out" that started the modern tradition. It was the first time the entire stadium wore white for a night game. Penn State crushed a struggling Jimmy Clausen-led Irish team 31-10. But since then? Silence.
The "recruiting war" is actually more active than the games themselves. Because Pennsylvania is a massive Catholic football state, the battle for the "Coal Region" kids in places like Scranton and Wilkes-Barre is constant. Notre Dame steals guys like Raghib "Rocket" Ismail; Penn State keeps the local studs. It's a 365-day-a-year rivalry that just doesn't happen on the field enough.
🔗 Read more: Bethany Hamilton and the Shark: What Really Happened That Morning
Comparing the Programs by the Numbers
| Category | Penn State | Notre Dame |
|---|---|---|
| All-Time Wins | 943 (9th) | 961 (4th) |
| National Titles | 2 (Claimed) | 11 (Claimed) |
| Series Head-to-Head | 9 | 10 |
| Tie Games | 1 | 1 |
Don't let the "Titles" column fool you. Since 1980, these two have been on remarkably similar trajectories. Both have struggled to get back to the absolute summit while remaining consistently in the top 10.
Why We Won't See This Often
If you're looking for a rematch in 2026 or 2027, don't hold your breath.
Looking at the future schedules, Penn State has games lined up against teams like Marshall, Temple, and Syracuse. The Big Ten's 9-game conference schedule is a "rivalry killer." With the expansion of the Big Ten to include USC, Oregon, and Washington, Penn State's schedule is already a gauntlet.
Notre Dame's deal with the ACC requires them to play five games against ACC opponents every year. Add in their protected rivalry with USC and the Navy game, and their "free" spots are limited.
Basically, unless they meet in the 12-team playoff again, we might be waiting another decade.
Practical Takeaways for the Fans
If you're a fan of either team or just a college football historian, here is how you should view the Penn State vs Notre Dame situation:
- Watch the Hockey Matchups: Since the Big Ten added Notre Dame as an affiliate member for hockey, these two play constantly on the ice. In fact, Penn State just swept the Irish in January 2026 at Pegula Ice Arena. It’s the only place the rivalry is currently "alive" and annual.
- Track the 2027 Recruiting Class: Keep an eye on 4-star and 5-star players in Eastern PA. If a kid from Philadelphia or the Lehigh Valley picks the Irish over the Lions, it’s a major signal of where the programs stand.
- Root for the Playoff: The new 12-team (and potentially 14-team) playoff format is the only realistic way we get this football game back. Because of their brand size, they are often seeded near each other.
- Check the Secondary Market Early: If a home-and-home is ever announced, tickets will be more expensive than Ohio State or Michigan games. The "novelty factor" of this game is at an all-time high.
The 2025 Orange Bowl showed that the fire hasn't gone out. It’s just waiting for the right moment to flare up again. For now, we just have the highlights of 1992 and the heartbreak of 2025 to keep us busy.
To get the most out of the next potential meeting, you can study the current roster construction of both teams—specifically how James Franklin's "keep the best in PA" strategy stacks up against Marcus Freeman's national reach. You should also keep an eye on the 2026 Big Ten schedule releases to see if any "neutral site" rumors start floating for future non-conference windows.