You’ve seen the formula a thousand times. A high-strung professional—usually in marketing or journalism—heads to a snowy town, meets a cynical but handsome local, and learns the "true meaning" of the season. But On the 12th Date of Christmas, which hit the Hallmark Channel back in 2020, did something a little different. It wasn't just about a magic gazebo or a hidden inheritance.
It was about a scavenger hunt.
Honestly, the premise sounds like a logistical nightmare. Two game designers, Jennifer and Aidan, are forced to compete for a career-making promotion by creating a 12-day scavenger hunt across the city of Chicago. If you’ve ever worked in a creative agency, the "forced collaboration" trope hits a little too close to home. Mallory Jansen and Tyler Hynes, the leads, have this weirdly natural chemistry that makes the usual Hallmark cheese feel, well, edible.
What Actually Happens in On the 12th Date of Christmas?
The movie follows Jennifer, a Midwest transplant living in the big city, who is basically a Christmas fanatic. She’s paired with Aidan, who is much more "data-driven" and "results-oriented." That’s corporate speak for being a bit of a Grinch.
They have to pitch a concept for the fictional "Chamberlain Hotel" to celebrate their anniversary. Jennifer wants heart; Aidan wants efficiency. It’s a classic clash. But as they scout locations around Chicago—which, fun fact, was actually filmed largely in Winnipeg because that’s just how the Canadian film tax credit works—they start to rub off on each other.
The "dates" in the title don't refer to romantic outings, at least not at first. They refer to the twelve stops or "dates" on the scavenger hunt. It's a clever play on words that most people miss when they first see the title on their DVR.
Why Tyler Hynes is the Secret Weapon
If you follow the "Hallmarkies" (the die-hard fanbase), you know Tyler Hynes is a bit of a legend. He doesn't play the typical, wide-eyed Christmas hero. He’s usually a bit dry. A bit sarcastic. In On the 12th Date of Christmas, his portrayal of Aidan is what keeps the movie from drifting into total saccharine territory.
👉 See also: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
He plays the guy who thinks a scavenger hunt is a waste of time, which is exactly how a real person would feel.
Mallory Jansen, known by many for her role in Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., brings a sharp, energetic contrast. She isn't just a "Christmas girl." She's a professional trying to prove her worth in a competitive industry. Their banter feels earned. It's not just scripted "meet-cute" dialogue. They actually seem to annoy each other, which makes the eventual romance feel way more satisfying than the movies where they fall in love over a shared cup of cocoa in the first ten minutes.
The Chicago Setting (and the Winnipeg Reality)
Location is everything in these films. While the story is set in the Windy City, the production team had to get creative. If you look closely at the background of some scenes, you’ll notice the distinct lack of the "L" train in certain "downtown" shots.
- The Fairmont Winnipeg: This stood in for the grand Chicago hotel.
- The Exchange District: Used for those charming, brick-lined street scenes.
- The Scavenger Hunt Stops: These were designed to look like iconic Chicago landmarks, even if the geography doesn't totally check out if you're a local.
Why does this matter? Because for fans of On the 12th Date of Christmas, the atmosphere is a character itself. The movie leans heavily into the "urban Christmas" vibe rather than the "small-town bakery" trope. It’s about finding magic in a cold, busy metropolis.
Breaking Down the Scavenger Hunt Concept
The 12-day hunt is the engine of the plot. Each "date" is a riddle. Jennifer’s ideas are all about tradition—carolers, tree lightings, and nostalgia. Aidan wants tech. He wants apps and QR codes.
The compromise they reach is actually a pretty good lesson in project management. You can’t have a soul-less app, but you also can’t run a city-wide event in 2020 using only paper maps and good vibes. They find a middle ground.
✨ Don't miss: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
One of the standout moments involves a "hidden" bakery that only those who solve the riddle can find. It’s the kind of thing that makes you want to go out and organize a scavenger hunt in your own city, though you’d probably just end up tired and cold.
The "Hallmark Formula" vs. Real Life
Let’s be real. Nobody gets a promotion that easily. In the real world, Jennifer and Aidan would be working 14-hour days, drinking lukewarm coffee, and arguing over budget spreadsheets. The movie skips the boring stuff to get to the "magic."
But it works.
It works because it taps into the desire for a "destination" Christmas. We want to believe that a city can be transformed into a playground. We want to believe that our coworkers are secretly charming and just waiting for a holiday project to reveal their true selves.
Common Misconceptions
People often confuse this movie with The 12 Dates of Christmas (the reality show) or 12 Dates of Christmas (the Amy Smart movie).
They are very different.
🔗 Read more: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie
The Amy Smart flick is a Groundhog Day style loop. The reality show is... well, it’s a dating show. On the 12th Date of Christmas is a standalone romantic comedy about professional rivalry turning into a partnership. If you go looking for it on streaming services, make sure you look for the "Date" (singular-ish) and the Hallmark crown logo.
How to Watch It Now
Since its 2020 debut, the movie has become a staple of the "Countdown to Christmas" rotation. You can usually find it on:
- The Hallmark Channel: It airs multiple times during November and December.
- Hallmark Movies Now: The subscription streaming service usually carries it year-round.
- VOD Platforms: You can buy or rent it on Amazon, Apple TV, or Vudu.
It’s one of those movies that actually holds up on a second watch because the clues in the scavenger hunt are actually woven into the background of earlier scenes. It’s surprisingly well-plotted for a genre that is often accused of being "filler."
Takeaways for Your Own Holiday Season
If you're looking to bring a bit of the On the 12th Date of Christmas energy to your life, you don't need a Chicago hotel budget.
- Create a "Micro-Hunt": Instead of a big gift, hide clues around the house for your partner or kids.
- Embrace the "Dry" Humor: Take a page from Tyler Hynes. You don't have to be bubbly to enjoy the holidays. Being the "sarcastic one" who still shows up for the tree lighting is a valid Christmas identity.
- Explore Your Own City: We often treat our hometowns as places we just live in. Act like a tourist for a day. Solve a "riddle" about a local landmark.
The movie reminds us that the best parts of the season aren't the things we buy, but the ways we find to engage with the world around us. Even if that engagement starts as a mandatory work assignment.
For fans of the genre, On the 12th Date of Christmas remains a top-tier entry because it respects the audience's intelligence just enough to keep the "cringe" at bay while delivering exactly the kind of warmth we need when it's five degrees outside and the sun sets at 4:00 PM.
Go find it on the schedule, grab a drink—maybe something stronger than cocoa if you’re feeling Aidan-esque—and enjoy the ride. The chemistry is real, the riddles are decent, and for two hours, Chicago (via Winnipeg) looks like the most magical place on earth.