If you pull into Old Hilliard and see the brick building at the corner of Center and Franklin, you’re looking at more than just a place to grab a beer. Otie’s Tavern & Grill is basically a living museum that happens to serve a mean fried bologna sandwich.
People always talk about the "vibe" of a place, but with Otie’s, it’s different. It’s not some manufactured, corporate version of a pub. It’s a building that has stood there since 1870, once serving as a post office and a grocery store before becoming a tavern in 1965. Honestly, if those walls could talk, they’d probably tell you to order another round and stop worrying about your step count for the day.
The Fried Bologna Factor at Otie's Tavern & Grill
You can't talk about this place without mentioning the Otie's Bologna.
Most people hear "fried bologna" and think of a sad, thin slice of Oscar Mayer in a skillet. That’s not what’s happening here. We’re talking a thick-cut slab of meat that’s been seared until the edges are crispy, topped with red onion and a mustard sauce that hits just right. It’s the kind of food that feels like a hug from a West Virginia coal miner—which makes sense, considering the original Otie, Otie Blankenship, moved here from the coal fields back in 1960.
The menu has evolved, sure. You’ve got smash burgers now, like the Royale Burger with sautéed mushrooms and Swiss, and a Nashville Hot Chicken that actually has a bit of a kick. But the bologna remains the soul of the menu. It’s a blue-collar legacy that survived the town’s transition from a sleepy railroad stop to a bustling Columbus suburb.
👉 See also: Bondage and Being Tied Up: A Realistic Look at Safety, Psychology, and Why People Do It
Why the Atmosphere is a Bit Polarizing
Walking into Otie's Tavern & Grill can be a bit of a trip. The decor is this wild mix of historical Hilliard photos and sports memorabilia. It’s not trying to be a sleek gastropub.
Lately, though, if you check the local chatter, things have been... complicated. There's been a lot of back-and-forth about ownership changes and the consistency of the service. Some folks swear by the outdoor patio—which, honestly, is one of the best spots in the city with its water wall—while others have had moments where the service felt a little "off."
- The Patio: Massive, sunny, and features a literal water wall.
- The History: It’s on the National Registry of Historic Places.
- The Food: Classic American comfort with a few Greek nods (thanks to the Jimmy V influence).
The truth is, Otie’s is a neighborhood spot. It has its "off" days like any place that's been around for sixty years, but when it’s clicking—especially during a Buckeyes game—there isn't a better seat in town.
The Real Story Behind the Building
The building at 5344 Center Street wasn't always a bar.
✨ Don't miss: Blue Tabby Maine Coon: What Most People Get Wrong About This Striking Coat
Back in 1912, it was the local post office and dry goods store. It stayed a store until 1965. When Otie Blankenship took it over, he turned it into a "workingman's bar." He was a guy who cared about Hilliard’s heritage, serving on the Old Hilliard Commission and fighting to keep the small-town feel even as Dublin and Upper Arlington were blowing up nearby.
He didn't want the town to be run by "big bucks." He wanted a place where you didn't have to be a bank president to feel welcome. That DNA is still there, even if the management has swapped hands and the town around it has changed.
What to Actually Order
If you're heading there for the first time, don't overthink it.
- The Blackened Shrimp Po' Boy: It’s got a solid remoulade and comes with fresh-cut fries.
- The Classic Burger: Two smash patties. Simple. Effective.
- The Wings: They do traditional and boneless, and they don't skimp on the sauce.
The "secret" parking lot behind the building is a life-saver, by the way. Don't waste twenty minutes circling Center Street like a shark. Just pull around the back; there’s a ramp for wheelchair accessibility there too.
🔗 Read more: Blue Bathroom Wall Tiles: What Most People Get Wrong About Color and Mood
Dealing with the "Front" Rumors
Look, every old bar in a historic district eventually gets hit with the "is this a front for something?" rumors. You’ll see it on Reddit or hear it at the barber shop. People see a beautiful second-story space that isn't always open and they start dreaming up conspiracies.
The reality is usually much more boring: staffing shortages and the logistical nightmare of running a historic building. Managing a multi-story venue in a structure built in the 19th century is expensive and difficult. While there's been talk of the place being renovated into a Cajun/Creole spot or changing hands again, for now, it remains the Otie's most people know.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
If you’re planning to check out Otie's Tavern & Grill, keep these things in mind to make sure you actually have a good time:
- Check the Event Calendar: They do a Comedy Night that’s usually only five bucks. It’s a steal for a night out.
- Go for Lunch: If you want the best version of the food without the "peak hour" service delays, a Tuesday or Wednesday lunch is the move.
- Ask for the Patio: If the weather is even remotely nice, the patio is the superior experience. The water wall actually does a great job of blocking out the street noise.
- Expect "Old School": Don't go in expecting a high-tech QR code ordering system. It’s a tavern. Treat the staff with a bit of patience, and you’ll usually get the same in return.
Otie’s isn't perfect, and it’s definitely not a polished chain restaurant. It’s a bit rough around the edges, a bit stubborn, and very much a product of Hilliard’s history. But for a thick slice of fried bologna and a cold drink in a building that has seen the town change for 150 years, it’s still the spot.