Look, ranking One Piece is a death wish. You’ve got people who have been reading since 1997 and kids who just binged the whole thing on 2x speed last summer. Everyone has "their" arc. But honestly? Most of the internet’s consensus on the one piece arc tier list is getting a bit stale.
We are officially in 2026. The Egghead Island arc just wrapped up its anime run with that massive episode 1155, and we’re all sitting here waiting for Elbaf to kick off in April. The landscape has shifted. If your tier list still has Long Ring Long Land at the bottom just because of Foxy, you’re missing the point. If you think Wano is the undisputed GOAT just because the animation looked like a fever dream, we need to talk.
The God Tier: Where Pacing Doesn't Matter
There are three arcs that basically sit in the "S-Tier" of every one piece arc tier list ever made. You know them. I know them.
Marineford is usually the one. It’s the peak of the Summit War Saga. It’s chaos. It’s Luffy being a tiny fish in a massive, terrifying ocean. What people forget is how fast it moves in the manga. It’s relentless. No Straw Hats (mostly), just pure world-building and heartbreak. Seeing Whitebeard stand tall even in death? Chills. Every single time.
Then you have Enies Lobby. This is the emotional core of the series. "I want to live!" is the moment One Piece went from a fun pirate adventure to a story about defying the entire world for one friend. The Lucci fight is still the gold standard for 1v1s. It’s gritty. It’s personal.
And then there's Egghead. Yeah, I'm putting it here. Now that the anime has caught up, we can finally admit it: Egghead is the most dense, lore-heavy, high-stakes stretch of the story since the timeskip. It took the mystery of Vegapunk—something we’ve waited decades for—and actually delivered. Plus, the Kuma backstory? I haven’t seen the fandom cry that hard since the Going Merry sank.
💡 You might also like: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
The "Actually Good" Tier: Justice for Skypiea
Skypiea is the most disrespected arc in the history of Shonen. Period.
For years, people told new fans to skip it. "It’s filler," they said. "It doesn’t affect the plot."
Wrong.
Skypiea is the essence of One Piece. It’s pure adventure. The mystery of the Knock Up Stream, the tragedy of Mont Blanc Noland, and the introduction of Haki (even if it was called Mantra back then). In 2026, with all the Sun God Nika revelations, Skypiea has aged like fine wine. It’s basically the blueprint for the endgame. Honestly, if you don't like Skypiea, do you even like One Piece? Or do you just like watching guys punch each other through mountains?
Alabasta also fits here. It’s the first "big" arc. It established the formula: get to island, meet princess, fight Warlord. Crocodile was a menace. He actually "killed" Luffy twice. The stakes felt real because for the first time, a whole country was actually going to blow up.
📖 Related: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
The Controversial Middle: Wano and Dressrosa
This is where the one piece arc tier list gets messy. These arcs are long.
Wano Country is a masterpiece of production. The animation during "Roof Piece" and Gear 5 was historic. But let’s be real: the pacing in the middle of the raid was a slog. How many times did we have to see those ice ogres? It’s an A-tier arc held back by its own bloat. When it hits, it hits harder than Kaido’s club, but you have to sit through a lot of fluff to get there.
Dressrosa has the same problem. Doflamingo is arguably the best villain Oda has ever written. He’s charismatic, terrifying, and deeply connected to the world’s dark history. But the anime pacing? It was brutal. One chapter per episode is a tough way to live. If you’re ranking based on the manga, Dressrosa is Top 5. If you’re an anime-only viewer, it’s a test of patience.
The Bottom (That Isn't Actually Bad)
Let’s talk about Long Ring Long Land. Everyone hates the Foxy arc. Why? Because it’s goofy. But after the high-stakes drama of Skypiea, we needed a breather. It’s funny. It’s creative. And it leads directly into the meeting with Aokiji, which is one of the most terrifying moments in the series.
Then there’s Fishman Island. It gets a bad rap because Hordy Jones wasn't a "hype" villain. But Hordy wasn't supposed to be a threat; he was a symptom of the cycle of hatred. The flashback with Fisher Tiger and Queen Otohime is some of the most mature writing Oda has ever done. It’s not about the fights; it’s about the message.
👉 See also: Jack Blocker American Idol Journey: What Most People Get Wrong
What Most People Get Wrong
People tend to rank arcs based on "hype" moments. They want the big transformations and the "The One Piece is real!" shouts. But the best arcs are the ones that build the world.
Sabaody Archipelago is a perfect example. It’s short. It’s punchy. And it ends with the protagonists losing. Completely. That kind of narrative bravery is why we’re still talking about this show 25 years later. It’s not just a power fantasy. It’s a story about the cost of freedom.
Your Next Steps for the Elbaf Era
As we transition into the Elbaf arc and the new "seasonal" 26-episode-per-year schedule for the anime starting in April 2026, it's time to re-evaluate how you consume this story.
If you've only ever watched the anime, read the manga for the Dressrosa and Wano arcs. The difference in pacing is like night and day. You’ll find yourself liking those "low-tier" arcs a lot more when the story actually moves. Also, go back and re-read the Noland flashback in Skypiea. With the knowledge we have now about the Void Century and Nika, it’s a completely different experience.
The final saga is here. Don't be the person who skips the setup and wonders why the payoff feels empty.