You’re halfway through a set of back squats, the weight feels fine, but then—pop. Or maybe it isn’t a pop. Maybe it’s just this annoying, tight, "full" sensation right in the pit of your leg. It feels like someone stuffed a golf ball into the back of your knee joint. You try to stretch it out, but nothing reaches it. Dealing with pain behind knee when squatting is honestly one of the most frustrating setbacks for anyone trying to stay active. It’s a literal bottleneck.
The posterior knee is a crowded neighborhood. You’ve got the gastrocnemius (calf) heads, the hamstrings, the popliteus muscle, the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), and various bursae all fighting for space. When you descend into a deep squat, the joint compression increases. If something is inflamed or torn, that compression screams at you. It’s not always a "stop immediately" kind of pain, which is why so many people make it worse by training through it for months.
The Baker’s Cyst: The Squat Destroyer
If you feel a localized swelling that makes it hard to fully flex your knee, you’re likely looking at a Baker’s Cyst. It’s also called a popliteal cyst. Weirdly enough, the cyst itself usually isn't the primary problem. It’s a symptom. When your knee joint is irritated—maybe from a meniscus tear or some early-stage osteoarthritis—it produces too much synovial fluid. This fluid has to go somewhere, so it bulges into the popliteal bursa.
Think of it like a safety valve.
When you squat, that fluid-filled sac gets pinched. It’s called the "Foucher Sign." If the pain gets significantly worse when you try to touch your butt to your heels but eases up when your leg is straight, that’s a classic indicator. Dr. Robert LaPrade, a world-renowned complex knee surgeon, often notes that treating the cyst without fixing the intra-articular issue inside the knee is basically a waste of time. It’ll just fill back up.
Is it Your Popliteus? The "Key" to the Knee
Most lifters have never even heard of the popliteus. It’s a tiny, thin muscle that sits deep in the back of the knee. Its main job is to "unlock" the knee from a fully extended position by internally rotating the tibia. Basically, it’s the key that starts the engine of a squat.
✨ Don't miss: Horizon Treadmill 7.0 AT: What Most People Get Wrong
If you have pain behind knee when squatting specifically during the first few inches of the movement, or right as you’re coming out of the hole, the popliteus might be strained. This usually happens because of "screw-home" mechanism issues or if you’re someone who tends to let your knees cave in (valgus collapse). Overuse can lead to popliteus tendinopathy. It feels deep. You can’t really massage it yourself because the neurovascular bundle—the big nerves and arteries—is sitting right on top of it.
Meniscus Tears: The Posterior Horn
Not all meniscus tears happen on the side of the knee. A tear in the posterior horn of the medial meniscus is a very common culprit for posterior pain. This is especially true for CrossFitters or Olympic lifters who spend a lot of time in deep flexion. When you go into a deep squat, the femur rolls back on the tibia, putting massive pressure on that back part of the meniscus.
If it’s a meniscus issue, you might notice:
- A mechanical clicking or catching.
- The sensation that the knee is "giving way."
- Pain that gets sharper as you add weight.
- Morning stiffness that takes ten minutes to walk off.
The "Goldthwait’s test" or "McMurray’s test" are things a physical therapist will do to check this, but honestly, a lot of people just know something is wrong deep inside the joint. It doesn't feel like a muscle pull. It feels like a bone-on-bone pinch.
Distal Hamstring Tendinopathy
Then we have the hamstrings. You have two main groups: the lateral (biceps femoris) and the medial (semimembranosus and semitendinosus). They attach right around the back of the knee. If you’ve been doing a ton of heavy RDLs or leg curls and then try to squat, you might have developed a tendinopathy.
🔗 Read more: How to Treat Uneven Skin Tone Without Wasting a Fortune on TikTok Trends
This usually feels like a dull ache that "warms up." It might hurt during your first warm-up set of empty bar squats, go away during your working sets, and then come back with a vengeance the next morning. It’s a classic "overuse" injury. You’ve exceeded the load capacity of the tendon, and now it’s protesting the compression it faces at the bottom of the squat.
