Politics in Pennsylvania never really takes a day off. You'd think after the absolute marathon of a presidential cycle, everyone would want to just sit on their porch and forget the word "ballot" exists. But that's not how the Keystone State works. If it’s an odd-numbered year, it’s a municipal year. And honestly, the PA primary election 2025 might be one of the most underrated dates on the calendar for anyone who actually cares about how their daily life functions.
Most people blow off the primaries. They think, "Oh, it's just local stuff." Big mistake.
In Pennsylvania, the May primary is where the real power is often decided, especially in areas where one party dominates. If you live in a deep blue city or a bright red township, the person who wins in May is basically measuring for drapes in November. This year, the stakes weren't just about trash collection or school tax rates—though those are huge—they were about the very courts that decide how our laws are interpreted for the next decade.
The Mid-May Scramble: Why the PA Primary Election 2025 Caught People Off Guard
The date was May 20, 2025. It felt like summer was already kicking down the door, but the turnout numbers told a different story. Pennsylvania remains one of the few states with a closed primary system. Basically, if you aren't registered as a Democrat or a Republican, you're sitting on the sidelines for the candidate races. You only get to weigh in on ballot questions or special elections.
A lot of voters find this frustrating. You've got nearly a million independent or third-party voters in PA who basically have to wait until November to have a say in the "big" names. But for the party faithful, May 20 was the day to settle some internal scores.
🔗 Read more: The Night the Mountain Fell: What Really Happened During the Big Thompson Flood 1976
The Judicial Heavyweights
We had some massive seats open on the intermediate appellate courts. These aren't the "sexy" races you see on CNN, but the Superior Court and Commonwealth Court handle the vast majority of legal appeals in this state.
- Superior Court: This is where your criminal and civil appeals go. On the Democratic side, Brandon Neuman—a judge from Washington County and former state rep—sailed through. The GOP side was more of a scrap, with Maria Battista eventually coming out on top against Ann Marie Wheatcraft.
- Commonwealth Court: This court is unique to PA. It handles cases involving the government. Think election law, environmental regulations, and labor disputes. Stella Tsai, a Philadelphia judge with a "Highly Recommended" rating from the Bar Association, cleared the Democratic field. The Republican primary was a real showdown between Erie’s Matthew Wolford and gun-rights attorney Joshua Prince. Wolford, who the state party really got behind, ended up taking the win with about 62% of the vote.
What Really Happened in the Big Cities?
If you want to see where the "vibe" of the state is shifting, you look at Pittsburgh and Philly. In Pittsburgh, the mayoral primary was the main event. Ed Gainey, the incumbent, found himself in a dogfight with Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor.
It was a classic "progressive vs. establishment" clash that we see playing out in every major American city right now. O'Connor had the funding, but Gainey has that grassroots energy that's hard to bet against. Meanwhile, over in Philadelphia, the District Attorney’s race saw Larry Krasner doing what Krasner does—driving his critics crazy while maintaining a solid grip on his base.
The "Silent" Power: School Boards and Local Tax Collectors
It’s kinda wild that we spend so much time talking about the Supreme Court and almost no time talking about the people who decide what your kids learn or how much your property taxes go up.
💡 You might also like: The Natascha Kampusch Case: What Really Happened in the Girl in the Cellar True Story
In the PA primary election 2025, school board races were again a frontline for the "culture wars." We saw a massive push in suburban counties like Bucks and Chester. Some groups were focused on "parental rights" and book removals, while others were pushing back to keep the status quo.
What’s interesting is that in several districts, we saw cross-filing. This is a weird PA quirk where a candidate can run on both the Democratic and Republican tickets for school board or judge. If they win both, they're essentially unopposed in the fall. It's a savvy move, but it makes the primary even more high-stakes because the whole election can literally be over by 9:00 PM in May.
Deadlines That Almost Everyone Misses
Every year, people wake up on Primary Day and realize they forgot to request their mail-in ballot. Pennsylvania’s rules are pretty strict:
- You had to be registered by May 5.
- Your mail-in application had to be in by May 13.
- The ballot itself had to be at the county office by 8:00 PM on May 20.
Postmarks? They don't count here. If your ballot is sitting in a USPS sorting facility at 8:01 PM on election night, it’s basically a piece of expensive scrap paper. This "received by" rule is a frequent point of litigation and something that causes a ton of headaches for voters every single cycle.
📖 Related: The Lawrence Mancuso Brighton NY Tragedy: What Really Happened
Why Should You Care Now?
You might think, "Okay, the primary is over, why are we talking about this?" Because the primary sets the table for everything that happens in the November 4, 2025 general election.
The winners of these May brawls are the ones now vying for 10-year terms on the bench. They are the ones who will be deciding zoning laws in your backyard or how the 2026 and 2028 elections are conducted. The PA primary election 2025 wasn't a standalone event; it was the filter.
If you weren't happy with the choices on your November ballot, the time to fix that was back in May. That’s the hard truth of Pennsylvania politics. The state’s "closed" system means the parties have a massive amount of control over who even makes it to the final round.
Actionable Insights for PA Voters
The 2025 cycle is moving toward the finish line, but the lessons are the same every time. If you want to actually have an impact on the next cycle, here is what you need to do:
- Check Your Registration Early: Don't wait until the two-week deadline. Go to the PA Voter Services website and make sure your address is current. If you moved and didn't update it, you're going to have a bad time at the polls.
- Re-evaluate Your Party Affiliation: If you’re an Independent and you’re tired of being locked out of the primary, you have to change your registration to a major party. You can always change it back after the primary, but that’s the only way to vote for candidates in May.
- Read the Bar Association Ratings: When it comes to judges, don't just vote for the name that sounds familiar. The Pennsylvania Bar Association does deep dives into these candidates. They rate them as "Highly Recommended," "Recommended," or "Not Recommended." It's one of the few non-partisan tools we have to vet people who will hold power for a decade.
- Track Your Mail-in Ballot: If you use the mail-in system, use the state's tracking tool. It tells you when your ballot was mailed, when it was received, and if it was recorded. If it’s getting close to the deadline and it hasn't shown up as "received," you can go to your county election office and get a replacement or vote via provisional ballot at your polling place.
The PA primary election 2025 proved once again that while the turnout might be lower than a presidential year, the consequences are just as permanent. Staying informed isn't just about reading the headlines; it's about knowing the mechanics of the system so you don't get left behind.