If you were around for the "Golden Age" of Netflix, you remember the summer of 2013. It was a weird, transitional time for TV. We were all starting to binge-watch things, and suddenly, there was this blonde lady in a tan jumpsuit everywhere. Taylor Schilling wasn't exactly a household name yet, though she’d done a Nicholas Sparks movie with Zac Efron and a brief medical drama. But when she stepped into the shoes of Piper Chapman, everything changed. For her and for us.
Honestly, the way people talk about Orange Is the New Black Taylor Schilling has morphed so much over the last decade. At first, she was the hero. Then she was the "Trojan Horse." By the end of the seven-season run, some fans were actually rooting against her. It’s a wild trajectory for a lead actor.
📖 Related: Daphne Oz TV Show: What You Might Have Missed Since The Chew
The "Trojan Horse" Strategy
Jenji Kohan, the show’s creator, was pretty blunt about why she cast Taylor Schilling. She called Piper her "Trojan Horse." Basically, the industry at the time didn’t think audiences would flock to a show lead by Black, Latina, or older women in prison. So, they used Piper—a wealthy, white, "relatable" protagonist—to get people through the door. Once we were inside Litchfield, the show pulled a bait-and-switch. We stayed for Poussey, Taystee, and Red.
Schilling knew this. She’s talked about it in interviews, specifically reflecting on how it felt to see the audience’s love turn into resentment. It’s gotta be a trip to realize your character is designed to be the least interesting person in the room so others can shine. But she played it perfectly. She leaned into Piper’s entitlement. She made her annoying. That takes a specific kind of lack of vanity that most "star" actors just don't have.
Piper vs. The Real Piper
People often forget the show is based on a real person. Piper Kerman wrote the memoir that started it all. While the real Kerman spent her 15 months and then became a massive advocate for prison reform, the fictional Piper Chapman became... well, a bit of a monster.
Remember the panty business? Or when she got that "White Power" branding?
✨ Don't miss: Sam Barber Better Year Lyrics: Why This Song Hits So Hard
The show pushed Piper into dark places the real memoir never touched. Schilling had to navigate this weird middle ground. She was playing a version of a real human being who was simultaneously becoming a caricature of privilege.
- The Salary Gap: There’s been a lot of talk lately about the pay on the show. While Taylor was the lead, reports suggest she was making around $35,000 per episode in the early seasons. That sounds like a lot until you realize the show was a global phenomenon.
- The Career Shift: Since the show ended in 2019, Schilling has taken a step back from the massive blockbuster machine. You’ve seen her in Pam & Tommy or Dear Edward, but she seems more interested in the Hudson Valley life than the Hollywood red carpet.
Why the Hate for Piper Chapman?
It’s actually kinda fascinating. By season three, the internet was flooded with "Why I Hate Piper" think pieces. Taylor Schilling was literally too good at her job. She portrayed the "white savior" complex so accurately that people started to despise the character for the very reasons she was created.
She wasn't just a fish out of water; she was a fish that kept trying to build a better aquarium while ignoring the fact that the other fish were dying.
Schilling herself admitted to feeling "hurt" by the backlash. She felt like a "space-holder." It’s a tough gig. You’re the face of the show, you’re doing the most press, but the narrative is constantly telling you that you’re the problem.
Life After Litchfield
So, what happened when the jumpsuits were turned in?
Schilling didn't go the "Marvel Movie" route. A lot of people expected her to become the next big rom-com lead or action star. Instead, she’s been doing really specific, character-driven work. She recently popped up in Poker Face with her old co-star Natasha Lyonne. Seeing them back on screen together was like a fever dream for OITNB fans.
She also came out publicly in 2020, confirming her relationship with visual artist Emily Ritz. She’s notoriously private—like, "deleting all social media" levels of private. In an era where every actor is trying to be an influencer, that’s honestly refreshing.
The Legacy of the Orange Jumpsuit
Looking back, Orange Is the New Black Taylor Schilling was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment.
The show didn't just change Netflix; it changed how we talk about the prison-industrial complex. Even if Piper was the "Trojan Horse," she was a necessary one for the time. Schilling’s performance was the anchor. Without her being the "steady middle," the chaotic brilliance of the ensemble might have felt untethered.
She wasn't there to be liked. She was there to be the lens.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Creators
If you're looking back at the series or following Taylor's career now, here’s how to view it with a bit more nuance:
🔗 Read more: 930 AM Radio Listen Live: How to Find the Right Station Anywhere
- Watch the evolution, not just the plot. If you rewatch, pay attention to Schilling’s facial expressions in the background of other people’s scenes. She’s often doing the heavy lifting of showing how the "outsider" perceives the system.
- Separate the actor from the archetype. Don't let your annoyance with Piper Chapman cloud the fact that Taylor Schilling is one of the most disciplined actors of her generation.
- Check out the "unseen" work. If you only know her from Litchfield, go watch Family (2018). It’s an indie where she plays a career-obsessed woman forced to watch her niece. It shows a comedic side of her that OITNB only hinted at.
- Support the advocacy. The "real" Piper (Kerman) is still doing incredible work with the Women's Prison Association. If the show moved you, looking into the actual systemic issues it raised is the best way to honor that legacy.
The show is over, and the orange jumpsuits are in storage, but the conversation about privilege, prison, and "who gets to tell the story" is still happening. Taylor Schilling played her part in starting that conversation. And honestly? She did it better than most people give her credit for.
To keep up with what's actually happening in the world of prison reform and the actors who champion it, you should look into the latest reports from the Sentencing Project or follow the Women's Prison Association.