Let’s be honest. We’re living in an era where the NFL basically wants every game to end 45-42. The rules are skewed for the offense, the defenders can barely breathe on a receiver without a flag, and yet, when you look at the leaderboard for passing touchdowns all time, there is one name that looks increasingly lonely at the summit.
Tom Brady.
The man finished with 649 regular-season touchdown passes. Think about that number for a second. It's not just a stat; it's a monument to staying healthy and obsessed for over two decades. While the league is faster and more pass-heavy than ever, catching "The GOAT" feels like trying to catch a ghost.
The Immortals: Breaking Down the Top 5
Most people know the names, but the gap between the legends is where the real drama lives. Behind Brady, you’ve got Drew Brees. Brees was a machine in New Orleans, finishing with 571. He was the king of the 5,000-yard season, but even with that ridiculous output, he still fell nearly 80 touchdowns short of Brady.
Then you have Peyton Manning.
✨ Don't miss: Fox NFL Sunday: Why the Original Pregame Show Still Dominates the Airwaves
Peyton is the guy who actually set the single-season bar with 55 touchdowns in 2013 with the Broncos. He ended his career with 539. It’s wild to think that arguably the smartest mind to ever play the position is third on the list, but that just shows you how much longevity matters here.
- Tom Brady: 649
- Drew Brees: 571
- Peyton Manning: 539
- Aaron Rodgers: 527 (and still adding to it)
- Brett Favre: 508
Aaron Rodgers is the fascinating one right now. As of early 2026, he’s sitting at 527. He’s passed Brett Favre, which had to feel good given their history, and he’s within striking distance of Manning. But Rodgers is 42. His "tread on the tires" is a major talking point in every sports bar from Green Bay to New York. Can he get to 550? Probably. Can he get to 649? Honestly, no way.
Why Dan Marino is Still the Most Impressive
If you want to talk about passing touchdowns all time without mentioning Dan Marino, you’re doing it wrong. Marino finished with 420. By today's standards, that's "only" good for 8th all time. Matthew Stafford actually just passed him recently, sitting at 423.
But context is everything.
Marino threw 48 touchdowns in 1984. In 1984! That was a year when defensive backs could basically clothesline you at the line of scrimmage. To do what he did in that era is like running a marathon in combat boots while everyone else is in Nikes. If you dropped 1984 Dan Marino into the 2026 NFL, he’d probably throw for 70 touchdowns. He was the original "video game" quarterback before the game even existed.
The Matthew Stafford Ascent
Speaking of Stafford, he’s the guy nobody talks about who is quietly destroying the record books. He’s currently at 423 touchdowns. He’s 37 years old and just coming off a 2025 season where he led the league with 46 touchdowns.
People used to dismiss him because he was "stuck" in Detroit. But since moving to the Rams, he’s shown that he’s an elite volume passer. If Stafford plays three more high-level seasons—which is totally possible given how protected QBs are now—he could realistically pass Brett Favre for 5th all time. That’s Hall of Fame territory, period.
The Mahomes Problem
Everyone wants to know if Patrick Mahomes will be the one to break the passing touchdowns all time record.
🔗 Read more: Why the Nike Tiger Woods Commercial Still Makes People Uncomfortable
He’s currently sitting at 267. He’s only 30. If you do the math, he’s on pace to get close. Some projections have him finishing around 629 if he plays as many games as Brees or Manning. But here’s the thing: football is violent. To reach Brady, Mahomes doesn't just need to stay elite; he needs to stay there.
Brady didn't just have talent; he had a weird, avocado-ice-cream-fueled durability that defied biology. Mahomes is mobile. He takes hits. He scrambles. Every time he tweaks an ankle, that 649 number feels a little further away.
The Evolution of the Score
It’s funny to look back at the guys who used to own this record. Johnny Unitas held it for forever with 290. Fran Tarkenton pushed it to 342. When Marino hit 420, we thought the ceiling had been reached.
Now, if a quarterback doesn't throw 30 touchdowns a year, they’re considered a "game manager." The floor has been raised. We’re seeing guys like Josh Allen (220) and Joe Flacco (272) climb the ranks because the league is designed for the ball to be in the air.
But even with the extra 17th game and the pass-happy rules, the passing touchdowns all time record requires a specific mix of:
- Starting as a rookie or shortly after.
- Playing for a coach who trusts you in the red zone.
- Avoiding the one "big" injury that ends a career.
- Having a death-grip-like obsession with the game into your 40s.
What to Watch For Next
If you’re a stat nerd, keep your eyes on the "Active Leaders" list. Aaron Rodgers is chasing Manning. Matthew Stafford is chasing Favre. And way down the list, guys like Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen are trying to build the foundation for a run at the top three.
The reality? We might never see 649 topped. It’s not just about being good; it’s about being lucky and stubborn for 23 years.
🔗 Read more: Why Ratings for First Take Keep Defying the Gravity of Cable TV
Next Steps for Fans
If you want to see history, don't just look at the totals. Watch the "Touchdown Percentage" of these players. It tells you who was most efficient, not just who played the longest. You should also check out the Pro Football Hall of Fame’s updated tracking for the 2026 season to see where the current crop of stars lands after the playoffs.