If you were glued to MTV in the late 2000s, you remember the "villain." Not the Spencer Pratt kind of villain with the crystals and the erratic shouting matches, but someone far more chillingly effective. I’m talking about Olivia from The Hills—or, more accurately, the breakout star of its sister show, The City.
Olivia Palermo didn't just walk onto a reality set; she glided. She was the antithesis of the messy, mascara-streaked drama we saw in Hollywood. While Lauren Conrad was crying over "the boy who didn't go to Paris," Olivia was in New York, subtly rolling her eyes at Whitney Port while wearing a perfectly tailored blazer. She was the girl we loved to hate because she was just so composed.
But here’s the thing. Almost everything we think we know about her time on that show was a masterclass in reality TV editing and strategic branding.
The Myth of Olivia from The Hills
First, let's clear up the biggest misconception. People always search for "Olivia from The Hills," but she was never actually a main cast member on the original L.A. series. She was the co-star and primary "antagonist" of the spin-off, The City, which followed Whitney Port to New York in 2008.
The confusion is understandable. The shows shared the same DNA—the sweeping shots of skylines, the moody indie-pop soundtracks, and that specific Adam DiVello "cinematic" look. Olivia appeared in the orbit of The Hills world as the socialite-slash-colleague at Diane von Fürstenberg.
She was presented as the "Upper East Side Princess" who didn't want to work. But if you look back at the footage now, you see something different. You see a woman who was acutely aware of the cameras and was playing a very specific role.
👉 See also: Why Taylor Swift People Mag Covers Actually Define Her Career Eras
That Famous Feud with Erin Kaplan
The real meat of the show wasn't actually Whitney’s romance with Jay Lyon (the guy with the long hair and the guitar). It was the workplace warfare between Olivia Palermo and Erin Kaplan, the then-Director of Public Relations at Elle.
It was fascinating.
Erin was the hard-working, no-nonsense career woman. Olivia was the socialite who seemingly glided into a prestigious accessories department job. Their interactions were legendary for their coldness.
- Erin would give a task.
- Olivia would do it her own way.
- The silence in those Elle offices was loud enough to break a window.
Most people thought it was all scripted. Honestly, though? Erin Kaplan has gone on record in years since saying the tension was very much real. The frustration she felt watching Olivia prioritize "networking" and "socializing" over traditional office grunt work wasn't an act.
But Olivia played the long game. She knew that in the world of 2009, being the "it-girl" was a full-time job.
✨ Don't miss: Does Emmanuel Macron Have Children? The Real Story of the French President’s Family Life
Where is She Now? (The 2026 Reality)
While many of her MTV peers ended up doing podcasts about their old episodes or appearing on The Hills: New Beginnings, Olivia Palermo stayed far, far away. She did what very few reality stars manage to do: she transitioned into a legitimate fashion powerhouse.
She didn't need a reboot.
By the time 2021 rolled around, she launched Olivia Palermo Beauty. It wasn't just another celebrity cash grab. She spent years building a digital editorial platform (oliviapalermo.com) and collaborating with brands like Karl Lagerfeld and Banana Republic. She became a fixture on the front row of every major fashion week from Milan to Paris.
In 2026, her influence is still tangible. She’s essentially the blueprint for the modern "influencer," but with a layer of old-school Manhattan prestige that you can't just buy with a ring light and a TikTok account.
What People Get Wrong About Her "Villain" Era
- The "Lazy" Narrative: The show portrayed her as someone who didn't want to work. In reality, she was using the platform to build a personal brand before "personal brand" was even a buzzword.
- The Socialite Scandal: Before the show, there was a whole controversy involving a website called Socialite Rank and a letter she allegedly wrote to her peers. She’s mostly moved past it, but that "mean girl" reputation followed her into the MTV casting room.
- The Relationship: Unlike the fleeting romances on The Hills, Olivia has been with her husband, German model Johannes Huebl, since 2008. They are the definition of "quiet luxury" before the term went viral.
The Actionable Takeaway from the Olivia Era
There is actually a career lesson hidden in the drama of The City.
🔗 Read more: Judge Dana and Keith Cutler: What Most People Get Wrong About TV’s Favorite Legal Couple
Olivia understood leverage. She knew that being the "villain" on a reality show was a temporary gig. She used the visibility to pivot into the industry she actually cared about: high fashion.
If you’re looking to follow her lead (minus the cold stares at coworkers), focus on these three things:
- Curate your image strictly. Olivia never let the show see her "unraveled." Control your own narrative.
- Network up. She spent her time at events, not at dive bars.
- Diversify. Don't just be one thing. She’s a model, an editor, a founder, and a creative director.
The next time you’re rewatching old clips of Olivia from The Hills (or The City), look past the scripted arguments. Look at the way she was building a business while everyone else was just filming a TV show. It’s a completely different experience when you realize she was the one winning the game the whole time.
Check out the archives of Elle or Vogue from the early 2010s to see her early editorial work. It’s a masterclass in how to turn 15 minutes of fame into a decades-long career.