Getting that email from South Bend feels like a punch to the gut. You’re not in. But you’re not out. You’re stuck in the University of Notre Dame waitlist purgatory, and honestly, it’s a weird place to be. You’ve got the grades. You probably have the extracurriculars that make people tired just looking at them. Yet, here you are, wondering if "waitlist" is just a polite way of saying "thanks, but no thanks."
It isn't. But it’s also not a guaranteed "later."
Notre Dame is a different beast compared to the Ivy League or big state schools. There’s a specific culture there—a mix of high-octane academia and a deeply rooted Catholic identity that prizes community. When the admissions office looks at the waitlist, they aren't just looking for the next smartest kid. They’re looking for the missing piece of a very specific puzzle. If you want to move from the "maybe" pile to the "yes" pile, you have to understand how that puzzle is built.
The Brutal Math of the Notre Dame Waitlist
Let’s talk numbers because numbers don't lie, even if they are a bit depressing. Every year, Notre Dame offers a spot on the waitlist to a few thousand students. A good chunk of them—usually around half—say "no thanks" and head off to Michigan, BC, or Georgetown. That leaves a pool of several hundred, sometimes over a thousand, students sitting by their phones.
The yield is the holy grail for admissions officers. They want to know that if they offer you a spot, you’re coming. Period. In recent cycles, the number of students plucked from the University of Notre Dame waitlist has fluctuated wildly. Some years, it’s a tiny handful—maybe 20 or 30 people. Other years, if their "yield" (the percentage of admitted students who actually enroll) dips unexpectedly, they might go deep and take 100 or more.
Don't bet your future on a 3% chance. You need to fall in love with your "Plan B" school right now. Deposit there. Buy the sweatshirt. If Notre Dame calls in May or June, it’ll be a happy surprise, not a desperate rescue mission.
👉 See also: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
Why You’re Actually on the List
It’s rarely about your SAT score at this point. If you weren't qualified, they would have rejected you outright. Admissions committees use the waitlist to manage the "shape" of the class. Maybe they realized they didn't enroll enough physics majors. Maybe they need more students from the Pacific Northwest to keep their geographic diversity stats looking healthy. Or maybe they just need more people who genuinely want to be part of the campus ministry or the band.
It’s about balance.
If a student from a specific high school in Chicago declines their offer to go to Harvard, the admissions officer might look at the waitlist for another student who fills that same "slot" in their internal projections. It’s a game of musical chairs where the music has stopped, and they’re looking for someone to fill the one empty seat left in the back row.
The Letter of Continued Interest (LOCI) is Your Only Lever
You have exactly one move left. The Letter of Continued Interest.
This isn't the time to be humble, but it’s also definitely not the time to be annoying. If you send a five-page manifesto, they’re going to think you’re high-maintenance. If you send nothing, they’ll assume you’ve moved on. You need to hit that sweet spot of "I am still obsessed with Notre Dame, and here is why I’m a better version of myself than I was three months ago."
✨ Don't miss: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
Be specific. Don't just say you love the "tradition." Everyone says that. Talk about a specific professor's research in the Keough School of Global Affairs. Mention a club like the Notre Dame Rocketry Team or the Bengal Bouts. Show them you’ve done the homework and that you aren't just looking for the prestige—you’re looking for the home.
What to Include (and What to Skip)
- New Grades: If your senior year second-semester grades are legendary, send them. If they slipped, maybe keep that quiet unless they ask.
- New Honors: Did you finally get that Eagle Scout rank? Did you win a state title in debate? This is the "meat" of the letter.
- The "First Choice" Promise: Only say "If admitted, I will enroll" if you actually mean it. Notre Dame takes this seriously. If you tell them they are your absolute number one and then turn them down later, you’re burning bridges for your high school’s future applicants.
- Avoid the "Pity Party": No one likes a whiner. Don’t talk about how heartbroken you were. Focus on the future.
Admissions officers like Don Bishop (who led the department for years) have often emphasized that they look for "fit" and "character." They want people who are going to contribute to the dorm culture—remember, Notre Dame doesn't have Greek life, so the dorms are everything. If you can prove you’re a "dorm person," you’re winning.
The Timeline of Uncertainty
The waiting is the hardest part. You’ll hear from most schools by April 1st. You have to put a deposit down somewhere else by May 1st. Then, the silence begins.
Notre Dame usually starts looking at their waitlist in early to mid-May, once they see how many "intent to enroll" forms actually landed on their desks. If they are under their target of roughly 2,000 freshmen, the phones start ringing. This can drag on into June. In very rare, extreme cases, students have been called in July, but don't count on that.
If you haven't heard by mid-June, it's probably time to fully commit your heart and soul to your backup school.
🔗 Read more: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
Realities of Financial Aid and Housing
Here’s a kicker people don't realize: being admitted off the University of Notre Dame waitlist can sometimes mess with your financial aid package. While Notre Dame is committed to meeting 100% of demonstrated need, the "pot" of discretionary scholarship money might be thinner by June than it was in January.
Housing is another hurdle. Freshmen are required to live on campus. Usually, the university holds back enough spots to accommodate waitlisted students, but you might not get your first choice of dorm (though at ND, you don't really "choose" your dorm anyway—the random assignment is part of the lore).
How to Handle the "No"
If the email eventually comes and it’s a rejection, it’s okay to be mad. For ten minutes. Then, let it go.
The reality is that the difference in your life outcome between attending Notre Dame and attending another top-tier university is effectively zero. Your drive, your curiosity, and your ability to network matter a thousand times more than the name on your diploma. Notre Dame is a spectacular place, but it doesn't own the rights to your success.
Actionable Next Steps for Waitlisted Students
- Accept your spot on the waitlist immediately. If you don't click the link in the portal, you don't exist to them.
- Submit your deposit elsewhere. Do not wait for Notre Dame. You need a guaranteed seat for the fall.
- Draft your LOCI. Keep it to one page. Use a professional but conversational tone. Mention 2-3 specific "new" developments since your application was filed.
- Send one (and only one) updated transcript. Ensure your counselor sends your mid-year or final grades if they show an upward trend.
- Check your email daily. When the waitlist moves, it moves fast. They often give you only 48 to 72 hours to decide if they call you.
- Stay off the forums. Sites like College Confidential or Reddit can be toxic during waitlist season. Everyone’s "uncle's friend who works in admissions" has a different theory. Ignore the noise.
The University of Notre Dame waitlist is a test of patience as much as it is a test of merit. You’ve done the work; now you just have to wait for the math to work in your favor. If it does, great. If it doesn’t, you’re still the same high-achieving student you were before you opened that email. Move forward with that confidence.