Eagle, Idaho isn't exactly where you'd expect a cultural firestorm to ignite. It’s a quiet, affluent suburb of Boise, known more for its sprawling horse properties and manicured greenbelts than for high-stakes political drama. But if you’ve been online lately, you’ve likely seen the Old State Saloon Idaho trending for reasons that have very little to do with its selection of whiskey or the quality of its live music.
Honestly, it’s a weird situation.
The bar, owned by Mark S. Johnson, has basically become a lighthouse for "anti-woke" sentiment in the Pacific Northwest. It’s not just a place to grab a drink anymore. It’s a statement. People are driving from states away just to sit in a booth there, while locals are deeply divided over whether the establishment is a bastion of free speech or a magnet for exclusionary rhetoric.
What’s Actually Happening at the Old State Saloon Idaho?
Most people think this started with a single event. It didn't. It’s been a slow burn of intentional branding.
Last year, the saloon made headlines for its "Heterosexual Awesomeness Month" in June. This was a direct, pointed response to Pride Month. They offered discounts to heterosexual couples, and the internet did what the internet does—it exploded. Some saw it as a cheeky joke or a stand for traditional values. Others saw it as a targeted middle finger to the LGBTQ+ community.
You’ve got to understand the geography here to get why this matters. Idaho is a deep red state, but Boise and its surrounding areas like Eagle are seeing a massive influx of people from California, Oregon, and Washington. There is a tangible tension between "Old Idaho" and "New Idaho." The Old State Saloon Idaho has positioned itself right in the middle of that friction.
It’s bold. It’s loud. And from a business perspective? It’s working, even if it’s making a lot of neighbors uncomfortable.
The Marketing Genius (or Madness) of Mark Johnson
Mark Johnson isn't just a bar owner. He’s a former police officer and a man who clearly understands the power of the "outrage economy." He knows that in 2026, nothing sells a beer faster than a viral controversy.
When the saloon announced their heterosexuality-themed month, they didn't back down when the backlash hit. They leaned in. They posted more. They doubled down on the "traditional values" messaging. They even hosted a "Hetero Couples Night" that allegedly saw record-breaking crowds.
But it’s not all just social media posts. The physical space of the Old State Saloon Idaho is designed to feel like a throwback. It’s located in a historic building that used to be a bank. It has that heavy, woody, "good old days" vibe. When you walk in, you’re greeted by decor that leans heavily into Americana. It’s an aesthetic that screams "we don't change for anyone."
🔗 Read more: Finding the Right Word That Starts With AJ for Games and Everyday Writing
Here is the thing: Most bars try to appeal to everyone. They want the widest possible customer base. Johnson took the opposite approach. He chose a niche. He basically said, "If you don't like my politics, don't come here."
That’s a risky move for a small business. In a town of 30,000 people, you usually can't afford to alienate half your potential customers. But the Old State Saloon Idaho isn't just relying on Eagle locals anymore. They’ve become a destination for the "Greater Idaho" movement and conservative tourists.
The Controversy That Wouldn't Die
You might be wondering if this is just about one month in the summer. It isn't. The saloon stays in the news because they keep poking the bear.
Whether it's hosting political rallies for far-right candidates or making public statements about local school board elections, the bar has transformed into a quasi-political headquarters. This has led to some pretty intense scenes. There have been protests outside the doors. There have been counter-protests. There was even a brief period where the bar claimed it was being "targeted" by local authorities for permit violations, which they framed as political persecution.
Is it persecution? Or is it just a bar owner who likes to skirt the rules?
Depending on who you ask in Eagle, you’ll get two completely different answers. To his supporters, Johnson is a hero fighting for the First Amendment. To his detractors, he’s a provocateur who is damaging the reputation of a peaceful town.
The Impact on the Eagle Community
It’s kinda sad, actually. Eagle used to be a place where everyone just got along because nobody talked about politics at the dinner table. Now? The Old State Saloon Idaho is a litmus test.
If you’re seen there, people assume things about you. If you refuse to go there, people also assume things about you. It has created this micro-climate of polarization.
- Local businesses around the saloon have had to deal with the overflow of crowds and the occasional chaos of protests.
- The City of Eagle has had to navigate the tricky legal waters of regulating a business that is constantly in the spotlight.
- Real estate agents have even mentioned that the "vibe" of downtown Eagle has shifted, which affects how they pitch the area to newcomers.
Honestly, the bar is a perfect case study in how national "culture wars" are no longer just happening on cable news. They are happening at your local watering hole. They are happening on your street corner.
💡 You might also like: Is there actually a legal age to stay home alone? What parents need to know
Why This Matters Beyond Idaho
You might think, "Who cares about a bar in Idaho?"
