Trust is weird. We think we’re logical creatures who make decisions based on spreadsheets, data points, and cold, hard ROI metrics. But honestly? We aren't. Not really. Most of the time, we’re just looking for one of our own.
That phrase—one of our own—carries a massive amount of psychological weight. It’s the shorthand for "this person understands my world." In 2026, where every inbox is flooded with AI-generated outreach and every LinkedIn feed looks like a graveyard of "thought leadership," the search for genuine connection has become a survival tactic. Whether you’re a venture capitalist looking for a founder or a manager hiring a new lead, you aren't just looking for skills. You're looking for the cultural fit, the shared language, and the unspoken understanding that defines being an insider.
It's about tribalism.
👉 See also: Average Commercial Real Estate Loan Rates: What Most People Get Wrong
The Psychological Hook of Being One of Our Own
Psychologists often talk about "in-group favoritism." It sounds clinical, but it’s basically just the warm feeling you get when you realize the person you’re talking to also grew up in the same struggling neighborhood or worked the same grueling graveyard shifts at a warehouse.
Social identity theory, first developed by Henri Tajfel and John Turner in the 1970s, suggests that people naturally categorize themselves and others into groups. These groups—the "in-groups"—become a source of pride and self-esteem. When we identify someone as one of our own, we’re not just being friendly. We are subconsciously deciding that this person is more trustworthy, more capable, and more deserving of our resources than an "outsider."
Think about the "PayPal Mafia." Why did that specific group of people—Peter Thiel, Elon Musk, Reid Hoffman, and others—go on to dominate Silicon Valley for decades? It wasn't just because they were smart. It was because they viewed each other as one of our own. They shared a specific, intense experience. They had a shorthand language. When one of them started a new venture, the others didn't need a 50-page pitch deck to know if the person was worth a check. The trust was baked into the identity.
Why "The Insider" Always Wins the Contract
You’ve seen this happen. A company brings in a high-priced consulting firm with a mountain of data. The consultants are brilliant. Their slides are perfect. But the CEO ignores them and instead listens to the guy who’s been in the industry for thirty years and "knows how things actually work on the floor."
Why? Because the veteran is one of our own.
He speaks the jargon. He knows that when the "upstream supply chain" is mentioned, it actually means "Bill at the loading dock is going to be late again." That nuance is impossible to fake. In a business world that feels increasingly detached and digital, that level of granular, shared reality is the ultimate currency. If you can’t speak the language of the tribe, you’re just a tourist. And nobody wants to give a multi-million dollar contract to a tourist.
The Dark Side: When the Tribe Becomes a Silo
We have to talk about the risk here. While the one of our own mentality builds incredible speed and trust, it also builds blind spots. Big ones.
✨ Don't miss: FOMC 2025 Meeting Schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
If your entire leadership team is made up of people who all went to the same three universities, worked at the same two tech giants, and spend their weekends at the same country clubs, you don't have a team. You have an echo chamber. You’ve created a tribe so tight that it can't see the world changing outside its walls.
History is littered with companies that failed because they were too focused on their internal culture. Look at the early days of BlackBerry (RIM). They were the kings of mobile messaging. They had a very specific culture of engineers who valued physical keyboards and security above all else. They were "keyboard people." When the iPhone showed up, the "one of our own" mentality at RIM actually worked against them. They couldn't imagine a world where people would trade a tactile keyboard for a piece of glass. They were too busy listening to each other.
- Innovation often requires an "outsider" perspective.
- Homogeneity leads to stagnant decision-making.
- "Culture fit" can sometimes be a masked version of "unconscious bias."
True leadership involves balancing that sense of belonging with a radical openness to people who are definitely not one of your own. It's about expanding the definition of the tribe, not just protecting the borders.
How to Build "In-Group" Trust Without the Elitism
So, how do you actually use this? If you’re a salesperson, a job hunter, or a founder, how do you become one of our own in a way that’s authentic?
You don't do it by faking it. People can smell a "poseur" a mile away. You do it through immersion.
I remember a story about a salesperson who was trying to sell software to independent trucking companies. He spent three months just hanging out at truck stops and warehouses. He didn't try to sell anything. He just listened. He learned the specific frustrations of the drivers—the way the logbooks were a pain, the way the dispatchers didn't understand the traffic patterns on I-95. By the time he finally made his pitch, he didn't sound like a software guy. He sounded like one of them. He had earned his way into the "one of our own" category.
Signals that Prove You Belong
- Shared Struggle: Don't lead with your wins; lead with the problems you've solved that are identical to theirs.
- Specific Jargon: Use the slang that only insiders know. Not the "corporate" jargon, but the "trench" jargon.
- The "Who You Know" Factor: Referencing shared contacts isn't just networking; it's providing a "proof of work" for your social standing.
- Cultural Literacy: Know the history of the industry. Who were the villains five years ago? What was the "great disaster" everyone remembers?
The Future of Belonging in a Virtual World
As we move deeper into 2026, the definition of "our own" is shifting. It’s no longer just about geography or even company history. It’s about digital communities.
The most powerful tribes right now are being built on Discord servers, niche Substack communities, and specialized Slack channels. In these spaces, being one of our own means you contribute value without asking for anything in return. It’s a reputation-based economy.
If you want to be seen as an insider in the AI ethics space, for example, you don't just post links. You engage in the nuanced debates about model transparency and data provenance. You show that you’ve done the reading. You demonstrate that you care about the things the tribe cares about.
This isn't just "networking." Networking is transactional. Being one of our own is relational. It’s the difference between having someone’s business card and having their cell phone number.
Actionable Steps to Leverage the Concept
Stop trying to appeal to everyone. Seriously. If you’re trying to be everything to everyone, you are "one of our own" to no one. You’re just white noise.
Identify your primary tribe.
Who are the 500 people whose respect actually matters to your career or business? Write down the specific characteristics of that group. What do they value? What do they fear? What do they hate?
Audit your language.
Look at your website, your LinkedIn profile, or your pitch decks. Does it sound like it was written by a marketing committee, or does it sound like it was written by someone who has spent time in the mud? Remove the generic "synergy" and "world-class" nonsense. Replace it with specific references to the day-to-day reality of your audience.
Invest in "Social Proof" that matters.
Instead of chasing a generic certification, get a testimonial from a respected elder in your specific tribe. One "he's the real deal" from a known industry veteran is worth more than a thousand "Endorsements" on LinkedIn from random strangers.
Broaden the gate.
If you are already the "insider," make a conscious effort to bring "outsiders" in. The strongest tribes are those that are constantly refreshed by new perspectives while maintaining a core sense of identity. Seek out the person who doesn't fit the mold and see what they see.
Trust isn't something you can "hack." It’s something you earn by showing up, speaking the truth, and proving—over and over again—that you understand the world from the same perspective as the people you serve. When you finally hear someone say, "Yeah, he’s one of our own," you’ll know you’ve actually arrived.