Television deaths usually feel like a cheap ploy for ratings, but when Pam Ferris Call the Midwife ended its run with the passing of Sister Evangelina, it felt like losing a member of the family. You probably remember where you were when it happened. I definitely do. The East End was a colder place without her blunt, no-nonsense bark.
Fans were gutted. Honestly, "gutted" barely covers it. Social media back then was just a sea of people crying over a pair of old, worn-out shoes left behind in a hallway. It was one of the most poignant exits in British TV history, but behind the scenes, the reasons for Pam Ferris leaving were far more practical than the dramatic on-screen tragedy suggested.
The Brutal Reality of Being Sister Evangelina
Pam Ferris didn't just play a nun; she inhabited a woman who had seen the absolute worst of humanity and responded with a stern, holy pragmatism. Sister Evangelina was the only nun at Nonnatus House who came from the same rough background as the people she served. She wasn't an aristocrat playing at charity. She was the real deal.
But playing the real deal is exhausting.
By 2016, Ferris had been with the show since its very first episode in 2012. Four years sounds like a short time, but the production schedule for a high-budget period drama is a monster. We’re talking long hours in cold locations and the physical toll of a very specific, very restrictive costume.
📖 Related: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
It wasn't just about the acting
Behind the scenes, the move to a new production set in Surrey created a massive logistical headache. Apparently, the new location made her commute a nightmare. Ferris lives in Elham, Kent, and the travel started eating into her life.
She's gone on record saying that making the decision to leave was a "wrench," which is actor-speak for "it was really hard to quit." But she also admitted that she missed her dogs. That’s relatable. Most of us wouldn't trade 14-hour days in a wimple for more time with our pets if we didn't have to.
And then there was the wimple itself.
Ferris mentioned in interviews that while she loved her habit because it was "well-worn and comfortable," she absolutely loathed the wimple. It made it incredibly difficult to hear the other actors. Imagine trying to perform a high-stakes medical scene where a baby's life is on the line, and you can't hear your scene partner because you're wrapped in layers of stiff fabric. It’s a recipe for burnout.
👉 See also: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Why the Character Had to Die
Some shows send characters off to a "sister convent" in another city. They leave the door open for a guest appearance or a Christmas special. Call the Midwife didn't do that with Evangelina. They chose a permanent, heart-shattering end.
Why the permanent exit?
- Integrity of the Story: Evangelina would never have left Poplar. She belonged to the streets of the East End. Having her "retire" to the countryside would have felt like a betrayal of everything the character stood for.
- The Emotional Stake: The show needed a way to transition into the mid-60s. Her death served as a bridge, forcing the other characters—specifically Sister Monica Joan—to grow in ways we hadn't seen before.
- A "Good" Death: She died in her sleep after a second stroke, sitting in her favorite chair. For a woman who spent her life in the chaos of birth and poverty, it was a rare moment of peace.
The impact was massive. I still see people on Reddit threads today—years after the fact—talking about "the shoe scene." If you know, you know. When Fred Buckle finds her and later, when her simple shoes are placed by the door, it’s a masterclass in visual storytelling.
Life After Nonnatus House
A lot of people think actors disappear after they leave a hit show, but Pam Ferris has been working since the 80s. She was Ma Larkin in The Darling Buds of May. She was the terrifying Miss Trunchbull in Matilda. She even floated away as Aunt Marge in Harry Potter.
She didn't leave because she was "done" with acting. She left because she was selective. She’s mentioned that the pace of television has sped up so much that it's hard to find "real quality work" anymore. She wanted to be the best 70-year-old she could be, which meant fulfilling herself outside of a grueling filming schedule.
✨ Don't miss: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
The Legacy of the Character
Sister Evangelina wasn't always "nice." She was a bully sometimes. She was an "inverted snob" who looked down on people with money. But she was also the one you’d want in the room if things went sideways during a delivery. She had a robust sense of humor—remember the farting scene in season one? It grounded the show. It made the holiness of the nuns feel human.
When we talk about Pam Ferris Call the Midwife, we’re talking about a performance that defined an era of the show. She wasn't just a supporting character; she was the grit in the oyster.
What to Do if You’re Missing Sister Evangelina
If you're feeling that Nonnatus-shaped hole in your heart, there are a few ways to revisit Ferris's work without just hitting "replay" on Season 5.
- Watch "Rosemary & Thyme": It’s the total opposite of the East End. It’s cozy, it’s green, and she gets to be a gardening sleuth alongside Felicity Kendal.
- Revisit "Matilda": It’s still wild to think that the woman who lovingly bathed babies in Poplar is the same woman who threw a girl by her pigtails. That's the range of a legend.
- Read the Books: Jennifer Worth’s original memoirs provide even more background on the real-life inspirations for the sisters. Evangelina was based on a real person, and the books dive into the "fearless" nature that Ferris captured so perfectly.
The show has continued for many seasons since she left, but there's a certain weight that left with her. You can't replace that kind of screen presence. You just have to appreciate that we got five years of it.
Actionable Insight: If you're a fan of the show's early years, focus your rewatch on the evolving relationship between Sister Evangelina and Sister Monica Joan. It’s the true heart of the first five seasons, representing the clash—and eventually the bond—between the practical and the poetic.