You probably expected a track meet. Most people did. When you have Arch Manning making his first official start as the Texas QB1 and Julian Sayin taking the reins for the defending champion Buckeyes, you don't typically bet on a defensive struggle. But the August 30 clash in Columbus was anything but a shootout. It was a grind.
Ohio State vs Texas 2025 was billed as the "Game of the Century" before September even hit. Number 1 versus Number 3. The atmosphere at the Shoe was electric, a sea of scarlet and gray that felt more like a January playoff game than a late August non-conference opener. Yet, the final score of 14-7 suggests a game played in the 1950s, not the high-flying era of modern college football.
The Arch Manning Debut Nobody Expected
Everyone wanted to see the arm. We’ve all seen the highlights of Arch Manning, the Manning scion who waited his turn behind Quinn Ewers. He’s got the pedigree, the size, and the hype. But Matt Patricia—the Buckeyes' defensive coordinator—had a different plan. He turned the game into a chess match where Manning was often the pawn.
💡 You might also like: Did Warriors Play Today: What Really Happened at Chase Center
Texas outgained Ohio State. Honestly, that’s the stat that still bugs Longhorn fans. Texas had 336 total yards to Ohio State's 203. Usually, when you outgain an opponent by over 100 yards, you're booking a flight home with a win. Not this time. Texas went 1-of-5 on fourth downs. That’s where the game was lost.
- Third Quarter Heartbreak: Manning tried a QB sneak on 4th and goal from the 1-yard line. Caden Curry and Lorenzo Styles Jr. weren’t having it. They met him at the line, a wall of Buckeyes that sent a message to the entire SEC.
- The Stats: Manning finished 17-of-30 for 170 yards. He did find Parker Livingstone for a 32-yard touchdown late in the fourth, but it was too little, too late.
Texas fans will point to the penalties. A facemask call on Colin Simmons effectively kept an Ohio State scoring drive alive in the second quarter. Those are the small, ugly moments that change the trajectory of a season.
Julian Sayin and the Buckeyes' "Conservative" Efficiency
Ryan Day didn't ask Julian Sayin to be a hero. He asked him to be a steward. Sayin, a freshman making his first collegiate start, was efficient if not spectacular. He only threw 20 passes. He completed 13.
🔗 Read more: Club world cup teams table: What Really Happened with the 2025 Expansion
The biggest moment? The 40-yard touchdown to Carnell Tate. It was a beautiful ball, honestly. Tate beat Jaylon Guilbeau, juggled it for a split second, and then secured it to put Ohio State up 14-0 in the fourth. That catch effectively ended the suspense, even if Texas made a late push.
Ground Game and Grittiness
CJ Donaldson Jr. did the heavy lifting. 19 carries. 67 yards. One touchdown. It wasn't flashy, but it wore the Texas front down. Ohio State controlled the clock for over 32 minutes. They basically sat on the ball and dared Texas to take it from them.
- Defense Wins Championships: Davison Igbinosun was everywhere. 10 tackles and a game-saving pass breakup in the fourth quarter.
- Special Teams: Joe McGuire’s punting was a weapon. He pinned Texas at their own 2-yard line at one point. That’s how you win close games.
Why Ohio State vs Texas 2025 Matters for the Playoff
This wasn't just a Week 1 game. It was a rematch of the previous season's Cotton Bowl where Ohio State beat Texas 28-14 to reach the National Championship. The fact that Ohio State has now beaten Texas twice in a calendar year (January 2025 and August 2025) is a massive statement of dominance.
The Buckeyes showed they can win without a 300-yard passing performance. That makes them dangerous. If you can win when your offense is stagnant, you're a problem for the rest of the country. For Texas, it’s a lesson in red-zone efficiency. You can’t leave points on the field against a team like Ohio State.
What to Watch Moving Forward
If you're following these two programs, the path doesn't get easier. Ohio State has to keep Sayin's confidence high while slowly opening up the playbook. Texas needs to figure out how to help Manning in short-yardage situations.
📖 Related: University of Oklahoma Football Seating Chart: Why the Palace is Changing
- For Buckeyes Fans: Keep an eye on Jeremiah Smith. He was double-teamed most of the night and only had 43 yards. Expect him to explode against Grambling State.
- For Longhorns Fans: The running game is actually okay. Quintrevion Wisner looked solid with 80 yards. The offense just needs to finish drives.
If you are looking to catch these teams again, remember the ticket market for these high-stakes games moves fast. Check secondary markets like StubHub or SeatGeek early in the week. Also, keep a close watch on the AP Poll; Ohio State’s win likely cements them as the new Number 1.
Check the injury reports for both teams before their next games. High-intensity matches like this often leave players banged up. Specifically, look at the status of the offensive lines, as both units were tested physically throughout the 60 minutes in Columbus.