Language is a funny thing. We use big words to sound smart, especially in legal documents or HR meetings, but sometimes the weight of a phrase gets lost in the jargon. You’ve probably heard someone say a person acted on his own volition. It sounds fancy. It sounds definitive. But if you’re standing in a courtroom or sitting across from a manager who is asking you to sign a "voluntary" resignation, that phrase becomes the most important thing in the room.
It basically means doing something of your own free will. No one pushed you. No one held a metaphorical gun to your head. You just decided to do it.
But here is the kicker: the law and your boss often have very different ideas about what "free will" looks like. In the real world, "on his own volition" is a battleground for determining who is at fault when things go sideways.
The Legal Reality of Free Will
When a lawyer says a defendant confessed on his own volition, they are trying to shut down any argument of coercion. This goes back to the Fourth and Fifth Amendments in the U.S. Constitution. It’s not just about what you said; it’s about why you said it. If the police keep you in a room for 12 hours without water, and you finally "confess," did you do it on your own volition?
Most courts would say no.
Psychologically, volition is complex. We think we make choices independently, but social pressure is a massive weight. Take the famous Milgram experiment from the 1960s. Stanley Milgram showed that people would perform actions that went against their conscience just because an authority figure told them to. In those cases, were they acting on their own volition? Technically, they pushed the button. But the "volition" was tainted.
In modern employment law, this comes up constantly with "forced resignations." You know the drill. A company wants to fire someone but doesn't want to pay unemployment benefits or deal with a wrongful termination suit. They tell the employee, "You can either be fired or resign on your own volition."
💡 You might also like: Why the Blue Jordan 13 Retro Still Dominates the Streets
If you choose to resign, you might think you’re saving face. Honestly, you might be signing away your right to sue or collect benefits. The legal term for this is "constructive discharge." It’s when an employer makes your life so miserable that you "voluntarily" quit, but the law recognizes that you didn't actually want to leave. Your volition was manufactured by a toxic environment.
Why Context Is Everything
I’ve seen cases where the distinction between "voluntary" and "coerced" hinges on a single email or a three-second pause in a recording.
If you’re a manager, you need to be careful. Telling a subordinate to "act on their own volition" while implying they’ll be punished if they don't is a recipe for a lawsuit. It’s a paradox. You can’t command someone to be spontaneous, and you can’t command someone to be voluntary.
The word "volition" stems from the Latin velle, which means "to wish" or "to will." It’s a deeply internal process.
The Philosophy of the "Self-Starter"
Outside of the courtroom, we use the phrase as a badge of honor. We love the idea of the "self-made" person who acts purely on his own volition. We see it in sports—the athlete who puts in extra hours when the coach isn't looking. We see it in tech—the coder who builds a side project that turns into a billion-dollar company.
But let's be real for a second.
📖 Related: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
Total volition is a bit of a myth. We are all products of our environment, our upbringing, and our neurochemistry. In the field of neuroscience, researchers like Benjamin Libet have famously (and controversially) argued that our brains initiate the decision to move before we are even consciously aware of our "will" to do so.
Does that mean we don't have volition? Not necessarily. It just means that "acting on one's own volition" is a much messier, more biological process than we like to admit.
Breaking Down the Misconceptions
People often confuse "volition" with "intention." They aren't the same.
- Intention is about the goal. You intend to go to the store.
- Volition is the power of using your will to actually get off the couch and walk out the door.
You can have the intention to start a diet every Monday morning, but without volition, you’re just a person thinking about salad while eating a donut. Volition is the engine. Intention is the map.
How to Protect Yourself in High-Stakes Situations
If you ever find yourself in a situation where someone is asking you to sign something or make a major life change "on your own volition," you need to stop and breathe.
Pressure tactics are designed to bypass your slow, rational thinking. They want you to act fast.
👉 See also: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
- Ask for time. True volition doesn't expire in ten minutes. If a decision is truly yours to make, you should be allowed to sleep on it.
- Check for "The Or." If the choice is "Do X or suffer Y," it isn't volition. It’s an ultimatum. Understanding the difference can save you thousands in legal fees or years of regret.
- Document the lead-up. If you are resigning, for example, and you feel forced, write down the events that led to that "voluntary" decision. Keep a paper trail of the "why" behind the "what."
The phrase on his own volition is often used as a shield by organizations to deflect responsibility. "He left on his own volition, so we aren't responsible for his lost wages." "She spoke on her own volition, so the testimony is valid."
Don't let the fancy wording distract you from the reality of the situation.
Practical Steps Moving Forward
If you are currently facing a decision that feels "forced" but is being labeled as "voluntary," here is what you should do immediately.
First, clarify the alternatives in writing. Send an email saying, "To clarify, my options are to resign or be terminated?" If they refuse to put it in writing, that is a massive red flag.
Second, consult an expert if the stakes are high. Whether it's a lawyer for a contract or a mentor for a career move, getting an outside perspective helps you determine if your "volition" is actually being steered by someone else's agenda.
Third, trust your gut. If you feel like you're being pushed into a "voluntary" action, you probably are. True volition feels like a choice, not a trap.
Ultimately, your will is your own. It is the one thing no one can truly take from you, though they will certainly try to influence it. Protecting your right to act on your own volition starts with recognizing when that right is being nudged, prodded, or outright ignored.
Understand the term. Watch for the tactics. Keep your agency intact.