Food internet is a weird place. One day everyone is obsessed with feta pasta, and the next, we're all staring in horror at a photo of a peas and mayo pizza that looks like it belongs in a museum of bad decisions. People lose their minds over pineapple. So, naturally, when a photo of a pie slathered in warm mayonnaise and canned peas goes viral, the reaction is basically a digital riot.
It’s gross, right? Most people think so. But here’s the thing about the internet: it lacks context. We see a jarring image, scream "heresy," and move on. If you actually look into where this combination comes from and why people are eating it, you find a weirdly fascinating overlap of regional traditions, post-war pantry staples, and the chaotic nature of global fusion.
The Viral Moment That Broke the Internet
It usually starts with a tweet. Back in 2017, a user posted a photo of a pizza topped with bright green peas and lines of mayonnaise. It wasn't a joke. It wasn't a "food crime" staged for clout. It was a real meal. The post racked up hundreds of thousands of interactions. People were tagging the FBI. They were calling for a ban on all ovens.
But why do we care so much?
Pizza is a sacred cow. We have these rigid rules about what belongs on dough. Yet, if you go to Japan or parts of South Korea, mayonnaise on pizza is as standard as pepperoni is in Chicago. They call it "Mayo Jaga." It’s usually potato, bacon, and a heavy drizzle of Kewpie. Peas? They show up too. In the UK, "mushy peas" are a cultural institution, so putting them on a flatbread isn't actually that much of a stretch if you've already accepted them next to your fish and chips.
The peas and mayo pizza controversy is really a clash of culinary geographies. What looks like a mistake to an American or an Italian is just Tuesday dinner somewhere else.
Where Did Peas and Mayo Pizza Come From?
We have to talk about Brazil. Brazilian pizza culture is legendary for its "more is more" philosophy. If you haven't seen a Brazilian pizza with a crust stuffed with cheddar and a topping list that includes corn, peas, hearts of palm, and hard-boiled eggs, you haven't lived. Or maybe you've just stayed safe.
📖 Related: Bates Nut Farm Woods Valley Road Valley Center CA: Why Everyone Still Goes After 100 Years
In Brazil, ervilha (peas) and milho (corn) are standard pizza toppings. They provide texture. They provide a bit of sweetness. And the mayo? In many South American and Eastern European contexts, mayonnaise is used as a moisture agent. It’s not necessarily glopped on after baking like a salad dressing. Often, it's baked into the pie or used as a base.
The Mayo Factor
Mayo is basically just oil and egg. When you heat it, it changes. It doesn't stay that cold, jiggly substance you put on a turkey sandwich. It thins out. It browns. It adds a massive hit of fat and acid.
Food historians like Kenji López-Alt have pointed out that mayonnaise is essentially a stable emulsion. While he might not be advocating for the peas and mayo pizza specifically, the science of why people like fat (mayo) and sweetness (peas) on a salty crust is pretty basic biology. We are hardwired to crave high-calorie combinations.
Why Our Brains Hate the Idea (But Might Like the Taste)
Visual bias is real. We eat with our eyes first. A pea is a sphere. It looks weird on a flat surface. It rolls around. Humans generally prefer foods that stay put. When you see a "wet" topping like mayo paired with a "rolling" topping like peas, your brain signals a texture mismatch.
Honestly, it's mostly a branding problem.
If you called it a "Sweet Pea and Aioli Flatbread with a Lemon-Egg Reduction," people would pay $24 for it in a Brooklyn bistro. But call it peas and mayo pizza, and suddenly you're a pariah.
👉 See also: Why T. Pepin’s Hospitality Centre Still Dominates the Tampa Event Scene
The reality is that peas have a high sugar content. When they pop in your mouth, they provide a burst of sweetness that cuts through the saltiness of the mozzarella. If the mayo is high quality—think Kewpie or a homemade lemon mayo—it acts as a creamy bridge between the earthy dough and the bright vegetable.