The Nerve Factor: Tibial Nerve Irritation
Sometimes, the pain isn't a muscle or a ligament at all. It’s neurological. The tibial nerve runs right through the popliteal fossa. If you have a lot of swelling or if your calves are insanely tight, you can actually get some nerve entrapment. This usually feels more like a zing, a burn, or a tingle rather than a dull ache.
Why You Can’t Just "Stretch It Out"
We’ve been conditioned to think that if something hurts, we should stretch it. That is often the worst thing you can do for pain behind knee when squatting. If you have a Baker's Cyst or a meniscus tear, aggressive stretching just increases the internal pressure. You’re essentially trying to stretch a joint that is already swollen and irritated.
Instead, you need to look at your ankle mobility. If your ankles are stiff, your knees have to travel further forward to keep you upright, which changes the sheer forces in the joint.
Improving Your Squat Mechanics
If the pain is mild, you don't necessarily need to stop squatting. You need to modify.
💡 You might also like: My eye keeps twitching for days: When to ignore it and when to actually worry
- Limit Depth: Stop just shy of the point where the pain starts. For some, this means squatting to a box.
- Change the Load: Switch from a low-bar back squat to a front squat or a Goblet squat. This keeps your torso more upright and often reduces the "pinching" sensation in the back of the knee.
- Check Your Foot Angle: Sometimes turning your toes out slightly can clear space in the joint and take pressure off the posterior horn of the meniscus.
- Slow Down: Use a 3-second eccentric (lowering) phase. This forces the muscles to stabilize the joint rather than relying on the "bounce" at the bottom which can aggravate the popliteus.
Real-World Recovery Steps
If you’re dealing with this right now, here is a practical checklist of what to actually do. First, stop testing it. Don't keep squatting into pain just to see if it's still there. You're just picking a scab.
Address the Soft Tissue (The Right Way)
Instead of stretching the back of the knee, use a foam roller or a lacrosse ball on your calves and your hamstrings (the fleshy parts, not the back of the knee itself). Releasing the tension in the calf can sometimes decompress the popliteal space enough to provide instant relief.
Isometrics are King
Tendons love isometrics. Try a wall sit where your knees are at a 45-degree angle (not a full 90 if it hurts). Hold for 30–45 seconds. This creates an analgesic effect—it basically numbs the pain—and helps rebuild the load-bearing capacity of the tendons without the aggressive compression of a full squat.
Identify the "Why"
Are you wearing old shoes? Did you suddenly double your squat volume? Most of these issues come down to a "too much, too soon" error. If the pain is accompanied by significant swelling that you can actually see, go see a sports med doc. You might need an ultrasound to confirm a Baker's Cyst or an MRI for a meniscus tear.
The Progression Back
Once the sharp pain subsides, don't jump back to your 1-rep max. Start with terminal knee extensions (TKEs) using a resistance band. This strengthens the vastus medialis (VMO) and helps the knee track properly. From there, move to box squats, then eventually back to full-depth squats.
Dealing with pain behind knee when squatting is a signal that your mechanics or your recovery has slipped. Listen to it. Ignoring a "full" feeling in the back of your knee is a fast track to a long-term injury that could require surgery.
Essential Actionable Next Steps
- Test your ankle dorsiflexion: Stand five inches from a wall and see if you can touch your knee to the wall without your heel lifting. If you can't, your ankle stiffness is likely destroying your knee health.
- Film your squat from the side: Look for "butt wink" or a sudden shift in weight toward your toes at the bottom. This shift puts massive stress on the posterior knee structures.
- Implement "Spanish Squats": Use a heavy band behind your knees anchored to a rack. Lean back and squat. This is a gold-standard rehab exercise for patellar and posterior knee issues because it offloads the joint while firing the quads.
- Swap your footwear: If you're squatting in running shoes with a squishy heel, stop. The instability is forcing your popliteus and deep stabilizers to work overtime. Switch to a flat sole or a dedicated weightlifting shoe with a hard heel.
- Monitor for Night Pain: If your knee throbs at night or hurts while you're just sitting on the couch, that's a sign of high-level inflammation. Take a full week off from lower-body lifting and focus on non-weight-bearing movement like swimming or easy cycling to flush the joint.