It’s been over a decade since Jamie Dornan first appeared on our screens as a soft-spoken grief counselor, but Paul Spector the Fall remains one of the most unsettling figures in television history. You’ve probably seen the tropes before. The genius serial killer. The cat-and-mouse game.
But Spector was different.
He didn't live in a basement. He didn't wear a hockey mask. Honestly, he was the guy you’d trust with your kids. That’s the core of why this character—and the show itself—stays stuck in the back of your brain long after the credits roll.
The Dual Life of Paul Spector the Fall
Most crime dramas treat the killer as a ghost, a mystery to be solved. The Fall flipped that. Right from the jump, we know who he is. We see him tucking his daughter, Olivia, into bed. We see him at work, helping people navigate the crushing weight of bereavement.
Then we see him in a dark attic, meticulously sketching his next victim.
This isn't just "good acting" by Dornan; it’s a terrifying look at compartmentalization. In psychology, this is a defense mechanism where the mind keeps conflicting parts of a life in separate boxes. Spector doesn't just pretend to be a loving father—he is a loving father. He doesn't just pretend to be a cold-blooded killer—he is a cold-blooded killer.
The two identities don't touch. Until they do.
The real horror isn't the violence itself, though that's plenty grim. It’s the sheer normalcy. Spector is a psychotherapist. He knows how to talk to people. He knows how empathy works, which makes his ability to switch it off even more predatory. He uses his professional knowledge of grief to exploit the very emotions he later inflicts on his victims' families.
💡 You might also like: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Where did he come from? (The BTK Connection)
A lot of people think Spector is purely fictional, but creator Allan Cubitt actually pulled a lot of the character's DNA from real life. Specifically, the BTK Killer, Dennis Rader.
Like Spector, Rader was a "pillar of the community." He was a church leader and a family man who managed to hide a decades-long killing spree in plain sight. Cubitt has mentioned in interviews that reading Bind, Torture, Kill: The Inside Story of BTK was a huge influence.
There are also shades of Ted Bundy in the way Spector uses his looks and perceived "safety" to disarm people. He’s the handsome stranger who shouldn't be a threat.
The Psychology of "Undoing"
One of the weirdest things Spector does is "nurturing" his victims after they’re dead. He bathes them. He paints their nails. He treats them with a bizarre, post-mortem tenderness.
Psychologists call this undoing.
It’s an attempt to mentally reverse a shameful act by doing the opposite. He kills them with brutal force, then "saves" them through care. It’s a loop. He’s trying to resolve a deep-seated trauma involving his mother, who died by suicide when he was only eight years old.
He hates women because he felt abandoned by his mother, yet he loves them because he craves that maternal connection. Every murder is a reenactment of that original loss.
📖 Related: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
Stella Gibson: The Mirror Image
You can’t talk about Paul Spector the Fall without talking about DSI Stella Gibson, played by the legendary Gillian Anderson. They are two sides of the same coin.
Gibson is just as cold, just as controlled, and just as focused as Spector. The difference, obviously, is the direction of their energy. While Spector seeks power through destruction, Gibson seeks it through order and justice.
There’s a famous scene where Gibson calls him out on his "Nietzschean" posturing. Spector likes to think of himself as an Übermensch—a man above morality. Gibson just sees a pathetic, damaged man who never grew past his childhood trauma.
She refuses to call him a monster. To her, "monster" is a way of distancing him from humanity. If he’s a monster, he’s an aberration. If he’s just a man, then he’s a product of our society. That’s a much scarier thought.
The Controversy of Season 3
If you’ve watched the whole series, you know the third season took a turn.
Spector gets shot. He gets amnesia. Or does he?
The show shifts from a police procedural to a medical and legal drama. Some fans hated it. They felt it dragged. But if you look at it through the lens of E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) in storytelling, it’s actually the most "realistic" part of the show.
👉 See also: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
It explores the messy reality of the justice system. What happens when a killer can’t remember his crimes? Can you try a man who isn't "the man" who committed the acts?
Spector’s final move—his suicide—wasn't an act of remorse. It was his final grasp at control. He didn't want the state to take his life or his freedom. He took it himself. It was the ultimate narcissistic exit.
Why it Still Matters Today
The Fall didn't just give us a scary villain. It forced us to look at the misogyny baked into everyday life.
The show is full of "casual" sexism—men in the police force talking down to Gibson, the way the media treats the victims. Spector is just the extreme version of a world that often views women as objects to be possessed or controlled.
Real-World Takeaways for Fans of the Genre:
- Don't look for monsters. Look for the "regular" guys. Real predators often hide behind respectable jobs and family lives.
- Understand the "Why." Most serial offenders have a history of Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs). Understanding this doesn't excuse the crime, but it helps in preventing future ones.
- Question the "Hero" Narrative. Gibson isn't a perfect hero. She’s flawed and complicated. True crime is never black and white.
If you're revisiting the series or watching it for the first time, pay attention to the silence. The show uses very little music during the stalking scenes. It forces you to hear what the victim hears. It’s uncomfortable. It’s supposed to be.
Next Steps for True Crime Enthusiasts:
If the psychology of Paul Spector fascinated you, your next step should be researching the BTK Killer (Dennis Rader) or Ed Kemper. Both provide a chilling real-world look at the "mask of sanity" that Spector wore so well. You can also look into the concept of "The Dark Triad" (narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy) to see how these traits manifest in high-functioning individuals.
The legacy of Paul Spector the Fall isn't just a great performance by Jamie Dornan. It's a reminder that the most dangerous people aren't lurking in the shadows—they’re often standing right next to us.