It was late. The South Bend air felt heavy, like it knew something ridiculous was about to happen. If you were watching the Ohio State vs Notre Dame game in 2023, you remember the silence that hit the stadium when Chip Trayanum plowed into the end zone with literally one second left on the clock. One second. That is the margin between being a legend and being a meme in this series. It wasn't just a win for the Buckeyes; it was a psychological collapse for the Irish and a masterclass in how college football can be both beautiful and incredibly cruel.
People talk about rivalries like Michigan or USC, but there is something distinct about when the Buckeyes and the Irish collide. It’s rare. It’s high-stakes. Honestly, it usually feels like a playoff game happened two months early.
The 10-Man Gaffe That Changed Everything
You can't discuss the Ohio State vs Notre Dame history without talking about the "10-man" disaster. Let’s be real: at this level of football, you expect mistakes, but you don't expect a basic math error to decide a Top 10 matchup. On the final two plays of that 2023 thriller, Notre Dame famously—or infamously—only had ten defenders on the field. Marcus Freeman later owned up to it, admitting they didn't want to take a penalty, but the optics were brutal. You simply cannot give a team like Ohio State an extra gap to exploit when the game is on the line.
Ryan Day’s reaction after that game was arguably more famous than the play itself. He went on a passionate, borderline-angry rant about Lou Holtz, who had questioned Ohio State’s "toughness" earlier that week. It was raw. It was unscripted. It was exactly what fans want to see but rarely get from polished head coaches. That moment cemented the idea that this isn't just a non-conference game; it's a referendum on the identity of two of the most powerful programs in the country.
🔗 Read more: Why Otis Taylor Still Matters: The Kansas City Chiefs Legend Time Forgot
A History of Limited Engagements
Unlike the yearly grind of the Big Ten schedule, the Ohio State vs Notre Dame series is a treat because of its scarcity. Before the home-and-home series in 2022 and 2023, these teams hadn't met in the regular season since the mid-90s. Those 1995 and 1996 games were absolute classics. Eddie George basically secured his Heisman trophy by shredding the Irish defense in '95, rushing for over 200 yards in a performance that older Buckeye fans still talk about like it was a religious experience.
When they do meet, the ratings are astronomical. Why? Because these are the two biggest brands in the Midwest. They recruit the same kids. They occupy the same headspace in the media. When a kid from Cincinnati or Chicago has to choose between Columbus and South Bend, it creates a ripple effect that lasts for four or five years.
Why the Style of Play Matters
If you look at the box scores, these games aren't usually the high-flying, 52-49 track meets you see in the Big 12. They are gritty. They are physical. The Ohio State vs Notre Dame clashes are defined by line-of-scrimmage warfare.
In the 2022 opener in Columbus, the score was a surprisingly low 21-10. People expected C.J. Stroud to put up video game numbers, but Notre Dame’s defense, led by Al Golden, played a shell coverage that forced the Buckeyes to be patient. It was boring for some, but for football purists, it was fascinating to watch Ohio State prove they could win a "boring" game. They had to grind. They had to rely on a defense that had been criticized for years.
- The Recruiting War: Both schools consistently land Top 10 classes.
- The Geography: Only 250 miles separate the two campuses.
- The Stakes: A loss in this game almost always removes the "margin for error" for the College Football Playoff.
Breaking Down the 2023 Tactical Battle
Kyle McCord’s legacy at Ohio State is complicated, but his final drive in South Bend was objectively elite. Facing a 3rd and 19? He converted it. The pressure was suffocating. Notre Dame’s pass rush was getting home, and the crowd was so loud you could barely hear the broadcast.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Reiss ESPN Twitter: Why Fans Actually Trust the Patriots Beat
What's interesting is how Notre Dame's offense evolved during these games. With Sam Hartman at the helm in 2023, they looked more modern, more capable of vertical threats. Yet, when it came down to the final four minutes, they went conservative. They tried to bleed the clock. In hindsight, they left too much time for a team that has future NFL wide receivers all over the field. Emeka Egbuka and Marvin Harrison Jr. didn't have "huge" statistical games by their standards, but their presence alone dictated how Notre Dame had to play defense. It opened up the middle for the tight ends and, eventually, that game-winning run by Trayanum.
The Lou Holtz Factor
We have to talk about the "toughness" narrative. Lou Holtz, the legendary Irish coach, sparked a firestorm by saying Ohio State wasn't a physical team. He pointed to their losses against Michigan. While some saw it as an old coach just supporting his school, it touched a nerve in Columbus.
Ryan Day’s "Where’s Lou Holtz?" post-game interview became an instant classic. It showed the immense pressure these coaches are under. If Day loses that game, the narrative is that he can't win the "big one." If Freeman wins, he’s the new king of college coaching. The swing of emotion in those sixty minutes of game time is enough to age a fan five years.
What to Watch for in Future Matchups
As the college football landscape shifts with conference realignment, games like Ohio State vs Notre Dame become even more precious. With the Big Ten expanding and the playoff moving to 12 teams, the "penalty" for losing this game isn't as death-defying as it used to be. But the prestige? That hasn't changed.
- Quarterback Development: These games are usually the first "real" test for new starters.
- Red Zone Efficiency: In the last two meetings, the winner was the team that didn't settle for field goals.
- Adjustments: Watch how the defensive coordinators react after the first quarter. Both Jim Knowles and Al Golden are chess masters.
The reality is that Notre Dame needs these games for their SOS (Strength of Schedule) more than Ohio State does, given the Buckeyes' grueling Big Ten slate. But for Ohio State, it's a chance to plant a flag in "Golden Domer" territory and tell the world they own the Midwest.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans and Analysts
If you are looking at the Ohio State vs Notre Dame matchup from a betting or analytical perspective, stop looking at the blowout wins they have against lesser opponents. Those don't matter. Look at how they perform in "Late Down" situations.
- Check the Trenches: Look at the returning starters on the offensive line. This game is always won by the team that can run the ball when the defense knows a run is coming.
- Monitor Injury Reports: Because these games often happen in September, a lingering hamstring injury to a star WR can completely flip the point spread.
- Home Field Advantage: South Bend is louder than people think, but the "Shoe" in Columbus is a different beast entirely. The home team has had a significant edge in recent decades.
To truly understand this rivalry, you have to look past the jerseys. It is a clash of cultures. It is the public university powerhouse versus the private, independent institution with a global following. It is "Hang on Sloopy" versus the "Victory Clog."
Next time these two programs are scheduled to meet, clear your calendar. Don't look at the stats from the week before. Just watch the first five minutes. You’ll see the speed, the hitting, and the pure desperation from both sidelines. That is what college football is supposed to feel like.
Next Steps for the Savvy Fan:
Review the historical recruiting crossover between these two programs on sites like 247Sports to see which players "flipped" from one to the other—it adds a layer of spice to the on-field trash talk. Additionally, watch the condensed "All-22" film of the 2023 final drive to see exactly how the Buckeyes exploited the missing 11th man; it’s a masterclass in situational awareness that Every coach in America now uses as a cautionary tale.