You’ve finally narrowed it down. The round brilliant felt too traditional, and the emerald cut was a bit too "hall of mirrors" for your taste. Then you saw it: the oval. It’s elegant, it elongates the finger, and it looks way bigger than its actual carat weight. But then you hold it under the light and see a dark, shadowy stretch across the center. It looks exactly like a black bow tie. Suddenly, that "perfect" stone feels a bit... broken?
The truth about an oval diamond with bow tie is that it’s not actually a flaw in the carbon. It’s a physics problem. Honestly, if you’re looking for a large-facet elongated cut like an oval, marquise, or pear, you are going to encounter this phenomenon. It is almost unavoidable. The real trick isn’t finding a diamond without a bow tie—it’s finding one where the bow tie doesn’t ruin the vibe of the stone.
Why Does My Diamond Have a Shadow?
Light is a fickle thing. When a diamond is cut, the goal is to bounce light off the internal facets and back up to your eye. We call this "light return." In a round diamond, the symmetry is perfect, so the light bounces around like a pinball and comes right back at you.
Ovals are different. Because they are elongated, the facets in the middle of the stone are shallower than the facets at the ends. When light enters the center of an oval diamond with bow tie, it sometimes passes straight through the bottom or gets trapped because of the angle of your head. Your own head and shoulders are actually blocking the light from entering the stone at that specific angle. You are seeing your own shadow reflected back at you.
It’s basically a glitch in the way the diamond handles light.
Some people will tell you that a bow tie is a sign of a "bad" diamond. That's a bit of an oversimplification. In fact, a very slight bow tie can actually give an oval diamond its character and contrast. Without any contrast at all, a diamond can look "mushy" or dull, like a piece of crushed ice. You want some dark areas to make the bright areas pop. The problem starts when the bow tie is so prominent that it’s the only thing you see when you look at the ring.
The Grading Report Won't Save You
Here is the frustrating part: GIA and IGI do not grade bow ties.
💡 You might also like: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
You can look at a diamond certificate all day long. You can check the "Excellent" polish and "Excellent" symmetry boxes. You can stare at the depth and table percentages until your eyes bleed. None of those numbers will tell you if the diamond has a distracting bow tie.
A certificate is a 2D map of a 3D object. It tells you the dimensions, but it doesn’t tell you how the light moves. This is why buying an oval diamond sight-unseen is a massive gamble. You might find two diamonds with identical specs on paper, but one has a faint, barely-there shadow, and the other has a thick, black bar across the middle that makes it look like the diamond is split in two.
If you are shopping online, you must have high-quality 360-degree video. Even then, videos can be tricky. Lighting setups in professional diamond photography are designed to minimize shadows. Always ask for a "natural light" video if possible.
What to Look for in Videos
When you're watching those 360-degree spins, pay attention to the stone as it tilts. Does the dark area stay dark the whole time? Or does it flash and disappear as the diamond moves?
- Persistent shadows: If the bow tie stays black no matter how the stone is tilted, walk away. That's a "dead" spot in the stone.
- The "Flash" effect: If the bow tie area sparkles and shows life as the stone moves, that’s a well-cut diamond.
- Color leakage: Sometimes a bow tie isn't just dark; it’s actually transparent. If you can see the color of your finger through the middle of the stone, that’s a "windowing" issue, and it’s arguably worse than a bow tie.
Finding the Sweet Spot: Proportions That Matter
While there is no "magic number" for avoiding a bow tie, certain proportions tend to behave better than others.
Most experts, including the folks over at Whiteflash or James Allen, suggest staying within a specific range for the length-to-width ratio. For ovals, a ratio of 1.35 to 1.50 is usually the "sweet spot" for aesthetics. If the diamond is too "fat" (closer to 1.30), the bow tie can look chunky. If it’s too "skinny" (over 1.55), the bow tie often becomes elongated and much more obvious.
📖 Related: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
Depth is another big one. If an oval is too shallow (under 60%), light leaks out the bottom. If it's too deep (over 70%), it traps the light and creates that dark center. Ideally, you’re looking for a depth between 62% and 66%. This doesn't guarantee a perfect stone, but it narrows the field significantly.
Is a Bow Tie Always a Dealbreaker?
Honestly, no.
I’ve seen plenty of stunning oval diamonds with bow ties that looked incredible in person. It’s all about the severity. Think of it like a birthmark. Some are subtle and blend in; others are all you can see.
There’s also a subjective element here. Some people love the "butterfly" effect that a well-defined bow tie creates. It adds a structural look to the diamond that sets it apart from the chaotic sparkle of a round cut. If you like the look, don’t let a salesperson talk you out of it just because they think it’s a "flaw." It’s your ring.
However, if you’re looking for maximum brilliance, you want to find a stone where the facets in the middle are cut at angles that "mix" the light better. This is often referred to as a "brilliant" vs. "crushed ice" look. A crushed ice oval has many tiny facets that hide the bow tie but sacrifice some of that big, bold sparkle. A traditional oval brilliant has larger facets that show more "fire" but are more prone to showing a bow tie.
Expert Tips for the Savvy Buyer
If you are currently in the trenches of diamond shopping, here is the realistic way to handle this.
👉 See also: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
First, stop looking at the diamond under the harsh, pinpoint LED lights of a jewelry store. Those lights are designed to make every stone look like a disco ball. Ask the jeweler to step away from the counter and look at the stone in natural daylight or even under a regular office lamp. This is where the bow tie will truly reveal itself.
Second, don't ignore the "shoulders" of the stone. Sometimes a bow tie is exacerbated by the way the stone is set. A six-prong setting or a bezel might change how light enters the sides of the diamond, potentially darkening or lightening that center section.
Third, consider the color grade. A lower color grade (like a J or K) can sometimes make a bow tie look more prominent because the shadow catches the warmth of the stone. In a D or E color diamond, the bow tie is a stark, clean black-and-white contrast.
Actionable Steps for Choosing Your Oval
- Prioritize Video Over Certificates: Never buy an oval based solely on a GIA report. You need to see the light performance in motion.
- Check the 1.40 Ratio: Start your search around the 1.40 length-to-width ratio. It’s the most classic oval shape and tends to balance the bow tie effect the best.
- Ask for "Vibrant" Centers: When talking to a jeweler, tell them you want a stone with "minimal extinction in the center." Use that specific phrase. It shows you know what you’re talking about.
- Compare Side-by-Side: If possible, look at three different ovals at once. The bow tie in one will almost always look better or worse than the others when compared directly.
- Trust Your Eyes, Not the Hype: If you love a stone and the bow tie doesn't bother you, buy it. The "perfect" stone is the one you want to look at every day for the next fifty years.
The oval diamond with bow tie is a reality of the shape. It is a byproduct of the beautiful, elongated faceting that makes ovals so popular in the first place. By understanding that it's a matter of light interference rather than a "stain" on the diamond, you can shop with a lot more confidence. Focus on finding a stone with "life" throughout the entire table, and you'll end up with a ring that sparkles from every angle.
When you're ready to make the move, reach out to a reputable dealer who offers a solid return policy. Seeing the stone in your own home, in your own lighting, is the only way to be 100% sure that the bow tie is a feature you can live with—or even love.