In the late summer of 2017, Sam Presti pulled another rabbit out of his hat. It felt like magic. Just weeks after snagging Paul George, the Oklahoma City Thunder traded for Carmelo Anthony, sending Enes Kanter, Doug McDermott, and a second-round pick to the Knicks. Suddenly, OKC had a "Big Three." On paper, it was a terrifying lineup. Russell Westbrook was the reigning MVP. Paul George was a two-way superstar. Carmelo was... well, he was Melo. One of the greatest scorers to ever touch a basketball.
The city went wild. You might remember the "Hoodie Melo" hype. The videos of him training in a sweatshirt, looking like an assassin. Fans thought they were getting the Olympic version of Anthony—the guy who could space the floor and knock down open jumpers while Russ and PG collapsed the defense.
💡 You might also like: Why the Nürburgring Langstrecken Serie 2025 matters more than ever for real racing fans
It didn't go that way. Honestly, it was a mess.
The Carmelo Anthony Oklahoma City Thunder Experiment
Looking back, the fit was doomed before it started. Carmelo Anthony joined the Oklahoma City Thunder just days before training camp. According to Paul George, coach Billy Donovan already had a full offensive scheme built around two stars. Then Melo arrived. Donovan basically told them to "find their way."
That’s not a plan. That’s a prayer.
The numbers from that 2017-2018 season are jarring. Anthony averaged a career-low 16.2 points per game. His field goal percentage plummeted to 40.4%. For a guy whose entire brand was efficiency in the mid-range, he couldn't find his rhythm. He was playing the "power forward" role, which he’d resisted for years, but he wasn't doing the dirty work. He wasn't a rim protector. He wasn't a fast-break threat. He was just a statue waiting for a pass that often came too late in the shot clock.
The "Ay P, they say I gotta come off the bench" quote became a meme, but it reflected a deeper reality. Melo wasn't ready to be a role player. He still saw himself as the guy who took the last shot. In OKC, he was often the guy who didn't even touch the ball for three straight possessions.
Why the Playoffs Exposed Everything
If the regular season was a struggle, the playoffs were a disaster. The Thunder faced the Utah Jazz in the first round. A rookie Donovan Mitchell and Rudy Gobert essentially played Melo off the floor.
The Jazz hunted him. They ran pick-and-rolls specifically to switch Mitchell onto Anthony. It was painful to watch. Every time Utah needed a bucket, they just looked for wherever #7 was standing. In Game 5, the Thunder actually staged a massive 25-point comeback to save their season. Want to know the kicker? Most of that comeback happened while Carmelo was sitting on the bench.
Statistically, the Thunder were outscored by 58 points when he was on the court during that series. When he sat? They outscored Utah by 32.
The Breakup and the Aftermath
The exit was inevitable. Anthony had a player option for $27.9 million. He wasn't leaving that money on the table, but the Thunder couldn't afford the luxury tax hit for a player who didn't fit.
👉 See also: Arnold Palmer Invitational 2025 Leaderboard: Why That Wild Finish at Bay Hill Changed Everything
In July 2018, the Oklahoma City Thunder traded Carmelo Anthony to the Atlanta Hawks in a three-team deal. It was a salary dump. Atlanta never intended to play him; they bought him out immediately, and he eventually landed in Houston (where things got even weirder).
What most people get wrong is blaming Melo’s talent. He still had game. He proved that later in Portland. The problem was timing and ego. OKC needed a "3-and-D" specialist, but they bought a vintage "Iso-Scorer." You can't put premium gas in a diesel engine and expect it to run smooth.
Lessons for Modern Teams
The Melo era in OKC is now a textbook example of why "star power" doesn't always equal "winning basketball." It taught front offices that fit matters more than 2K ratings.
- Role Clarity is Key: You can't ask a Hall of Famer to change his entire identity in three days. Donovan’s lack of a specific "Melo plan" was the first domino to fall.
- Defensive Versatility Trumps Scoring: In the modern NBA, if you can’t switch on a screen, you’re a target. Anthony’s defensive lapses neutralized his offensive contributions.
- The "Third Option" Paradox: Some stars can transition to being a third option (like Chris Bosh or Kevin Love). Others struggle when they don't have the "rhythm" of the ball. Anthony needed the ball to feel the game. Without it, he was cold.
If you’re analyzing the current Thunder roster or any team trying to build a "superteam," look at the Melo experiment as the ultimate warning. It wasn't that he was "washed"—he just wasn't what they needed. To truly understand the impact of that season, you have to look at how it forced the Thunder to eventually pivot toward the massive rebuild they are in today.
Next time you watch a team trade for an aging star, ask yourself: are they getting the player the highlights show, or the player the system actually requires? Usually, it's not the same thing.