For decades, the phrase "Ohio State NFL quarterbacks" felt like a punchline to a joke that Buckeye fans didn't find particularly funny. You know the drill. A guy lights up the Big Ten, puts up video game numbers in Columbus, and then hits the pros only to look like a deer in headlights. It became a draft-season tradition. Analysts would wag their fingers, citing the "friendly system" or the "elite talent" surrounding the QB as the reason for their success, rather than the player himself.
But honestly? That vibe is dead. Or at least, it’s on life support.
The 2023-2025 stretch has basically nuked the old "system QB" label from orbit. If you’re still clinging to the idea that an Ohio State helmet means a professional bust, you’re just not watching the Sunday games. We’ve moved from the era of Art Schlichter and Craig Krenzel into a reality where the face of the Houston Texans—and arguably the future of the league—hails from the 614.
C.J. Stroud and the Death of the Buckeye Curse
Let’s talk about C.J. Stroud for a second. When the Houston Texans took him second overall in 2023, the skeptics were out in force. They pointed at Dwayne Haskins' struggles or Justin Fields' shaky start in Chicago as evidence that Stroud was just the next product of a factory that didn’t translate to the NFL.
Stroud didn't just break that narrative; he shattered it.
His 2023 rookie season was historical. We're talking 4,108 passing yards and 23 touchdowns with only five interceptions. You've seen the clips—the poise in the pocket, the way he looks off safeties. It wasn’t just "good for a rookie." It was top-tier veteran stuff.
👉 See also: Tottenham vs FC Barcelona: Why This Matchup Still Matters in 2026
As we look at the data coming out of the 2025 season, Stroud has stayed the course. He finished 2025 with 3,041 yards and 19 touchdowns through 14 games, leading Houston to another winning record. He’s currently sitting on 10,876 career passing yards and a 93.5 passer rating. He’s the undisputed proof that the "Ohio State NFL quarterbacks" label is no longer a warning sign. It’s a stamp of quality.
The Justin Fields Paradox
Then there's Justin Fields. Man, what a wild ride. Fields is the guy everyone uses to argue both sides of the coin.
His time with the Chicago Bears was... messy. He broke the single-game rushing record for a QB with 178 yards, and he became only the third quarterback ever to rush for 1,000 yards in a season. The talent was screamingly obvious. But the wins? The passing consistency? It just wasn't there.
After a stint in Pittsburgh, Fields found himself with the New York Jets for the 2025 season. It's been a tough year for the Jets—they went 3-14—but Fields showed flashes of the old magic before landing on Injured Reserve. He’s got 9,039 career passing yards and 2,892 rushing yards.
The nuance here is that Fields proves Ohio State can produce elite athletes at the position, but the NFL team’s environment matters just as much as the college pedigree. He didn't fail because he went to Ohio State; he struggled because he was dropped into a revolving door of offensive coordinators and sub-par offensive lines.
✨ Don't miss: Buddy Hield Sacramento Kings: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
The Joe Burrow "Technicality"
We have to address the elephant in the room. Does Joe Burrow count?
If you ask an LSU fan, they’ll laugh you out of the room. If you ask a Buckeye fan, they’ll point to his Ohio State degree. Burrow himself has famously said, "I went to school at Ohio State, and I played football at LSU."
Technically, he’s an Ohio State alum. He spent three years in Columbus. He developed under Ryan Day and Urban Meyer. But his "NFL launchpad" was clearly Baton Rouge. Regardless of which side you take, Burrow’s success in Cincinnati—taking them to a Super Bowl and consistently being a top-five QB—further bridges the gap between the Buckeyes' development style and NFL success.
Why the Old Names Still Haunt the Conversation
To understand why people were so down on Ohio State NFL quarterbacks for so long, you have to look at the "graveyard" of the 2000s and 2010s.
- Dwayne Haskins: A tragic story. He was a pure pocket passer who threw for 50 touchdowns in a single season at Ohio State. In Washington, he struggled with the speed of the game and internal team politics. He passed away in 2022 before he could truly find his footing with the Steelers.
- Terrelle Pryor: A freak athlete who was simply ahead of his time. He was a 6'4" dual-threat who eventually had to switch to wide receiver to stay in the league. He did have a 1,000-yard receiving season for Cleveland in 2016, which is an incredible feat for a former QB, but it didn't help the "Buckeye QBs can't throw" narrative.
- Troy Smith: A Heisman winner who just didn't have the size or the system fit in the NFL. He spent a few years with the Ravens and 49ers but never became "the guy."
- Cardale Jones: The "12-gauge" hero of the 2014 National Championship. He had an absolute cannon for an arm but lacked the refined accuracy needed for the pro game.
The Ryan Day Factor: What Changed?
So, why are the modern guys like Stroud doing so much better than the legends of 15 years ago? It comes down to coaching.
🔗 Read more: Why the March Madness 2022 Bracket Still Haunts Your Sports Betting Group Chat
Under Urban Meyer, the Ohio State offense was a power-spread system that relied heavily on the QB being a run threat. It worked in college, but it didn't translate well to the NFL of 2010.
When Ryan Day took over, the offense shifted. It became a pro-style passing attack disguised in college concepts. Day teaches NFL progressions. He teaches his quarterbacks how to read the "middle of the field Open/Closed" looks that they’ll see on Sundays. That’s why Stroud looked so comfortable from Day 1. He wasn't learning a new language in Houston; he was just speaking a faster version of the one he learned in Columbus.
Future Outlook: Who's Next?
The pipeline isn't slowing down. While the 2026 NFL Draft highlights for the Buckeyes are currently leaning toward the defensive side—like linebacker Arvell Reese and safety Caleb Downs—the quarterback room remains a factory.
Names like Julian Sayin are already being discussed by scouts as "the next one." The recruiting hasn't dipped. If anything, Stroud’s success has made Ohio State the premier destination for high school QBs who want to play in the NFL.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
- Scout the System, Not the Helmet: Stop looking at the school and start looking at the offensive scheme. If a QB is coming out of a Ryan Day-led offense, they are likely more "pro-ready" in their progressions than those from traditional "Air Raid" schools.
- Context Matters for Fields: If Justin Fields gets one more shot with a stable coaching staff and a real WR1, don't write him off. His rushing floor alone keeps him fantasy-relevant, even if the "passing project" remains ongoing.
- Stroud is a Tier 1 Asset: In dynasty fantasy football or long-term betting, Stroud is now a cornerstone. He has officially ended the "Buckeye QB" discount.
The narrative is over. Ohio State is no longer a graveyard for quarterbacks. It's a launchpad. If you're still betting against them, you're betting against the reality of the modern NFL.