Let's talk about the mustache. Or, more specifically, the man behind it. When Orange Is the New Black first dropped on Netflix back in 2013, nobody really knew it would change the way we watch TV forever. It was a massive experiment. But amidst the sea of orange jumpsuits and heartbreaking backstories, one guy stood out for all the wrong reasons. George "Pornstache" Mendez.
He was the guy we all loved to hate. Actually, mostly just hate. But Pablo Schreiber, the actor who lived inside that creepy uniform, did something almost impossible. He took a character who was—on paper—a complete monster and turned him into one of the most memorable figures in prestige TV history. Honestly, it’s been years since the show ended, and people are still talking about his performance.
The Birth of a Villain (and a Mustache)
It wasn't supposed to be this big. Pablo Schreiber actually worked with Jenji Kohan before on Weeds, and she basically called him up for a "little part." She asked him to come in and try on a mustache. That was it. He didn't even have a full character arc at first; he’d only read the pilot script.
Schreiber, being the kind of actor who leans into the weird, didn't just put on a fake lip-warmer. He brought a photo of Dolph Lundgren from Rocky IV and told the hair team, "Give me the flattop." He wanted that hyper-aggressive, 80s-villain energy. It worked. Maybe too well.
👉 See also: Who Plays JJ in Criminal Minds? The Surprising Career of A.J. Cook
The character was officially George Mendez, but the inmates called him "Pornstache." He was corrupt. He was a drug smuggler. He was a predator. He was basically everything wrong with the prison industrial complex wrapped in a thin layer of grease and overconfidence. Yet, Schreiber found a way to make him weirdly human, even if that humanity was deeply, deeply warped.
Why Pablo Schreiber in Orange Is the New Black Was Genius Casting
If you’ve seen Schreiber lately—maybe as Master Chief in Halo or as the massive Mad Sweeney in American Gods—you know he’s a big guy. He’s 6'4" and physically imposing. In Orange Is the New Black, he used that height to bully the inmates, but he also used it to show how pathetic Mendez was.
There's this nuance to his performance that most people miss. He played Mendez with this desperate, crushing loneliness. Remember the "Tall Men With Feelings" episode? He’s at a bar with John Bennett, and he basically admits he feels like a sex object. It’s hilarious because he’s a terrible person, but it’s also a glimpse into the insecurity that drives his abuse of power.
📖 Related: Saved by the Bell Map: The Truth About Bayside High's Impossible Architecture
Schreiber has always said that to make an unsympathetic character believable, you have to find their insecurity. For Mendez, it was the need to be loved. That’s why he fell so hard for Daya’s "setup." He was so desperate for a connection that he believed—truly believed—that an inmate he was harassing was actually in love with him.
The Departure: Why Did He Leave?
A lot of fans were shocked when Mendez vanished after the first few seasons. He popped up for cameos later, sure, but his run as a regular antagonist ended fairly early. Why?
Basically, it was a career move. Pablo Schreiber wasn't a series regular on OITNB; he was a guest star. When HBO came knocking with a starring role in the comedy The Brink alongside Jack Black and Tim Robbins, he took it. He called it a "no-brainer" for his career. Can you blame him? Moving from a guest spot to a lead on an HBO show is the dream.
But his exit was iconic. Being led out in handcuffs while screaming his "love" for Daya and her unborn baby (which wasn't even his) was the perfect ending for a character who lived in a total delusion.
The Legacy of Pornstache
You’ve probably seen the "unpopular opinion" threads on Reddit. Some people argue that Mendez was actually "better" than Bennett because he stayed to raise the baby in the end.
Let's be clear: Mendez was a sociopath. He framed Tricia for her own death. He was a monster. But the fact that fans even have these debates proves how good Schreiber was. He didn't play a cartoon. He played a man with a specific, twisted internal logic.
Today, Schreiber is a massive star, often playing heroes or complex warriors. But for a whole generation of binge-watchers, he’ll always be the guy who made us check our locks and cringe at the sight of a chevron mustache.
What You Should Do Next
If you want to see the full range of what Pablo Schreiber can do beyond Litchfield, here is your watchlist:
- The Wire (Season 2): He plays Nick Sobotka. It’s a totally different vibe—vulnerable, blue-collar, and tragic.
- American Gods: Watch him as Mad Sweeney. He’s huge, loud, and incredible.
- Halo: If you want to see him as the ultimate "good guy" (mostly), check out his take on Master Chief.
- Defending Jacob: He plays a prosecutor here, and it’s a great reminder that he can be terrifying even without the facial hair.
Honestly, go back and re-watch Season 1 of Orange Is the New Black. Pay attention to how Schreiber uses his eyes. Even when he’s saying the most disgusting things, there’s a flicker of a little boy who just wants someone to like him. It’s masterclass acting in a role that could have been a joke.
The character of George Mendez remains a textbook example of how a talented actor can elevate a "villain" role into something that defines an entire era of television. Pablo Schreiber didn't just play a prison guard; he created a cultural touchstone that still sparks debate over ten years later.