Ever watched a game that felt like a chess match played at a track meet? That’s basically the vibe when Pachuca and the New York Red Bulls share a pitch. It’s not just about Liga MX vs. MLS bragging rights anymore. It’s about two very different philosophies of soccer clashing head-on in a way that makes your head spin.
Honestly, the Pachuca vs NY Red Bulls matchup is one of those fixtures that "purists" sometimes overlook because it doesn't have the 100-year history of a derby. But if you've been paying attention to the Leagues Cup or the Champions Cup lately, you know these two teams produce some of the most chaotic, tactically intense football in North America.
What Actually Went Down in Their Last Meeting
If you missed their 2024 Leagues Cup clash, you missed a weird one. Seriously. The Red Bulls are known for that "Energy Drink" style—high press, suffocating defense, and basically trying to make the opponent miserable for 90 minutes. Pachuca, on the other hand, usually wants to play. They want the ball.
The game at Red Bull Arena ended 1-1 in regulation. Elias Manoel scored for New York early in the second half, and for a minute, it looked like the Red Bulls' system was going to break the Tuzos. But then Salomón Rondón happened. The man is a tank. He found the equalizer in the 56th minute, and the game eventually spiraled into a penalty shootout.
Pachuca won that shootout 5-4. It was a classic "Mexican team survives the storm" scenario. But the stats told a different story. The Red Bulls actually outshot Pachuca 19 to 6. They had more clear-cut chances, but Pachuca had the composure when it mattered.
Why the Tactical Clash is So Addictive
The Red Bulls under Sandro Schwarz play this very specific brand of soccer. They don't care about possession. In that last match, they only had about 36% of the ball. Most teams would be panicking with those numbers. For New York? That’s exactly where they want to be. They want you to have the ball so they can take it from you in dangerous spots.
Pachuca is different. Guillermo Almada has built a team that relies heavily on youth and technical skill. They have one of the best academies in the world (seriously, look at the players they've produced like Chucky Lozano or Héctor Herrera). When they face a pressing machine like the Red Bulls, it becomes a test of "can our kids pass through the chaos?"
💡 You might also like: National Football League Rosters: What Most People Get Wrong
The "Rondón Factor" and Roster Realities
You can't talk about Pachuca vs NY Red Bulls without mentioning Salomón Rondón. He’s the focal point. At 35, he’s still bullying MLS defenders who are ten years younger than him. He’s the reason Pachuca doesn’t always need 20 shots to score. Give him one half-chance, and it’s in the back of the net.
On the New York side, they’ve been dealing with some annoying injury luck lately. Emil Forsberg—their big marquee signing—has been in and out of the lineup. When he’s on the field, the Red Bulls have a level of creativity they usually lack. Without him, they’re a bit more one-dimensional, relying on Lewis Morgan to do basically everything in transition.
Surprising Things You Might Not Know
- Pachuca is old-school: They were founded in 1901. That makes them one of the oldest clubs in the Americas.
- The Red Bulls are consistent: They have the longest active playoff streak in North American sports. It's actually kind of insane when you think about how much the league has changed.
- Geography matters: Playing in Pachuca (the city) means dealing with an altitude of about 8,000 feet. When the Red Bulls have to go there, their high-pressing style usually falls apart by the 60th minute because nobody can breathe.
What to Watch for in the Next Matchup
If these two meet again in the 2026 season—perhaps in a revamped continental tournament or another Leagues Cup—keep an eye on the midfield.
Pachuca has been integrating guys like Nelson Deossa, who is a physical marvel. He’s one of the few players who can actually match the Red Bulls' intensity in the middle of the park. If New York can't win those second balls, they're in trouble.
Also, watch the coaching battle. Schwarz and Almada are both "system" coaches. They don't really adjust their styles for anyone. It's a game of chicken to see who blinks first.
Real Insights for the Smart Fan
Don't just look at the final score next time. Look at the "Pressing Efficiency" stats. If the Red Bulls are winning the ball back in the final third more than five times a half, Pachuca is going to struggle to build out. If Pachuca completes more than 85% of their passes, it means they've bypassed the press and are probably going to find Rondón for a tap-in.
The rivalry is growing. It’s gritty. It’s loud. And frankly, it’s exactly what North American soccer needs more of.
Next Steps for the Dedicated Follower:
- Check the official MLS and Liga MX injury reports 48 hours before kickoff; the availability of Forsberg or Rondón shifts the betting odds by a massive margin.
- If the game is at Red Bull Arena, favor the Red Bulls on the "Total Shots" market; their system almost guarantees high volume regardless of the score.
- Watch the first 15 minutes closely—if Pachuca survives the initial New York "blitz" without conceding, they usually settle in and control the tempo for the rest of the match.