Everyone has that one friend who refuses to watch anything that doesn’t have a gold statue plastered on the thumbnail. You know the type. They treat the Academy Awards like a holy scripture of "quality," even though we all know the history of Best Picture is basically a graveyard of safe choices and weird snubs. Remember when Green Book beat Roma? Or that absolute chaos where La La Land was halfway through a speech before they realized Moonlight actually won?
But honestly, looking at the recent crop of oscar movie of the year winners, something has shifted. The "prestige" formula is breaking.
If you’ve been paying attention to the 2024 and 2025 seasons, the old-school "Oscar bait" period piece about a king with a stutter just doesn't carry the weight it used to. We’ve entered an era where a movie about a Brooklyn sex worker or a multiverse-jumping laundromat owner can actually take home the big one. It’s kinda refreshing.
The Anora Effect: A Shift in 2025
The 97th Academy Awards (the ones that just happened in March 2025) felt like a fever dream. If you’d told someone ten years ago that a gritty, screwball comedy-drama about a sex worker marrying a Russian oligarch’s son would sweep the major categories, they’d have laughed you out of the room. Yet, Sean Baker’s Anora did exactly that.
It didn't just win Best Picture; it dominated. Baker pulled off something virtually unheard of, taking home four individual trophies in one night: Director, Editing, Original Screenplay, and the big one.
Anora is a wild choice for the Academy. It’s loud, it’s sexually explicit, and it’s deeply empathetic toward people Hollywood usually ignores. Mikey Madison’s win for Best Actress was a huge "finally" moment for fans of indie cinema. She beat out massive names like Demi Moore and Cynthia Erivo. That kind of upset usually doesn't happen unless the performance is undeniable.
📖 Related: Ashley Johnson: The Last of Us Voice Actress Who Changed Everything
The film followed in the footsteps of Parasite (2019) by winning the Palme d'Or at Cannes before heading to the Dolby Theatre. That "Cannes-to-Oscar" pipeline is becoming the new gold standard for oscar movie of the year winners. It proves that "theatrical filmmaking" isn't dead—it’s just evolving.
When the Big Guys Actually Deliver
Before Anora blew the doors off, we had the "Barbenheimer" year.
2024 was the year Christopher Nolan finally got his flowers. Oppenheimer was a massive outlier in the history of Best Picture. Usually, a movie that makes a billion dollars is considered "too populist" for the Academy. But Nolan’s three-hour biopic about a physicist was a technical marvel that was impossible to ignore.
It’s interesting to compare Oppenheimer to something like CODA (2021) or Nomadland (2020).
- CODA was the ultimate "feel-good" win during a really dark pandemic era. It was small, intimate, and human.
- Oppenheimer was the opposite: massive, loud, and existential.
The fact that the Academy can swing from a small Apple TV+ acquisition (CODA) to a nuclear-sized blockbuster in just two years shows that the voting body is getting younger and, frankly, more interesting. They aren't just looking for a "message" anymore; they're looking for a vibe.
👉 See also: Archie Bunker's Place Season 1: Why the All in the Family Spin-off Was Weirder Than You Remember
What Most People Get Wrong About the "Oscar Bump"
There is this myth that winning Best Picture makes a movie a permanent cultural staple. It doesn't.
Actually, the "Oscar Bump" is mostly about immediate survival. For a film like Anora, which had a tiny $6 million budget, that Best Picture win is the difference between being a "cult classic" and a movie that makes $50 million at the box office.
Most people think the Academy chooses the "best" film. That’s rarely true. They choose the film that best represents the industry's mood at that specific moment.
In 2020, Parasite won because the industry was finally ready to admit that the best movies in the world aren't all made in English. In 2023, Everything Everywhere All At Once won because voters were exhausted by the "serious" drama and wanted something that felt like a chaotic hug.
Why Some Winners Fade While Others Last
Let's be real: nobody is talking about Nomadland at dinner parties anymore.
✨ Don't miss: Anne Hathaway in The Dark Knight Rises: What Most People Get Wrong
It’s a beautiful film, but it was a "mood" movie for a very specific time. On the flip side, people are still dissecting Moonlight and Parasite. The winners that last are the ones that challenge the way we think about the medium itself.
The Road to 2026: Who’s Next?
As we sit here in early 2026, the buzz for the 98th Oscars is already reaching a boiling point. The frontrunners this time around aren't the usual suspects.
Everyone is talking about Paul Thomas Anderson’s One Battle After Another. It’s an action-thriller, which is a genre the Academy usually snubs, but PTA is a "legacy" director. He’s in that Christopher Nolan zone where he’s due for a win.
Then you have Hamnet, directed by Chloé Zhao. She already won for Nomadland, and if she wins again, she’ll be the first woman to ever win Best Director twice. That’s the kind of narrative the Academy loves to reward.
Actionable Insight: How to Actually Watch These Movies
If you want to stay ahead of the curve, don't wait for the nominations in January.
- Watch the Festival Winners: If a movie wins the Palme d'Or (Cannes) or the People’s Choice Award at TIFF (Toronto), put it on your list immediately. This has predicted the last few oscar movie of the year winners with scary accuracy.
- Follow the Screenplay Wins: The Academy is a writer's guild at heart. If a movie is winning "Best Original Screenplay" at the Golden Globes or Critics' Choice, it has a massive head start for Best Picture.
- Ignore the "Lock": There is no such thing as a "lock." Just ask Saving Private Ryan or La La Land. The most interesting wins happen when the consensus breaks.
The Academy has a lot of flaws. It’s elitist, it’s often late to the party, and it loves a good "apology" win. But if the last five years have taught us anything, it’s that the era of the "boring" winner might finally be over.
To get the most out of this year's awards season, you should start tracking the winners of the SAG and PGA awards. These "precursor" awards are voted on by the same people who pick the Oscars, making them the most reliable crystal ball for who will be taking home the next Movie of the Year trophy.