You’ve probably seen them on a Telegram channel or tucked behind a glass counter in a "gift shop" in DC or New York. The packaging is loud. It’s colorful. It looks exactly like something out of a Super Mario game, complete with the iconic green and red mushrooms. But One Up mushroom bars are a bit of a mystery, honestly. Depending on who you ask, they’re either the gold standard of the edible world or a cautionary tale about the Wild West of the unregulated supplement market.
People are looking for a specific experience. They want the benefits of psilocybin—the active compound in "magic mushrooms"—without the gritty, dirt-like taste of dried fungi. It makes sense. Eating raw mushrooms is, frankly, gross for a lot of people. Infusing them into chocolate seems like the perfect solution. But if you’re planning on buying one, there’s a massive gap between the marketing and the reality of what’s actually in that foil wrapper.
The Massive Branding Problem
Let’s be real for a second. The biggest thing you need to know about One Up mushroom bars is that there is no "official" company. There isn’t a massive factory in California with a CEO and a board of directors churning these out under a legal license. Instead, the packaging is sold in bulk online.
Go to any major Chinese wholesale site or specialized packaging site. You can buy 1,000 empty One Up boxes for pennies. This means anyone—literally anyone—can buy the boxes, melt down some Hershey’s bars, stir in whatever they want, and sell it as a "One Up bar."
This is why your experience with a bar in Denver might be totally different from a bar in London. One might contain high-quality Psilocybe cubensis powder. The other might contain 4-AcO-DMT.
What is 4-AcO-DMT?
This is where things get technical but stay with me. 4-AcO-DMT (Psilacetin) is a synthetic prodrug. Many researchers, including the legendary chemist David Nichols who studied it extensively, believe the body metabolizes it into psilocin, just like it does with natural mushrooms.
It’s not necessarily "dangerous" in the way some synthetic drugs are, but it’s not organic mushroom matter. It’s a lab-made powder. It's cheaper for underground producers to use because it’s easy to dose and doesn't make the chocolate taste like a forest floor. If your bar hits you in 15 minutes and feels "cleaner" than a traditional trip, you’re probably eating a research chemical, not a ground-up mushroom.
The Legal Gray Area and Real Risk
We’re living through a psychedelic renaissance. Oregon and Colorado have moved toward decriminalization and regulated use. Places like Oakland and Ann Arbor have followed suit. But even in these spots, selling a branded chocolate bar in a retail store is still technically a legal nightmare.
👉 See also: Why the Man Black Hair Blue Eyes Combo is So Rare (and the Genetics Behind It)
Because One Up mushroom bars use trademarked imagery from Nintendo, they’ll never be a "legal" brand. Nintendo is notoriously litigious. No legitimate, state-licensed psilocybin producer would touch that branding with a ten-foot pole. It’s an immediate cease-and-desist at best and a federal raid at worst.
So, when you buy a One Up bar, you are participating in a totally gray market.
Knowing the Dosages
Most of these bars claim to have 3.5 grams or 5 grams of "magic blend."
They’re usually divided into 8 or 12 squares.
The math sounds simple.
It isn't.
If the person who made the bar didn't use a professional tempering machine or didn't stir the mixture properly, you get "hot spots." One square might do nothing. The next square might send you to the moon. This lack of quality control is the biggest gripe long-term users have. You’ve gotta be careful. If you’re a beginner, starting with one square and waiting two full hours is the only way to play it safe. Seriously. Don't be the person who eats half the bar because "it’s not working" after thirty minutes.
Why People Keep Buying Them
Despite the risks of "fakes" and the lack of oversight, these bars are incredibly popular. Why? Because when they're good, they're great.
The chocolate masks the chitin in the mushrooms. Chitin is the cell wall of the mushroom that humans can't digest well. It’s what causes the "shroom nausea" or "the bubbles" in your stomach. When mushrooms are finely ground and suspended in fats (like cocoa butter), many people find the digestive load much easier to handle.
- Convenience: No weighing out grams on a tiny scale.
- Taste: Usually comes in flavors like Milk Chocolate, Cookies and Cream, or Vegan Dark.
