Walk into the St. Regis at 55th and Fifth, and you’re basically stepping into a time machine that smells like expensive cologne and history. You’ve probably heard of the Old King Cole Bar NYC, but honestly, most people just think of it as that "expensive hotel bar" where the Bloody Mary was born. It’s so much more than a cocktail origin story. It is a room where the walls actually talk, mostly because Maxfield Parrish painted a giant, flatulent king on them back in 1906.
The vibe is dark wood, dim lights, and the kind of hushed reverence you usually find in a cathedral, except here, the communion is a thirty-dollar martini. It’s a weirdly democratic space in a very undemocratic way. You’ll see titans of industry sitting three feet away from a couple on their first "fancy" date, and everyone is staring at the same thing: that massive mural.
The Mural, The Myth, and the Royal Gas
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room—or rather, the King on the wall. The centerpiece of the Old King Cole Bar NYC is the massive 30-foot mural by Maxfield Parrish. It wasn’t originally painted for this spot; it was commissioned by John Jacob Astor IV for his Knickerbocker Hotel. When that place folded, the mural did a little tour of the city before landing at the St. Regis in the 1930s.
Parrish was a master of color, but he also had a sense of humor that most people miss because they’re too busy looking at their phones. Look closely at the faces of the courtiers surrounding King Cole. They’re smirking. Why? The local legend, which has been whispered by bartenders for decades, is that the King has just... let one rip. Parrish supposedly wasn't thrilled with the commission or the pay, so he painted the King with a very specific, satisfied expression of relief, while the guards hold back their laughter. It’s a multi-million dollar joke hidden in plain sight in one of the world's most sophisticated rooms.
The scale of the work is staggering. It creates a warmth that shouldn't exist in a room with such high ceilings and heavy mahogany. You aren't just drinking in a bar; you’re drinking inside a piece of American art history.
👉 See also: Richmond Extended Weather Forecast: Why January Always Keeps Us Guessing
Red Snappers and the 1934 Revolution
You cannot mention the Old King Cole Bar NYC without talking about the Bloody Mary. Except, if you want to sound like you know what you’re doing, you call it the Red Snapper.
The story goes that Fernand Petiot brought the recipe over from Harry’s New York Bar in Paris in the early 1930s. He refined it here, adding salt, pepper, lemon, and Worcestershire sauce to the vodka-tomato mix. Why the name change? Apparently, the St. Regis management felt "Bloody Mary" was way too vulgar for their high-society clientele. It stayed the Red Snapper on the menu for decades.
Honestly, the drink itself is a polarizing experience. Some people find it too spicy; others think it’s the gold standard. It’s served in a tall glass, rimmed with salt, and usually accompanied by a tiny sidecar of beer or just a very serious garnish. It is thick. It is savory. It costs about as much as a decent steak in the suburbs. But you’re paying for the lineage. You’re drinking the exact evolution of a cocktail that conquered every brunch menu on the planet.
📖 Related: Why Bang Hairstyles Short Hair Are Making a Massive Comeback (And How to Not Regret Them)
The Unwritten Rules of the Room
This isn't a place where you "grab a drink." You inhabit the space.
There is a dress code, though it’s more "vibe-based" than it used to be. Don't show up in gym shorts. You don't need a tuxedo, but if you look like you just rolled out of a subway grate, the host will have a very polite, very firm conversation with you. It’s about respect for the room.
The seating is a tactical game. The bar stools are the prize. From there, you get the best view of the mural and the theater of the bartenders. These guys are pros. They aren't "mixologists" who take twenty minutes to burn a piece of rosemary; they are classic New York bartenders who move with a terrifying efficiency. They’ve seen everything from Salvador Dalí (who was a regular) to modern Hollywood royalty.
- The Best Time to Go: Aim for 4:00 PM on a Tuesday. The post-work rush hasn't hit, and the light hitting the mural is perfect.
- The Seating Trick: If the bar is full, don't just stand awkwardly. There’s a small lounge area, but the real power move is waiting for a corner table where you can people-watch both the entrance and the bar.
- The Order: If you hate tomato juice, get the Vesper. It feels right in this environment.
Why It Survived When Others Didn't
New York eats its legends. We lost the original Four Seasons. We lost the Campbell Apartment (sort of—it’s different now). But the Old King Cole Bar NYC persists because it refused to modernize.
In the 90s and early 2000s, there was this massive push for "ultra-lounges" with neon lights and loud bass. The St. Regis stayed brown. It stayed quiet. It stayed expensive. By refusing to chase trends, it became timeless.
👉 See also: Low Maintenance Men's Short Haircuts for Thin Hair That Actually Work
There’s a specific kind of silence in this bar that you don't get elsewhere. The heavy carpets and the thick drapes soak up the city's noise. You could be in 1945 or 2026; once the door shuts behind you, the timeline blurs. It’s one of the few places left in Manhattan where the "Old Money" aesthetic doesn't feel like a costume. It’s just the DNA of the building.
What Most People Get Wrong
A common misconception is that this is a tourist trap. Sure, tourists go there, but they usually leave after one drink because of the price tag. The "real" Old King Cole experience is the regulars. You’ll see people who have been sitting in the same chairs for thirty years. They know the bartenders' kids' names.
Another mistake? Thinking you need a reservation. They don't take them for the bar. It’s first-come, first-served. This creates a weirdly frantic energy at the velvet rope during peak hours. If you see a line, don't bail immediately. It moves faster than you think because people realize quickly that they can't afford a second round.
Practical Steps for Your Visit
If you’re planning to drop some cash at the Old King Cole Bar NYC, do it right. Don't just wander in.
- Check the Mural Lighting: The painting is cleaned and lit in a way that changes throughout the day. Go while there's still a hint of daylight outside to see the gold leaf pop.
- Budget Accordingly: Look, a round for two with a tip is going to run you $80-$100. Minimum. Accept it before you walk in so you aren't checking your bank app at the table. It ruins the vibe.
- Engage the Staff: Ask about the "hidden" details in the mural. The staff is trained on the history, and if it’s not too busy, they’ll tell you things about the Astor family that aren't in the brochures.
- Eat Elsewhere: The bar snacks are great (those olives are dangerous), but this is a drinking den. Use it for a pre-dinner aperitif or a nightcap. For a full meal, you're better off hitting one of the nearby spots in Midtown where you aren't paying a "mural tax" on your entrée.
The Old King Cole Bar isn't just a place to get a drink; it's a place to witness the version of New York that usually only exists in black-and-white movies. It’s expensive, it’s a bit snobby, and it’s absolutely worth it for the sheer audacity of that painting.
When you leave and step back out onto 5th Avenue, the noise of the taxis and the glare of the LEDs will feel a lot harsher. That’s the sign of a good bar. It creates a world you don't actually want to leave.