If you’ve been keeping up with the gaslit streets of Victorian London in Miss Scarlet (formerly Miss Scarlet and the Duke), you know that the departure of William "The Duke" Wellington wasn't the only massive shakeup. We need to talk about Patrick Nash. Specifically, why the slickest, most charismatic rival Eliza Scarlet ever had suddenly vanished across the globe.
Honestly, it feels like a bit of a gut punch. Just as we were getting used to the idea of Eliza navigating a world without the Duke, the show decided to ship her best professional alternative off to Australia.
Nash, played with a sort of roguish perfection by Felix Scott, wasn't just another face in the crowd. He was the only guy who truly looked at Eliza’s career and didn't see a "woman detective"—he just saw a damn good detective.
The Rise and Fall (and Docks) of Patrick Nash
When Patrick Nash first strutted onto the scene in Season 2, he was basically the anti-Duke. While William was all brooding rules and Scotland Yard bureaucracy, Nash was the king of the private sector. He ran London’s most successful private investigator agency, Nash & Sons. And yeah, he was a total jerk at first. He was slippery, a bit sinister, and definitely wasn't above a little light bribery to get what he wanted.
But then something changed.
He didn't just want to beat Eliza; he wanted to hire her. He recognized that they were both "survivors" in a world that didn't particularly want them to succeed. His Irish background gave him that "outsider" edge that mirrored Eliza’s struggle as a woman in a male-dominated field.
👉 See also: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
What happened to him in Season 5?
By the time Season 5 rolled around, things had gone sideways for our favorite mustachioed entrepreneur. Following the chaos of Season 4, where he ended up wanted for an alleged murder, Nash spent the beginning of Season 5 in a place no one expected: behind bars.
In the episode titled "The Deal" (Season 5, Episode 4), we find a very different Nash. He’s in prison, bribing guards for whiskey and trying to charm his way out. When he finally gets released, it’s not to go back to his old life. He’s essentially a man without a country—or at least, a man without a license.
The big twist? To avoid going back to jail and to start fresh, Nash decides to head to the Docks. He's moving to Australia.
He tells Eliza—whom he affectionately calls "Victoria Mars" sometimes when they're bickering—that anything is possible over there. It was a bittersweet goodbye. A hug, a promise that he might be back "probably," and then he was gone.
Why the Fans are Actually Revolting
If you browse any Miss Scarlet subreddit or fan forum, the sentiment is pretty clear: people are frustrated. It’s not just that Nash left; it’s the pattern.
✨ Don't miss: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
First, we lost Rupert. Then Moses (for a while). Then the Duke himself. Now Nash. It feels like the show is clearing the decks to make room for the new Inspector, Alexander Blake. But did they have to lose the best secondary character to do it?
The chemistry between Felix Scott and Kate Phillips was undeniable. It wasn't always romantic—though many "Nash-Scarlet" shippers would disagree—it was a partnership of equals. Nash challenged her. He didn't protect her like a child; he pushed her like a colleague.
The Felix Scott Exit Explained
Behind the scenes, the news broke in early 2025 that Felix Scott would not be returning as a series regular for Season 6. While he made that brief, impactful appearance in Season 5 to wrap up his arc, the actor has moved on to other projects, including the PBS production Miss Austen.
The show’s creators have hinted that Nash will still "cause chaos" from across the globe in Season 6. This suggests he might be mentioned in letters or his agency's remnants might still play a role, but the physical presence of Patrick Nash is, for now, a thing of the past.
Patrick Nash vs. The Duke: Who Was Better for Eliza?
It’s the debate that will never die.
🔗 Read more: Why Grand Funk’s Bad Time is Secretly the Best Pop Song of the 1970s
The Duke was the childhood friend, the "will-they-won't-they" anchor of the show for four seasons. But he also spent half his time trying to talk Eliza out of her job.
Patrick Nash was different. He saw her ambition as an asset.
- He offered her a job when no one else would.
- He trusted her instincts when the Yard laughed at her.
- He never asked her to "settle down" in the traditional sense.
In many ways, Nash represented the future of the show—a version where Eliza could be a professional powerhouse without the constant weight of the Duke’s disapproval. By removing him, the writers have forced Eliza to stand entirely on her own, which is great for her character growth, but kinda lonely for the viewers.
What’s Next for the Nash & Sons Legacy?
With Nash in Australia, what happens to the agency? We saw Eliza taking over much of the workload while he was in "predicaments," and Clarence remains a loyal fixture.
The "chaos from across the globe" mentioned in the Season 6 logline suggests that even from the Southern Hemisphere, Patrick Nash isn't quite done with London. Maybe he sends a case her way. Maybe he sends a telegram that ruins a date with Inspector Blake. We can only hope.
If you're looking to fill the Patrick Nash-shaped hole in your heart, the best thing to do is revisit Season 3, Episode 3, "Hotel St Marc." It’s arguably the best Nash/Scarlet episode, featuring a high-stakes chase in France that perfectly encapsulates why their dynamic worked. No Duke, no Scotland Yard—just two brilliant PIs trying to outsmart each other.
Actionable Insights for Fans
- Watch for Season 6 mentions: Keep an eye on the mail Eliza receives. The writers have confirmed Nash’s "presence" will still be felt.
- Follow Felix Scott’s new work: If you miss that specific brand of charm, check out Miss Austen on PBS Masterpiece.
- The "Moses" Factor: Since Nash is gone, the return of Moses (played by Ansu Kabia) in Season 6 is going to be the main source of "old school" chemistry. Focus your attention there if you’re tired of the new Inspector Blake dynamic.
Patrick Nash might be halfway around the world, but in the world of Victorian detectives, nobody stays gone forever. Australia is a long way away, but a ship ride back only takes a few months. For now, we'll just have to settle for the chaos he causes from afar.