The Bullpen Call That Changed Everything
He wasn't supposed to be "Bulldog." Not at first. In the early '80s, Orel Hershiser was a skinny kid with a high leg kick who looked more like a substitute teacher than a future Cy Young winner. Most collectors today hunt for the orel hershiser rookie card because of that legendary 1988 season—the 59 scoreless innings, the World Series MVP, the pure dominance. But if you look at his actual rookie cards from 1985, you see a pitcher who was still just trying to stick in the Dodgers' rotation.
Honestly, the market for Orel is weird. It’s not like the frenzy for a Ken Griffey Jr. or a Mickey Mantle. It’s more of a "know-it-all" market where the difference between a $5 card and a $400 card comes down to a slightly shinier coating or a microscopic centering issue. You've probably got a few of these sitting in a shoebox in your garage. Whether they're worth a steak dinner or just a pack of gum depends on a few specific details people usually overlook.
1985 Topps #493: The True Rookie Card
If you ask a purist, the 1985 Topps #493 is the only one that truly counts. This is the card. It features a young Orel in his home whites, looking surprisingly lean.
The 1985 Topps set is notorious for its wood-grain border's predecessor—the thick colored borders that show every single nick and chip. Because of the way these were cut in the mid-80s, finding one with perfect 50/50 centering is a nightmare. Most are shifted slightly to the left or right.
Why the 1985 Topps Tiffany is a Different Beast
Basically, Topps produced a high-end version of this set called "Tiffany." They only made about 5,000 to 10,000 of these factory sets. If you have the Tiffany version of the orel hershiser rookie card, you're looking at a much bigger payday.
How do you tell the difference?
💡 You might also like: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
- The Gloss: Tiffany cards have a smooth, high-gloss finish on the front. Regular cards feel like standard cardboard.
- The Back: This is the real giveaway. Flip the card over. If the back is bright white, it’s a Tiffany. If it’s that dull, greyish/brown recycled cardboard look, it’s the standard 1985 Topps.
In today's market, a standard PSA 10 (Gem Mint) Orel Hershiser rookie usually moves for somewhere between $150 and $240. But a Tiffany PSA 10? You’re easily looking at $400 to $450 depending on the day. That’s a massive jump for a card that looks identical from five feet away.
The "Rookie" Confusion: 1984 vs. 1985
You’ll see a lot of people on eBay trying to sell a 1984 Los Angeles Police Dodgers card as his "rookie."
Is it? Sorta.
It’s an "XRC" or an extended rookie card. It’s a regional issue given out by cops to kids in LA. While it’s his first appearance on a piece of cardboard, it’s not considered a "true" rookie card by the major grading companies like PSA or Beckett. The hobby generally agrees that his 1985 appearances in Topps, Donruss, and Fleer are the official rookies.
Then there's the 1985 Leaf #38. This was the Canadian version of the Donruss set. It’s much rarer than the US Donruss counterpart. If you find a Leaf version in a PSA 9 or 10, keep it. The population reports on those are significantly lower because way fewer people in Canada were tucking these away in acid-free sleeves back then.
📖 Related: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Valuation and the Grading Trap
Condition is everything.
Let’s be real: an ungraded, "raw" orel hershiser rookie card is usually a $2 to $5 item. You can find them in the dollar bin at almost any local card show. The value only explodes when the card is authenticated and graded.
| Grade | Estimated Value (Standard Topps) |
|---|---|
| PSA 10 (Gem Mint) | $175 - $250 |
| PSA 9 (Mint) | $35 - $50 |
| PSA 8 (NM-MT) | $10 - $15 |
| Raw (Ungraded) | $1 - $5 |
Don't go spending $20 to grade a card that looks "okay." If the corners aren't sharp enough to draw blood and the centering isn't nearly perfect, you’ll end up with a PSA 7 or 8. At 그 point, you’ve spent more on the grading fee than the card is actually worth. It’s a losing game unless the card is pristine.
The 1985 Fleer and Donruss Alternatives
Topps wasn't the only player in the game. 1985 Fleer #371 and 1985 Donruss #581 are the other "Big Three" rookie cards for Hershiser.
The Fleer card is actually quite handsome. It has a cleaner design than the Topps version, but Fleer was notorious for "ink hickeys" (small blobs of ink) and terrible centering in '85. The Donruss card is okay, but it’s part of a set that was overproduced even by junk-wax standards.
👉 See also: Scores of the NBA games tonight: Why the London Game changed everything
If you're collecting for investment, stick to Topps Tiffany or high-grade Fleer. If you're collecting for nostalgia, the Donruss card is a cheap, fun way to own a piece of the Bulldog's history without breaking the bank.
Is It a Good Investment in 2026?
Orel Hershiser is a Dodgers icon. He’s always on the broadcast. He’s always around the stadium. Because of that, his market is incredibly stable. It doesn't spike like a current superstar, but it also doesn't crater.
The biggest risk to the orel hershiser rookie card value is the sheer volume of cards produced during the 80s. This was the start of the "Junk Wax Era." Millions of these cards exist. However, very few were kept in perfect condition. That’s why the "Pop Report" matters. There are thousands of PSA 9s out there, but the number of PSA 10s is relatively small compared to the demand from Dodgers fans.
What to Look For Before You Buy
If you're hunting for a deal on eBay or at a card shop, keep these three things in mind:
- Check the corners first. The dark blue/black borders on the 1985 Donruss and the colored edges of the Topps card show "whitening" instantly. If you see white fuzz on the corners, it’s not a 10.
- Look for the "Diamond Cut." Sometimes 1985 Topps cards were cut at an angle, making the image look slightly tilted. Collectors hate this. Even if it's "centered," a tilted image will kill the grade.
- The "O-Pee-Chee" Factor. There is a 1985 O-Pee-Chee version (the Canadian Topps). It has a different card number (#273) and is much harder to find in high grades due to the rougher "wire-cut" edges used by the Canadian factory.
Actionable Steps for Your Collection
Don't just leave your cards in a box. If you think you have a winner, here is exactly what you should do:
- Self-Screen: Use a magnifying glass or a loupe to check the corners of your orel hershiser rookie card. If you see any wear at all, it's likely a PSA 8 or lower.
- Verify Tiffany Status: Use a bright LED flashlight. If the back of the card looks like bright white printer paper, it’s a Tiffany. If it looks like a brown paper bag, it’s the common version.
- Check the Pop Report: Before buying a graded card, go to the PSA website and check how many 10s exist. If the number is climbing fast, the price might drop soon.
- Protect the Asset: If you have a raw card in good shape, put it in a "Penny Sleeve" first, then a "Top Loader." Never put a card directly into a hard plastic screw-down case, as these can actually crush the corners or surface over time.
The Bulldog’s legacy is set in stone. Whether he eventually makes the Hall of Fame via the Veteran's Committee or remains a "Hall of Very Good" legend, his 1985 cards will always be a cornerstone for Los Angeles collectors.
Practical Next Step: Go through your 1985 Topps commons and look for card #493. If the back is white and the front is glossy, you've found a Tiffany—put it in a protector immediately and consider getting it professionally graded to maximize its market value.