You know, being the quarterback at Ohio State isn't just a job. It’s basically a high-stakes residency where 100,000 people are watching your every move, and if you lose to Michigan, they might forget your name by Monday. Honestly, the Ohio State starting QB history is a wild ride that’s shifted from "three yards and a cloud of dust" to a literal NFL factory in less than two decades.
People think it started with the modern era. It didn't.
But if you want to understand why the Buckeyes are where they are today—fresh off a 2024 National Championship and currently riding the Julian Sayin wave—you've gotta look at how the DNA of the position changed. We went from gritty game managers like Craig Krenzel to guys who throw for 400 yards while barely breaking a sweat.
The Era of Gritty Winners: Krenzel to Troy Smith
Back in 2002, nobody was asking for a 5,000-yard passer. Craig Krenzel was basically a bio-molecular engineering major who happened to be really good at not losing. He wasn't flashy. But he won. He took the Buckeyes to a national title against a Miami team that looked like an NFL Pro Bowl roster.
Then came Troy Smith.
Troy changed everything. Before him, Ohio State quarterbacks were mostly there to hand the ball off to legendary backs like Archie Griffin or Eddie George. Smith was different. He was the first guy who made you feel like the QB was the most dangerous athlete on the field. In 2006, he won the Heisman by the largest margin ever at the time. He was 3-0 against Michigan. If you want to be a legend in Columbus, that’s the blueprint.
👉 See also: NFL Fantasy Pick Em: Why Most Fans Lose Money and How to Actually Win
The Transitional Years and the Tattoo Scandal
Things got weird after Smith. Terrelle Pryor was a freak of nature—6'6", ran like a deer, huge arm. But his era is always gonna be stained by "Tattoo-gate." It’s kinda sad because, on the field, Pryor was revolutionary. He was the bridge to the dual-threat era we see now.
When Jim Tressel left and Urban Meyer arrived, the expectations didn't just rise; they exploded.
The Urban Meyer Revolution: Braxton and the Three-Headed Monster
If you didn't live through the 2014 season, I don't know if I can properly explain the chaos. It’s the peak of Ohio State starting QB history.
Braxton Miller was the guy. He was electric. Two-time Big Ten Player of the Year. Then his shoulder gave out. Enter J.T. Barrett. J.T. was a freshman who played like a 30-year-old vet. He broke every record in the book. Then, he broke his leg against Michigan.
Enter Cardale Jones.
✨ Don't miss: Inter Miami vs Toronto: What Really Happened in Their Recent Clashes
Basically, a guy who hadn't started a game all year comes in and beats Wisconsin 59-0, takes down Alabama, and then wins the National Championship against Oregon. Three games. Three wins. One trophy. It was a movie. Honestly, we’ll probably never see anything like that again in college football.
- J.T. Barrett: The most decorated. He stayed for what felt like 12 years.
- Cardale Jones: The "12 Gauge" with the strongest arm in school history.
- Braxton Miller: The most purely athletic, who eventually moved to wide receiver.
The Ryan Day Aerial Show: Haskins to Sayin
When Ryan Day took over the offense, the philosophy shifted. Suddenly, Ohio State was "Quarterback U."
Dwayne Haskins (RIP to a legend) changed the math in 2018. He threw for 50 touchdowns in a single season. 50! Before him, Ohio State fans were happy if a guy threw for 25. Haskins proved that you could run a Pro-Style passing attack in Columbus and absolutely torch the Big Ten.
Then came Justin Fields.
Fields was probably the best overall player to ever take snaps for the Buckeyes. He had the toughness of Krenzel and the arm of Haskins. That 2020 game against Clemson where he took a helmet to the ribs and still threw six touchdowns? That’s the stuff of lore.
🔗 Read more: Matthew Berry Positional Rankings: Why They Still Run the Fantasy Industry
The Recent Timeline (2021-2026)
The last few years have been a rollercoaster of elite talent and massive pressure.
- C.J. Stroud (2021-2022): The most accurate passer I've ever seen. He’s killing it in the NFL now with the Texans, which shouldn't surprise anyone who saw him play.
- Kyle McCord (2023): Led the team to 11-1 but struggled with the weight of the "Michigan game." He eventually transferred to Syracuse.
- Will Howard (2024): The transfer from Kansas State who finally got the Buckeyes back to the mountain top. He wasn't the "prettiest" passer, but he was a winner. He led them to a 14-2 record and the 2024 National Championship.
- Julian Sayin (2025-Present): The "California Kid." He’s currently rewriting the record books. As of early 2026, he’s leading the nation in completion percentage (78.4%) and looks like the next first-round lock.
Why the Michigan Rivalry Defines the History
You can have all the stats in the world, but if your record against "That Team Up North" is bad, the history books treat you differently.
Look at C.J. Stroud. He’s arguably the most talented thrower in Ohio State starting QB history, but he went 0-2 against Michigan. Meanwhile, Craig Krenzel is a god in Ohio because he went 2-1 and won a title. Fans are fickle, sure, but that’s the reality of the Horseshoe.
The pressure is why guys like Joe Burrow left. People forget Burrow was a Buckeye! He couldn't beat out Dwayne Haskins, so he went to LSU and made history there. That’s how deep the talent pool has been lately.
What's Next for the Buckeyes?
We’re in a weird spot now where the "starting QB" isn't just a college kid—they're a brand. Between NIL deals and the transfer portal, the room changes fast. Tavien St. Clair is the next big thing waiting behind Sayin, and the cycle just keeps spinning.
If you're a fan trying to keep track, here is the move:
- Watch the 2014 Season Highlights: If you want to see the soul of the program, that’s it.
- Follow Julian Sayin's 2026 Campaign: He’s on pace to be the most efficient QB in NCAA history.
- Check the NFL Draft: Ohio State QBs are no longer "system players." They are the system.
Honestly, the history of this position is just getting started. We went from a running school to a passing juggernaut in the blink of an eye. If you want to see where the game is going, just look at whoever is wearing number 10 or 3 in Columbus this Saturday.