It’s been over a decade since the news broke, but people still can’t stop talking about the time Paul Wesley and Torrey DeVitto were the "it" couple of the supernatural TV world.
Think back to 2011. The Vampire Diaries was at its peak. Every teenager in America was choosing between Team Stefan and Team Damon. Then, in walks Dr. Meredith Fell—played by Torrey DeVitto—and suddenly, the line between fiction and reality got incredibly blurry. Why? Because she was actually married to the leading man in real life.
Honestly, their relationship felt like a fever dream for fans. One minute they’re the private, cool indie-vibe couple who met on a horror movie set, and the next, they’re navigating a very public divorce while still being coworkers. You’ve probably seen the TikToks of Paul forgetting her character's name at a recent convention. It's awkward. It’s human. And it's exactly why we’re still obsessed with what really happened between them.
The "Killer Movie" Meet-Cute
They didn't meet in Mystic Falls. No, the spark actually happened in 2007 on the set of a slasher flick called Killer Movie.
🔗 Read more: Miley Cyrus Leg Infection: What Really Happened On The Walk Of Fame
Paul was a rising actor, and Torrey was already making waves in shows like One Tree Hill. They weren't an overnight tabloid sensation. In fact, they dated for four years before quietly tying the knot in New York City in April 2011. It was private. Very "low-key Brooklyn," which was Paul’s whole aesthetic at the time.
But then, the CW came calling.
When Torrey joined the cast of The Vampire Diaries in Season 3 as Dr. Meredith Fell, it seemed like a dream setup. Paul even told reporters back then that it was "fantastic" because they didn't have to be 2,000 miles apart. He was filming in Georgia, she was often in LA or on other sets. Working together was supposed to be the glue.
Life on the TVD Set
It’s gotta be weird, right? Working with your spouse while playing characters who aren't romantically involved. On screen, Meredith was the love interest for Alaric Saltzman (played by Matt Davis). Paul, meanwhile, was busy being the brooding Stefan Salvatore.
Fans loved the meta-layers. They’d show up to conventions together—like Wizard World Toronto in 2012—looking like the perfect power couple. But behind the scenes, the pressure of a high-profile show and constant travel started to take its toll.
Why Did Paul Wesley and Torrey DeVitto Call It Quits?
By July 2013, the dream was over. The couple announced their split after only two years of marriage.
The official statement was the classic Hollywood template: "amicable split" and "remaining good friends." But the internet, being the internet, went into overdrive. People were looking for a villain.
The Realities of the Split
- The Prenup: This wasn't one of those messy, years-long legal battles. They had a solid prenuptial agreement. According to legal documents from late 2013, they kept their earnings separate.
- The House: They listed their Los Angeles home for roughly $1.6 million just days after the split was announced.
- The Timing: The divorce was finalized in December 2013, less than six months after the initial filing.
There was a lot of noise about Paul moving on quickly with co-star Phoebe Tonkin, but Torrey has since clarified in interviews—specifically on podcasts years later—that there wasn't "bad blood" in the way people imagined. She even mentioned that her family stayed supportive of him.
💡 You might also like: George Clooney Natal Chart: Why His 50-Year Bachelorhood Was Written in the Stars
The Aftermath: Did She Refuse to Come Back?
Here is a detail a lot of casual fans miss. Torrey DeVitto recently admitted that after the divorce was finalized, she didn't want to go back to The Vampire Diaries.
Her character, Meredith Fell, basically vanished after the Season 4 premiere. The show wrote it off as her moving to Alaska with a new husband. In reality, Torrey just didn't want to be on that set anymore. Can you blame her? Seeing your ex every day at your "office" is a nightmare for most people, even if you’re professional actors.
"I didn't want to return to the show after the divorce," she admitted in 2024. It was about protecting her own peace.
Paul Wesley and Torrey DeVitto in 2026: Where Are They Now?
Fast forward to today. A lot has changed.
Paul Wesley has been through another marriage and divorce (to Ines de Ramon, who is now famously dating Brad Pitt). He’s currently seen with model Natalie Kuckenburg. He’s also busy making bourbon with his "brother" Ian Somerhalder and starring in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.
Torrey DeVitto has found a different kind of peace. She’s moved on to massive success in Chicago Med and recently married Jared LaPine in 2024. She even welcomed her first child recently, a huge milestone she’s been very open about on social media.
That Viral Convention Moment
If you’re on "Vampire Diaries Twitter," you saw the clip. Paul was at a fan convention and literally couldn't remember who Dr. Meredith Fell was. He looked genuinely confused.
Some fans took it as a diss. Others saw it for what it was: a guy who has filmed hundreds of hours of television and simply blocked out a complicated chapter of his life. Honestly, if you had a short-lived marriage that ended over a decade ago, you might forget the specifics of your ex’s guest-starring arc too.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors:
If you’re still a die-hard fan of this era, there are a few things you can do to keep the history alive without the drama:
- Watch "Killer Movie": To see the actual chemistry that started it all, skip the TVD reruns and find the 2008 film. It’s a time capsule of their early relationship.
- Look for Rare Memorabilia: Signed items from the 2012 convention circuit where they appeared together are becoming increasingly rare and valuable for collectors.
- Respect the Boundaries: While the "Stefan and Meredith" era was fun, both actors have made it clear they’ve moved into entirely different seasons of life. Supporting their current projects—like Torrey’s lifestyle content or Paul’s Brother's Bond bourbon—is the best way to show love for the work they did together.
The reality of Paul Wesley and Torrey DeVitto isn't a tragic drama. It’s just a story of two young people who fell in love on a movie set, tried to make it work in the crazy world of TV, and eventually realized they were better off apart. No vampires required.
To stay updated on Torrey's latest projects or Paul's upcoming Star Trek episodes, you can follow their official social media channels where they frequently post behind-the-scenes updates.