Honestly, it’s getting hard to keep track of the rings. If you’ve spent any time watching football over the last few years, you know that the postseason basically belongs to one guy. Patrick Mahomes has turned the Kansas City Chiefs into a permanent fixture in February. But when we talk about Patrick Mahomes Super Bowls, we often get lost in the highlight reels of sidearm throws and no-look passes. We forget how close some of these games actually were to being disasters.
He isn’t perfect. He’s human.
By the start of 2026, the narrative around Mahomes has shifted from "can he win one?" to "how many can he get before he retires?" It’s a wild conversation to have about a guy who is still essentially in his prime. Most people look at the 3-2 record in the Big Game and see a dynasty. Others look at the losses—especially the heavy one against Tampa Bay or the more recent stumble against the Eagles in Super Bowl LIX—and see the few times the "magic" actually ran out.
The Patrick Mahomes Super Bowls: A Brutal Reality Check
Let’s be real for a second. In Super Bowl LIV, Mahomes was playing pretty badly for three quarters. Two interceptions. The 49ers defense had him in a straightjacket. Then, suddenly, "Jet Chip Wasp" happens on 3rd and 15, and the world changes. That’s the thing about Patrick Mahomes Super Bowls; they aren't usually wire-to-wire blowouts. They are stressful, grit-your-teeth battles where the Chiefs look dead until they aren't.
Mahomes currently sits with three rings from five starts.
He’s beaten the 49ers twice and the Eagles once. He’s also lost to Tom Brady’s Buccaneers and had that rough outing against Jalen Hurts and the Eagles in the 2025 season’s finale. If you’re keeping score at home, that’s a 60% win rate on the biggest stage in sports. For comparison, Joe Montana went 4-0. Terry Bradshaw went 4-0. Tom Brady went 7-3. Mahomes is in the room with the legends, but he’s also shown he can be neutralized if the offensive line decides to take a vacation.
Breaking Down the Wins and the Rings
- Super Bowl LIV (2020) vs. 49ers: The comeback. Down 20-10 with less than seven minutes left. Mahomes wins his first MVP because he refuses to quit.
- Super Bowl LVII (2023) vs. Eagles: The "ankle" game. He was literally limping on one leg and still put up 38 points. No interceptions. Pure efficiency.
- Super Bowl LVIII (2024) vs. 49ers: The overtime thriller. This was the one where he proved he could win even when the offense was "struggling" all year.
The stats in these wins are decent, but they don't tell the full story. He’s thrown for over 1,000 yards in his Super Bowl career already. He’s also got 3 Super Bowl MVPs, which ties him with Joe Montana for second all-time. Only Brady has more with five. That’s a lot of hardware for a guy who hasn't even hit his mid-30s yet.
The Games Where the Magic Failed
It’s sort of taboo to talk about the losses, but they matter. In Super Bowl LV, the Buccaneers didn't just beat the Chiefs; they embarrassed them 31-9. Mahomes was running for his life. Literally. He ran 497 yards before throwing or being sacked in that game due to pressure. It was the first time we saw that even a superhero has a breaking point.
Then there was Super Bowl LIX in 2025.
The Eagles got their revenge. Mahomes threw three touchdowns, but he also had a fumble and was sacked six times. It was his worst performance ever as a scrambler in the playoffs. It proved that if you can keep him in the pocket and take away his deep threats—like a late-career Travis Kelce who was being doubled all night—you can actually make him look like a normal quarterback. Kind of.
Why the Patrick Mahomes Super Bowls Stats are Deceptive
If you just look at a box score, you might think Mahomes is a turnover machine in the big game. He’s got five interceptions across his first four starts. That’s not a great ratio. But if you watch the tape, you see the context. He takes risks because he has to. He’s often playing from behind.
The Chiefs' defense has actually been the unsung hero in several of these. In 2024, the defense kept the 49ers to field goals while Mahomes figured out how to move the ball. Without Steve Spagnuolo’s schemes, Mahomes might only have one or two rings. Football is a team sport, obviously, but we tend to give the QB all the credit or all the blame.
Mahomes’ rushing stats in these games are actually what most people overlook. He averages over 40 rushing yards in his Super Bowl wins. When the passing lanes are clogged, he tucks it and runs. That 26-yard scramble against the Eagles in LVII? That won the game. It wasn't a 50-yard bomb; it was a guy with a bad ankle deciding he wanted it more.
🔗 Read more: Chris Paul 3 Pointers Last Game: What Really Happened in Miami
What’s Left for the Dynasty?
The talk now is about the "Three-Peat" that never happened. Falling short in 2025 against Philly hurt the legacy talk for a minute, but the Chiefs are still the favorites every single September. The roster is changing. Kelce is near the end. The receiving corps is a revolving door of young speedsters.
But as long as #15 is under center, the "Chiefs Kingdom" expects a parade.
To really understand Patrick Mahomes Super Bowls, you have to accept that he isn't going to have a perfect passer rating. He’s going to make a mistake. He’s going to throw a ball into triple coverage once a game. But in the fourth quarter, with two minutes left, there is nobody else on the planet you’d rather have with the ball.
If you're looking to track his progress toward the "GOAT" status, keep an eye on these specific metrics:
- Passer Rating in the 4th Quarter: This is where he usually jumps from a "70" to a "110."
- Sack Percentage: When he gets sacked more than 3 times, his win probability drops by nearly 40%.
- Target Share: See how often he relies on his "safety blanket" versus spreading it out to four or five different guys.
The road to the Hall of Fame is already paved. Now, it's just about how long the pavement is. Whether he catches Brady's seven rings is a tall order, but he’s already passed basically everyone else who ever put on a helmet.
If you want to stay ahead of the curve on the next Chiefs run, start looking at their defensive secondary depth and the health of the interior offensive line. Those are the real factors that determine if Mahomes gets to hold the Lombardi Trophy or ends up watching the confetti fall for someone else. Watch the line play, not just the highlights. That’s where the games are actually won.