Honestly, if you grew up a college football fan in the Northeast or the Midwest during the 80s, the phrase Notre Dame vs Penn State probably does something to your heart rate. It wasn’t just a game. It was a culture clash, a recruiting war, and usually, a de facto national title eliminator all wrapped into one Saturday afternoon in November.
The weirdest part? For nearly twenty years, this rivalry just... stopped.
Aside from a brief home-and-home in 2006 and 2007, and that absolute heart-stopper of a College Football Playoff semifinal in early 2025, these two blue bloods have spent most of the modern era avoiding each other like exes at a grocery store. But with the way the landscape is shifting in 2026, everyone is asking the same thing: Why aren't we playing this every year?
Why the Notre Dame vs Penn State History Hits Different
To understand why fans get so worked up about this, you have to look at the "12-Year War." Between 1981 and 1992, these teams played every single season. It was the peak of independent football. No conferences, no tie-ins—just two giants meeting in the snow to decide who was the king of the East.
The series is famously knotted up. After the Irish took that 27-24 thriller in the Orange Bowl on January 9, 2025, the all-time record stands at a razor-thin margin. We’re talking about over a century of history—starting in 1913—and there is basically no daylight between them.
📖 Related: Why Netball Girls Sri Lanka Are Quietly Dominating Asian Sports
The Games We Still Talk About
- The 1992 "Snow Bowl": This is the one. In what was supposed to be the final annual meeting before Penn State joined the Big Ten, South Bend was hit by a literal blizzard. Rick Mirer threw a touchdown to Jerome Bettis with 20 seconds left, and Lou Holtz—being Lou Holtz—went for two. They got it. Irish won 17-16. It was cinematic.
- The 2007 White Out: This was the birth of a legend. It was the first-ever full-stadium White Out in Beaver Stadium. Penn State absolutely crushed the Irish 31-10. If you ever want to see 110,000 people losing their minds in unison, watch the highlights of Derrick Williams’ punt return from that night.
- The 1990 Upset: Notre Dame was ranked No. 1. Penn State was No. 18. The Nittany Lions walked into South Bend and ruined everything for the Irish with a 24-21 win.
The 2025 CFP Semifinal: A Modern Classic
We can't talk about Notre Dame vs Penn State without mentioning that Orange Bowl matchup from a year ago. It felt like a time machine. You had Nicholas Singleton and Kaytron Allen hammering away for the Nittany Lions, while Riley Leonard was doing everything in his power to keep the Irish alive.
Penn State actually clawed back from a 17-0 deficit to take a lead late in the fourth. It looked like James Franklin was finally going to punch that ticket to the title game. But a 41-yard field goal with seven seconds left broke State College's heart. It reminded everyone that when these two schools meet, the script usually gets thrown out the window.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Rivalry
A lot of younger fans think the "rivalry" is just about geographic proximity. Sorta, but not really. The real heat comes from the recruiting trail.
For decades, if a five-star kid lived in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, or Ohio, it came down to these two. Joe Paterno used to hate losing kids to South Bend. He actually pioneered the "early commitment" strategy specifically to lock up kids before the Irish could fly them out to see the Grotto.
👉 See also: Why Cumberland Valley Boys Basketball Dominates the Mid-Penn (and What’s Next)
Think about the "defectors" Penn State fans still remember:
- Raghib "Rocket" Ismail: A Pennsylvania kid who went to Notre Dame and became a Heisman finalist.
- Ricky Watters: Another Harrisburg legend who chose the golden helmet.
That stuff leaves scars. Even now, with Marcus Freeman recruiting at a high level and Penn State consistently landing top-tier talent, the "us vs. them" mentality in the Mid-Atlantic is very real.
Why the 2026 Landscape Changes Everything
We are in a weird spot right now. Notre Dame just missed the 12-team playoff, and Marcus Freeman is under a microscope to "leave no doubt" in 2026. Meanwhile, Penn State is trying to navigate a Big Ten that looks more like an NFL conference than a college one.
The lack of a scheduled game between them in 2026 is a travesty. Honestly. You have teams playing cross-country "conference" games that mean half as much to the fans as a Notre Dame vs Penn State matchup would.
✨ Don't miss: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026
The Current State of the Programs
| Feature | Notre Dame (2026) | Penn State (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Quarterback | CJ Carr (The Future) | Drew Allar (The Vet) |
| Identity | Elite Defense / Portal WRs | Power Run / Chaos Defense |
| Pressure Meter | High - Needs CFP run | Very High - Needs a Title |
The Irish are banking on a rebuilt wide receiver room featuring guys like Quincy Porter and Mylan Graham. They've realized they can't just rely on tight ends anymore. Penn State, on the other hand, is leaning into their "LBU" roots with Abdul Carter making a massive push for the 2026 NFL Draft.
How to Follow the Next Chapter
Since there isn't a regular-season game on the books for 2026, the only way we see this happen is in the postseason. And with the 12-team (and potentially expanding) playoff, the odds are actually pretty high.
If you're a fan wanting to keep the fire alive:
- Watch the Hockey Series: Surprisingly, the ice is where this rivalry is most active. Penn State just swept the Irish in a "hostile clash" at Pegula Ice Arena in January 2026. The bad blood is definitely there.
- Track the 2027 Recruiting Class: Watch for four-star and five-star battles in the PA/NJ corridor. That's the best indicator of who's winning the "War" right now.
- Lobby for a Series: Both ADs have hinted at future talks, but the schedules are packed. It’s basically going to take a massive TV deal or a playoff bracket to make it happen.
College football is better when the big brands play. Period. The 2025 Orange Bowl proved that the appetite for Notre Dame vs Penn State hasn't faded one bit. Whether it's in a snowy South Bend or a white-out State College, this is the game the sport needs back on the permanent calendar.
If you're tracking the Irish or the Nittany Lions this season, keep an eye on the AP Poll rankings. If they both stay in that 5-10 range, we might just get a January 2027 rematch that rivals the 1992 Snow Bowl. Until then, we're just left with the highlights and the "what ifs."
Actionable Next Step: Check the 2027 non-conference schedules as they are released this summer. Many independent and Big Ten slots for that year remain "To Be Announced," and rumors are swirling about a neutral-site "Kickoff Classic" to get these two back on the field together.