Patriots vs Raiders: What Most People Get Wrong About This Weird Rivalry

Patriots vs Raiders: What Most People Get Wrong About This Weird Rivalry

You’d think after the Tuck Rule, these two teams would just stay away from each other. Honestly, the New England Patriots vs Las Vegas Raiders discussions usually start with someone yelling about Charles Woodson’s "fumble" in the snow and end with a debate about whether Drake Maye is actually the next big thing or just another victim of the Foxborough rebuild.

It’s personal. It’s always been personal.

💡 You might also like: Golf at The Broadmoor: Why Most Players Struggle With the Mountain

We just wrapped up the 2025 season, and if you haven’t been paying attention, things got weird again. The Raiders technically "won" the most recent battle in September 2025, taking a 20-13 victory at Gillette Stadium. But looking at the box score doesn’t tell you the real story of how these two franchises are basically mirror images of chaos right now.

Why the Recent Patriots vs Raiders Discussions are Changing

Most fans are still stuck in 2001. Move on. The real conversation today centers on two names: Drake Maye and whoever is brave enough to coach the Silver and Black next.

In that 2025 season opener, we saw Mike Vrabel making his official debut as the Patriots' head coach. It was a homecoming that felt like it should have been a blowout, but the Raiders—led at the time by Pete Carroll in a short-lived, strange tenure—spoiled the party. Raiders fans love to remind everyone that they’ve actually taken three of the last five meetings.

But here is the thing people miss.

The 2026 outlook for the Raiders is basically a giant question mark. Pete Carroll is out after a 3-14 disaster. As of January 2026, the Raiders are literally in the middle of interviewing everyone from Kevin Stefanski to former players for that head coaching vacancy. They have the number one pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Every single Patriots vs Raiders discussion right now is essentially a debate about whether Vegas will finally draft a franchise QB or if they’ll keep recycling veterans like Geno Smith, who actually outplayed Maye in their last head-to-head.

🔗 Read more: Golden State Warriors vs Charlotte: Why the Warriors Just Set a New NBA Record

The Drake Maye Factor

Let’s talk about Maye. He’s the centerpiece of New England’s future. In the 2025 opener, he looked... well, jumpy. Julian Edelman even went on record saying Maye looked "out of sorts." He threw for 287 yards but had a brutal interception that basically handed the game to Vegas.

Compare that to the Raiders' weaponry. Brock Bowers is a monster. 112 catches in his rookie year? That’s not normal. When these teams meet, the mismatch isn't at QB anymore; it's whether the Patriots' linebackers can even touch Bowers before he’s 15 yards downfield.

The Ghost of Josh McDaniels

You can't have a New England Patriots vs Las Vegas Raiders discussion without mentioning the man who tried to turn the Raiders into "Patriots West" and failed spectacularly. Josh McDaniels is currently back in New England as the offensive coordinator.

Think about that irony for a second.

He went to Vegas, dismantled the roster, got fired, and now he’s back in Foxborough trying to develop Drake Maye. Raiders fans still hate the guy. Patriots fans are still skeptical. It adds this weird layer of "who got the better end of the deal?" every time they play. Spoiler: usually, nobody wins that argument.

📖 Related: Jared Goff: Why the Detroit Lions Quarterback Is Still the Guy in 2026

The historical record is surprisingly tight.

  • Total Meetings: 48
  • Patriots Wins: 25
  • Raiders Wins: 22
  • Ties: 1

The Patriots have dominated the postseason (4-0), which is why the "Tuck Rule" still burns so hot in Nevada. But in the regular season? It’s a dogfight.

What to Watch for in 2026

If you're betting on the next matchup, look at the trenches. The Raiders' Maxx Crosby is a nightmare for young quarterbacks. In the 2025 game, he was constantly in Maye's face. The Patriots' offensive line is still a work in progress, and if the Raiders use that #1 overall pick on a defensive stud or a mobile QB, the dynamic shifts again.

New England is banking on stability under Vrabel. They want that old-school, tough-nosed identity back. Vegas is banking on a total reset. Again.

Actionable Insights for Fans

If you're following these teams, stop looking at the 20-year history and start looking at these three specific areas:

  1. The Raiders' 2026 Draft: If they take a QB at #1, the 2026 meeting becomes a "Maye vs. The Rookie" narrative that will dominate the media.
  2. Brock Bowers vs. New England's Safeties: Kyle Dugger and the crew have to find a way to jam Bowers at the line. If they don't, he'll catch 10 passes every time they play.
  3. The Mike Vrabel Effect: Watch how the Patriots' discipline improves. Under the previous regime, they were making uncharacteristic mistakes. If Vrabel cleans that up, the Patriots become a much harder out in these close, 7-point games.

The New England Patriots vs Las Vegas Raiders discussions aren't just about football anymore; they're about two franchises trying to find their soul after the greatest era in NFL history ended for one and a decades-long identity crisis continued for the other. Keep an eye on the Raiders' coaching search—it'll tell you everything you need to know about how they'll match up next season.