If you had told an Ohio State fan back in 2023 that they’d be sweating a December matchup against the Indiana Hoosiers, they probably would’ve laughed in your face. Honestly, who wouldn’t? For thirty years, this "rivalry" was basically a scheduled win for the Buckeyes. It was a mathematical certainty. You wake up, you see the Scarlet and Gray on the schedule, and you mark down a "W."
But things changed. Fast.
The 2024 and 2025 seasons didn't just move the needle; they broke the whole speedometer. We’re currently sitting in a reality where Indiana isn't just a "scrappy underdog" or a "trap game." As of early 2026, they are the defending Big Ten Champions. That’s not a typo. Curt Cignetti actually did it.
The 30-Year Wall That Finally Crumbled
To understand why Ohio State and Indiana is the biggest story in the Midwest right now, you have to look at the sheer weight of history. Before the recent shift, the Buckeyes had won 30 straight games against the Hoosiers. The last time Indiana had tasted victory was in 1988.
Think about that.
Gas was about 90 cents a gallon. Rain Man was the big movie. A whole generation of fans grew up never seeing the Hoosiers take down the giant from Columbus. Even in 2024, when Indiana arrived at Ohio Stadium with a perfect 10-0 record, the Buckeyes still handed them a 38-15 reality check. Will Howard was efficient, the defense was suffocating, and it felt like the status quo was safe.
But the status quo was actually rotting.
✨ Don't miss: The Division 2 National Championship Game: How Ferris State Just Redrew the Record Books
The turning point came in the 2025 Big Ten Championship. It was a No. 1 vs. No. 2 clash in Indianapolis. Ohio State brought the stars—the 5-star recruits, the massive NIL collective, the NFL-ready roster. Indiana brought a bunch of transfers and a quarterback named Fernando Mendoza who seemingly refused to believe he was supposed to lose.
Indiana won 13-10.
It wasn't a fluke. It was a grind. Mendoza threw a 17-yard dart to Elijah Sarratt to take the lead, and then he iced the game with a gutsy 33-yarder to Charlie Becker on third down. That win didn't just give Indiana a trophy; it ended the longest active winning streak in a single series in the country.
Why the "Talent Gap" Stopped Mattering
There’s this obsession in college football with recruiting rankings. If you look at the 247Sports Talent Composite, Ohio State and Indiana look like they belong in different universes.
- Ohio State: Usually top 3 nationally. We’re talking 11 five-star players and over 50 four-stars.
- Indiana: Ranked near the bottom of the Big Ten in "raw talent" (around 72nd nationally).
On paper, the Buckeyes should win by 40 every single time. But Cignetti proved that the transfer portal is the great equalizer. He didn't build a team of 18-year-old projects; he built a team of 23-year-old men.
The 2025 Hoosiers defense was essentially a mirror of the Buckeyes'. Both teams allowed exactly 50 points to five common opponents (Illinois, Penn State, Purdue, UCLA, and Wisconsin). While Ryan Day’s squad relied on elite athleticism and "NFL-style" schemes, Indiana used a suffocating, veteran-heavy rush defense that ranked No. 2 in the nation.
🔗 Read more: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
It’s kinda wild to see a team with less talent than UTSA—according to some metrics—beat a roster that cost millions to assemble.
The Academic and Cultural Divide
Beyond the field, these two schools represent the two different faces of the Big Ten. Ohio State is a massive, urban research powerhouse in Columbus with over 65,000 students. It’s got that capital-city energy where the football team is the sun and everything else orbits around it.
Indiana University is the quintessential college town. Bloomington is all about the arts, the Kelley School of Business, and, traditionally, basketball. For years, "IU Football" was something people did to kill time until Midnight Madisness.
Quick Comparison by the Numbers
- Established: IU (1820) vs. OSU (1870).
- Selectivity: OSU is tougher to get into (53% acceptance) compared to IU (82%).
- Research: Both are R1 powerhouses, but OSU spends over $1.2 billion annually, mostly in STEM and Medicine.
- Vibe: OSU is "The Ohio State," a massive institution. IU is "Bloomington," a residential, liberal arts-heavy sanctuary.
The funny thing is that the "basketball school" tag is finally falling off. When you're 13-0 and the No. 1 seed in the College Football Playoff—which Indiana was entering 2026—people stop asking about the Hoosiers' point guard and start asking about their linebacker.
What People Get Wrong About This Rivalry
Most people think Ohio State "choked" in the 2025 championship game. That's the easy narrative. It’s also wrong.
The Buckeyes didn't play poorly; they got out-physically-ed. Indiana held them to 10 points. Ten! In an era of high-octane offenses, Indiana beat Ohio State at their own game: ball control, field position, and a defense that wouldn't break.
💡 You might also like: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
Also, don't sleep on the "Cignetti Effect." The man famously told fans to "Google him" when he took the job. He wasn't joking. He has won everywhere he’s been, and his 24-2 record over the last two seasons at Indiana is arguably the greatest turnaround in the history of the sport.
Actionable Insights for the Future
If you’re a fan or a bettor looking at future matchups between Ohio State and Indiana, here’s what actually matters now:
- Watch the Lines: The days of Indiana being a 20+ point underdog are over. The markets have adjusted to the fact that Cignetti’s defense is elite.
- Follow the QB Health: Fernando Mendoza proved he's the "it" factor for the Hoosiers. His ability to play through injury was the difference in the Big Ten title.
- Recruiting vs. Development: Keep an eye on how Ryan Day responds to the 2025 loss. Does he lean more into the portal, or does he stick to the 5-star high school model?
- Home Field: The 2026 regular-season meeting is scheduled for Bloomington. Memorial Stadium used to be "The Shoe West," packed with Buckeyes fans. That won't happen again. Getting tickets in Bloomington is now officially harder than getting them in Columbus.
The rivalry has officially flipped from a blowout to a chess match. Whether Indiana can sustain this is the big question, but for now, the path to the Big Ten title goes through both Columbus and Bloomington.
Next Steps:
To prepare for the next season, you should track the transfer portal entries for both schools this spring. Specifically, look at the defensive line depth for Ohio State—which struggled to contain Indiana's veteran interior—and check if Mendoza uses his final year of eligibility.
Finally, keep a close watch on the Big Ten's 2026 scheduling. With the conference expansion, these matchups are becoming rarer and higher stakes. You'll want to secure any "away" tickets for the Bloomington game at least six months in advance, as the demand has spiked by nearly 300% since the Hoosiers' championship run.