Honestly, the internet has been trying to pin down Olivia Ponton’s love life since the Hype House days. It’s a lot. If you’ve followed her for a while, you probably remember the Kio Cyr era or when she basically became the face of "pansexual joy" with her ex-girlfriend, Kaila Novak. But 2024 changed the script entirely.
People aren't really searching for an "Olivia Ponton girlfriend 2024" because she’s dating a woman. They’re searching because the rumors shifted toward one of the biggest names in the NFL.
The Burglary That Changed Everything
Life is weird. In December 2024, Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow had his home broken into while he was away playing in Dallas. You’d expect the news to be about the security system or the stolen items. Instead, the police report dropped a bombshell: the person who found the break-in and called 911 was Olivia Ponton.
She was right there. At his house. In Ohio.
The report initially tried to play it cool, labeling her as an "employee" of Burrow. Yeah, okay. Fans didn't buy that for a second. Why would a high-profile Sports Illustrated model be working a 9-to-5 for a quarterback? Insiders quickly leaked to People that the two had actually been "hooking up" since the fall of 2024.
🔗 Read more: Celebrities Born on September 24: Why This Specific Birthday Breeds Creative Giants
From Kaila Novak to the NFL
For a long time, Olivia was half of one of TikTok’s favorite queer power couples. Her relationship with Kaila Novak was public, loud, and very sweet. When they broke up, it left a gap in the "lesbian side of TikTok" that fans were desperate to fill.
That's why the jump to Joe Burrow caused such a stir.
Olivia has been very open about being pansexual. She’s told Sports Illustrated and Teen Vogue that her attraction isn't limited by gender. Yet, when the Burrow rumors took off, some corners of the internet got weirdly protective. There were accusations of "queerbaiting," which, if we’re being real, is a pretty harsh thing to say about someone who has been out and proud for years.
She hasn't stopped being queer just because she’s linked to a man. Sexuality is fluid. She’s literally said that herself a dozen times.
💡 You might also like: Brooks Nader Naked: What Really Happened with That Sheer Dress Controversy
Keeping the "Booked and Busy" Energy
While everyone was obsessing over her relationship status, Olivia was busy rebranding. 2024 was the year she stopped being "just a TikToker" and started becoming a mogul. She launched her podcast, Booked and Busy, which is basically a giant digital book club.
It’s kind of refreshing. Instead of fueling the fire with "soft launch" photos of a boyfriend or girlfriend, she’s talking about Colleen Hoover and Fourth Wing.
Where They Stand Now
So, who is the Olivia Ponton girlfriend 2024? Technically, there isn't one. All signs point to her being with Joe Burrow, though they are playing it extremely safe.
Throughout 2025, they were spotted together at:
📖 Related: Brooklyn and Bailey Nose Job: What Really Happened with Those Plastic Surgery Rumors
- The F1 Miami Grand Prix.
- Met Gala after-parties (they arrived separately but left together).
- Random 3 a.m. walks in New York City.
They haven't done the "Instagram Official" post. They might never do it. Olivia recently told Elite Daily that her first public relationship taught her a hard lesson: when you let the world in, they don't leave when things get messy. She’s choosing privacy this time.
Why the Mystery Matters
We live in an era where influencers share their entire lives, from their morning coffee to their breakups. Olivia’s shift toward a "private but not secret" relationship reflects a bigger trend among Gen Z celebs. They’re tired. They want a life that belongs to them, not their followers.
Whether she’s dating a girl, a guy, or just her stacks of books, Olivia seems the most grounded she’s ever been.
Actionable Insights for Following Celeb News:
- Check the source: If a "dating" story comes from a police report (like the Burrow/Ponton break-in), it's usually more reliable than a random TikTok theory.
- Respect the labels: Being pansexual means attraction to all genders; linking her to a man doesn't "cancel out" her previous relationships with women.
- Follow the projects: If you want to know what Olivia is actually thinking, listen to her podcast Booked and Busy. She shares more truth there than in any paparazzi photo.