Basketball is a game of "what-ifs." Honestly, if you're a fan of the Blue and Gold, you've probably spent the last seven months replaying the first quarter of June 22, 2025, in your head. It’s that one moment. The one where the collective breath of Indianapolis just... stopped.
The Pacers vs OKC Game 7 wasn't just a basketball game. It was a collision of two small-market titans that shouldn't have been there according to the "experts," and it ended in a way that still feels sort of surreal. We all saw the headlines: Oklahoma City Thunder 103, Indiana Pacers 91. The Thunder got their first ring since moving from Seattle. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (SGA) cemented his legacy as a superstar.
But the box score is a liar. It doesn't tell you about the silence in the Paycom Center when Tyrese Haliburton hit the floor. It doesn't capture how close Rick Carlisle's squad actually came to pulling off the impossible without their engine.
The Injury That Changed Everything
Let's talk about the elephant in the room. About five minutes into the first quarter, Tyrese Haliburton was cooking. He’d already splashed three triples. The Pacers were up by five and looked like they were going to run the Thunder right out of their own building. Then, a non-contact drive. A scream. A slap of the hardwood.
💡 You might also like: 2025 US Open tennis schedule: Why This Year's New Format Changes Everything
It was a torn right Achilles.
Just like that, the best individual playoff run in Pacers history was over. Haliburton had been playing through a calf strain the whole series, basically duct-taping himself together to keep Indiana’s "track meet" offense running. When he went down, the energy in the building shifted from competitive fire to something that felt more like a funeral.
Most people think the Pacers folded right then. They didn't.
Indiana actually led 48-47 at the half. That’s the part everyone forgets. Bennedict Mathurin came off the bench and played like a man possessed, finishing with 24 points and 13 boards. T.J. McConnell was everywhere. It was gritty, ugly, and totally Indiana. But you can only hold back a 68-win juggernaut like OKC for so long when you're missing your All-NBA playmaker.
Why the Thunder Finally Broke Through
Oklahoma City’s Game 7 victory was a masterclass in "staying the course." While Indiana was scrambling to reinvent their offense on the fly, Mark Daigneault’s group just kept doing what they’ve done all year. They moved the ball. They defended without fouling. Well, mostly.
The SGA Factor
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander is a different breed. He finished with 29 points and a playoff career-high 12 assists. But it was his composure that killed the Pacers. Every time Indiana made a mini-run in the second half, Shai would just get to his spot, draw a foul, or find Jalen Williams for a dagger.
Chet’s Defensive Wall
Chet Holmgren’s stat line of 18 points and 8 rebounds is solid, but the 5 blocks? That’s the Game 7 record. He made the paint a "no-fly zone" for Pascal Siakam and McConnell. Every time the Pacers tried to generate momentum at the rim, Chet was there to swat it into the third row.
The Third Quarter Avalanche
The game was won in the third. OKC outscored Indiana 34-20 in that frame. Jalen Williams, who had that monster 40-point game earlier in the series, dropped 9 in the third alone. By the time the fourth quarter started, the Pacers were down 81-68 and looked like they were running on fumes.
The Controversy Nobody Talks About
If you go into any Pacers message board right now, you’ll hear about the officiating. Is it sour grapes? Kinda. But there's a legitimate gripe there.
During a crucial stretch in the fourth, the whistle felt... lopsided. T.J. McConnell was getting hounded by Alex Caruso, and while Caruso is an elite defender, there were at least three "no-calls" where McConnell clearly got hacked on the wrist. On the other end, the Thunder were living at the free-throw line.
Rick Carlisle was nearly ejected in the final minutes after a particularly questionable call on a Mathurin transition drive. When you lose by 12 and the turnover battle is 21-7 against you, you can't blame the refs for everything. But for a game of this magnitude, the lack of consistency in the second half definitely left a bitter taste in the mouths of Pacer fans.
The Small Market Milestone
One thing that gets lost in the SGA vs. Haliburton narrative is that this was the "Smallest NBA Finals" ever.
Between Indianapolis (22nd market) and Oklahoma City (26th), the media giants were panicking about ratings. But for real basketball fans, it was the first Finals since 2002 without a luxury tax team. It proved that you don't need a $200 million payroll or a New York zip code to build a champion. You just need a Sam Presti or a Kevin Pritchard who knows how to draft.
Real Insights for the 2026 Season
The ripples of Pacers vs OKC Game 7 are still being felt today.
📖 Related: Who Actually Won? Real Chiefs Winners and Losers From the Recent Run
- The Haliburton Absence: Since that night, Tyrese hasn't seen the floor. His Achilles recovery has sidelined him for the entire 2025-26 campaign so far. The Pacers are currently fighting for a play-in spot, a far cry from the Finals stage.
- The OKC Dynasty: This win wasn't a fluke. The Thunder were the second-youngest team in history to win a title. With the assets they still have, they aren't going anywhere.
- Draft Strategy: Every GM in the league is now trying to mimic the OKC model—stockpiling wings like Jalen Williams and Cason Wallace who can play multiple positions and defend at a high level.
If you want to understand the current state of the NBA, you have to look at the tape of that Game 7. It was the night the "old guard" of the league finally gave way to the era of Shai and the Thunder.
To truly grasp the impact of this series, watch the replay of the third quarter—specifically how OKC utilized Chet Holmgren as a secondary playmaker. If you're looking for actionable ways to analyze the upcoming 2026 playoffs, keep a close eye on turnover differentials; Indiana's 21 turnovers in Game 7 are the primary reason they aren't wearing rings today.