The "Pantry Pizza" Phenomenon
There’s a socioeconomic side to this too. Let’s be real. Not everyone has access to fresh basil and buffalo mozzarella. Historically, some of the most famous dishes in the world came from people making do with what was in the cupboard.
- Canned Peas: Long shelf life, cheap protein, easy color.
- Mayonnaise: Stays good in the fridge forever, provides the fat that fresh cheese might be missing.
- Frozen Dough: A canvas for whatever is left at the end of the month.
During the mid-20th century, especially in the UK and parts of the US, "salad" often meant anything held together by mayo. Pea salads were a staple. Eventually, those flavors migrated. If you like a pea salad, why wouldn't you put it on a warm piece of bread?
Regional Variations You Didn't Know Existed
- Sweden: They put bananas and curry powder on pizza. Compared to that, peas are downright normal.
- Japan: Corn and mayo is the gold standard. Adding peas is just a color swap.
- Russia: It’s not uncommon to see mayo used as a drizzled garnish on a variety of hot savory dishes, including pizzas and flatbreads.
Is It Actually Healthy?
Probably not. You're adding a significant amount of saturated fat via the mayo. However, peas are one of the better pizza toppings from a nutritional standpoint. They offer fiber, Vitamin K, and Vitamin C. Most pizzas are just carbs and fat. At least the peas and mayo pizza is inviting a legume to the party.
If you're using a low-fat mayo or a vegan alternative, you're looking at a completely different macro profile. But let’s be honest: nobody is eating this for a diet. You're eating it because you're curious, you're broke, or you're from a culture that doesn't think it's weird.
How to Actually Make It Edible (The Expert Way)
Look, if you're going to try this, don't just dump a can of Le Sueur peas on a frozen cheese pizza and squirt Hellmann's over it. That’s how you end up on a "Worst Food" subreddit.
✨ Don't miss: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
If you want to understand the appeal, you have to do it right. Use fresh or flash-frozen peas. They have a snap. They aren't mushy. For the mayo, mix it with a bit of garlic and lemon juice. This turns it into an "aioli" (even if the purists disagree).
The Assembly Process
- The Base: Use a thin, crispy crust. A thick, doughy crust with mayo becomes a soggy mess.
- The Cheese: Go light on the mozz. You already have fat from the mayo. Maybe try a bit of salty feta to contrast the sweet peas.
- The Heat: Bake the pizza with the peas on it so they blister slightly.
- The Mayo: Drizzle it after the pizza comes out of the oven. This prevents the oil from separating and becoming a greasy pool.
The Verdict on Peas and Mayo Pizza
Is it the future of Italian cuisine? No. Is it a sign of the apocalypse? Also no.
The peas and mayo pizza is a testament to how globalized food has become. It’s a mashup of different cultures' comfort foods. It’s a reminder that "authentic" is a moving target.
If you hate it, that’s fine. Most people do. But the vitriol directed at this specific combo usually says more about our desire for food rules than it does about the flavor itself. Food is subjective. One man's culinary nightmare is another man's childhood nostalgia.
Practical Steps for the Brave
If you're genuinely curious about trying this combo without ruining your night, follow these steps:
- Start Small: Make a French bread pizza. It’s lower stakes than a full pie.
- Quality Control: Use frozen petite peas, not canned. The texture difference is massive.
- The "Mayo" Hack: Mix your mayo with a dash of Sriracha or pesto. It bridges the gap between the traditional pizza flavors and the creaminess of the mayo.
- Acid is Key: A squeeze of fresh lime or a sprinkle of red pepper flakes after baking will balance the heavy fats.
Ultimately, the best way to handle the peas and mayo pizza debate is to try a bite before you join the online mob. You might still hate it. You might think it’s a crime against dough. But at least you’ll know why it’s there in the first place. Stop treating pizza like a museum piece and start treating it like a blank canvas. Even if that canvas occasionally gets painted with green circles and white streaks.