Well, you should. The Old State Saloon Idaho is a blueprint. We are seeing more and more businesses adopt this "identity-first" model. We see it with Black Rifle Coffee on one side and brands like Ben & Jerry's on the other. But seeing it play out in a brick-and-mortar bar in a small town is different. It’s more personal. It’s more visceral.
The success of the saloon proves that "rage-baiting" is a viable business strategy for local service industries. If you can make enough people angry, you will eventually find enough people who want to support you just to spite the people who are angry. It’s a feedback loop of tribalism that is incredibly hard to break.
Visiting the Old State Saloon Idaho: What to Expect
If you actually go there—not to protest, but just to see what the fuss is about—it’s a bit of a surreal experience.
The building itself is beautiful. It’s the old Eagle State Bank building, built in 1904. It’s got that classic sandstone architecture that looks like it belongs in a Western movie. Inside, the bar is well-stocked. They have a solid rotation of local Idaho brews.
But you can't escape the politics.
There are signs. There are conversations happening at the bar that are definitely not about the weather. It’s an environment where the "us vs. them" mentality is baked into the atmosphere. If you’re a conservative who feels like the world has gone crazy, you’ll probably feel like you’ve found your people. If you’re a liberal or even a moderate who just wants a quiet IPA, you’ll likely feel like an interloper.
They do have "Family Days." They do have live music nights where the bands are actually quite good. But everything is filtered through the lens of the bar’s reputation.
The Financial Reality
Is the Old State Saloon Idaho actually profitable?
📖 Related: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
That’s the million-dollar question. While they seem to have huge crowds during their big events, some local reports suggest that their weekday traffic has dipped. Some long-time regulars, people who had been going to that building for decades through different iterations of bars, have stopped coming. They just don't want the drama.
However, the saloon has launched an online merchandise store. They sell shirts, hats, and stickers with their logo and various "traditional" slogans. This allows them to monetize their fame far beyond the borders of Idaho. They aren't just selling beer; they are selling a brand.
Misconceptions and Rumors
Let’s clear some stuff up because the internet is a game of telephone.
- Is it a "Hate Group" hangout? The bar has been accused of this by various activist groups. While some patrons certainly hold extreme views, the bar officially maintains it is simply "pro-heterosexual" and "pro-tradition." There is a fine line there that they walk very carefully to avoid legal trouble.
- Did they lose their liquor license? There have been many rumors about this. As of now, they are still operating. They’ve had skirmishes with the liquor board over various minor infractions, but nothing that has shut them down permanently.
- Is it "Members Only"? No. It is a public bar. Anyone of age can walk in.
What Happens Next?
The Old State Saloon Idaho isn't going anywhere. Mark Johnson seems to thrive on the attention. He’s essentially become a local celebrity, or a local villain, depending on your Facebook feed.
As we move further into 2026, expect more "themed" months. Expect more viral videos of confrontations in the parking lot. This is the new normal for Eagle.
If you’re planning to visit or if you’re just watching from afar, here are some actionable ways to process what’s happening at the saloon:
- Look past the headlines. Both the bar’s own social media and the activist groups protesting them use "loaded" language. Try to find raw video or first-hand accounts that aren't edited to fit a narrative.
- Support the local area, not just the drama. If you visit Eagle to see the bar, make sure you also stop at the other local businesses that are caught in the crossfire. The coffee shops, the boutiques, and the other restaurants in downtown Eagle deserve support too.
- Understand the "Greater Idaho" context. To understand why this bar has so much support, you need to read up on the movement of eastern Oregon counties trying to join Idaho. The saloon is a symptom of a much larger regional desire for a "conservative sanctuary."
- Keep it civil. If you do go, remember that Eagle is a real town where real people live. The servers at the bar are just trying to make a living, and the people living in the apartments nearby just want to sleep at night.
The Old State Saloon Idaho is a lot of things. It’s a bar. It’s a bank building. It’s a political statement. It’s a marketing masterclass. But mostly, it’s a mirror. It shows us exactly where we are as a country right now—divided, loud, and looking for a place where we feel like we belong, even if that means making everyone else feel like they don't.
If you want to understand the modern American West, don't look at the mountains. Look at the bars. They’ll tell you everything you need to know.
To stay truly informed on this specific situation, you should follow local Boise news outlets like KTVB or the Idaho Statesman rather than national aggregate sites. National news tends to flatten the nuance, whereas the local reporters actually know the history of the building and the players involved. Also, checking the public records of the Eagle City Council meetings can give you the real "boring" truth behind the permit battles that the social media posts often sensationalize.