- Discretion: It looks like a candy bar. It doesn't look like a bag of dried roots and stems.
There's also the community aspect. People share their experiences on Reddit and Discord, trying to track down which "vendors" are currently using real fruit bodies versus who is using synthetics. It’s a weird, digital game of cat and mouse.
✨ Don't miss: Chuck E. Cheese in Boca Raton: Why This Location Still Wins Over Parents
Identifying a "Real" One Up Bar
Since the packaging is open-source, "real" is a relative term. However, the more "sophisticated" underground producers have started adding verification stickers. You might see a QR code that leads to a "lab result."
Word of caution: these are easily faked.
A PDF of a lab test from three years ago doesn't prove that the bar in your hand right now is safe. Look for things like holographic seals or "scratch-to-verify" codes. Even then, take it with a grain of salt. The best way to know what you’re getting is to know the source. If you’re buying it from a random person on a street corner, the branding is just cardboard.
The Effects: What to Expect
If you happen to get a bar that is actually dosed correctly with psilocybin, the experience follows the standard psychedelic arc.
The first 45 minutes are usually the "come up." You might feel a little lightheaded or get some mild "body load" where your limbs feel heavy. Around the hour mark, visual distortions start. Colors look more vivid. Patterns might start to "breathe."
By hour two, you're in the peak. This is where the introspective thoughts happen. It’s not just about seeing pretty lights; it’s about that shift in perspective. For many, it’s a tool for working through personal issues or just feeling a deep sense of connection to the world.
The whole thing usually wraps up by the six-hour mark. Unlike alcohol, there isn't really a "hangover," though you might feel emotionally drained or "fried" the next day.
🔗 Read more: The Betta Fish in Vase with Plant Setup: Why Your Fish Is Probably Miserable
Safety and Best Practices
If you're going to dive into the world of One Up mushroom bars, you have to be your own advocate. There’s no FDA looking out for you here.
First, test your stuff. There are reagent test kits available (like the Ehrlich or Hofmann reagents) that can detect the presence of indoles (like psilocybin or 1P-LSD). While you can't easily test chocolate, you can sometimes find kits designed for edibles.
Second, mind your set and setting. This is the golden rule of psychedelics. Don't take these if you're in a bad headspace or a chaotic environment. Being in a comfortable, familiar place with people you trust is non-negotiable.
Third, have a trip sitter. Especially if it’s your first time or if you're trying a new brand of bar. Having one sober person who can get you a glass of water or remind you that "the drug will wear off" is invaluable.
The Future of Mushroom Edibles
As the laws change, we’re going to see the "One Up" era fade away. In legal markets like Oregon, you don't see Mario-themed bars. You see professional, clinical packaging with clear dosage labels, ingredient lists, and batch numbers. These products are tested for heavy metals, pesticides, and mold—things that underground producers rarely check for.
The "street" brands exist because there is a massive demand and not enough legal supply. Until federal law catches up with public opinion, these colorful, questionable bars will stay on the shelves.
Actionable Steps for the Curious
If you are considering trying these, don't just jump in.
- Research the current "packaging" trends. Check forums like Shroomery or specific subreddits to see if there are known "bad batches" or reports of adverse reactions in your area.
- Start incredibly small. Take a half-square or one square. Wait two hours. You can always take more, but you can't "un-take" it.
- Check for allergens. Many of these bars use cheap chocolate that may contain soy, nuts, or dairy. Since the labels are often generic, they might not list everything.
- Prioritize whole fungi. If you have the choice, many experts recommend using actual dried mushrooms. You know exactly what they are. You can see the blue bruising (a sign of psilocybin). You aren't guessing what a lab in another country put in a chocolate vat.
- Verify your source. If you’re buying from a local "delivery service," ask them directly: "Is this made with ground mushrooms or 4-AcO?" A transparent seller will usually tell you the truth because they want repeat customers.
The world of One Up mushroom bars is a fascinating look at how culture moves faster than the law. They are a bridge between the old-school "bag of mushrooms" and a future where psychedelics are just another item on a dispensary shelf. Just remember: when the branding looks like a toy, treat the contents with the respect of a powerful medicine.