You know the drill. It’s December 23rd. You’re sitting on the sofa, scrolling through a streaming app, and your brother-in-law pipes up with that one specific, exhausting sentence: "You know, Die Hard is actually a Christmas movie."
Suddenly, the living room is a war zone. Half the family is arguing about Nakatomi Plaza, and the other half is trying to figure out if Gremlins counts because of the snowy setting or if it's just a horror flick that happens to feature a bow on a box.
We’ve all been there.
The "not Christmas Christmas movies" phenomenon isn't just a quirky internet meme anymore. It's a full-blown subgenre. These are the films that don't necessarily have a guy in a red suit or a magical reindeer, but they’ve become essential viewing for people who find the usual Hallmark-style sweetness a bit too saccharine.
Why We Fight Over Die Hard (and Why It Matters)
Honestly, Die Hard is the poster child for this whole debate. People get genuinely heated about it. Is it a Christmas movie? If you ask Steven E. de Souza—the guy who literally co-wrote the script—he’ll tell you "yes" without blinking. He’s even joked that it’s more of a Christmas movie than White Christmas because it actually takes place entirely on Christmas Eve.
Think about the evidence. John McClane is a guy traveling across the country to reconcile with his family. That’s like, the most "holiday" trope in the book. Plus, his wife’s name is Holly. The soundtrack is littered with bells and Run-D.M.C.’s "Christmas in Hollis."
Then there’s the opposition. They’ll say it was released in July 1988. It’s an action movie. If you swap the date to the Fourth of July, the plot mostly stays the same, right?
💡 You might also like: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
Not really. Without the office Christmas party, Hans Gruber doesn’t have a room full of hostages to hold over the LAPD's head. The holiday isn't just a backdrop; it’s the catalyst for the entire heist.
The Tim Burton Effect: From Scissorhands to Gotham
If anyone owns the "kinda-sorta-holiday" space, it’s Tim Burton. The man loves a dark, snowy aesthetic.
Batman Returns
This movie is basically a Gothic Christmas pageant. It opens with the Penguin being tossed into a sewer on Christmas Day. It features a tree-lighting ceremony that ends in a kidnapping. Max Shreck is essentially a murderous version of Ebenezer Scrooge.
Yet, most people just remember it as "the one with Danny DeVito and the penguins." But look closer. The entire visual language is built around the contrast between the "joyous" holiday season and the literal filth of the Gotham underground. It uses the holiday to highlight how lonely the outcasts—Bruce, Selina, and Oswald—really are.
Edward Scissorhands
This one is a bit more direct. The whole story is framed as a grandmother telling her granddaughter why it snows on Christmas. The climax happens during a holiday party. The iconic scene of Kim dancing under the ice shavings? That’s pure Christmas magic, even if the ending is heartbreakingly lonely.
Shane Black and the Christmas Obsession
You can't talk about not Christmas Christmas movies without mentioning Shane Black. The man is obsessed. He has a track record that makes you wonder if he had a traumatic experience with a Nutcracker as a kid.
📖 Related: Album Hopes and Fears: Why We Obsess Over Music That Doesn't Exist Yet
- Lethal Weapon: Takes place at Christmas.
- Kiss Kiss Bang Bang: Christmas.
- The Long Kiss Goodnight: Christmas.
- Iron Man 3: Yup, Christmas.
In Iron Man 3, Tony Stark is dealing with PTSD and a literal identity crisis. Shane Black has said he uses the holiday because it provides a "unifying" backdrop. It makes the lonely characters feel lonelier and the reunions feel more earned. Tony giving a gift to the kid who helped him or Happy Hogan waking up from a coma? Those are "Christmas miracles" in a movie about exploding super-soldiers.
The Weird Ones: Eyes Wide Shut and Gremlins
Then we get into the truly debated territory.
Take Gremlins. It’s a horror movie about little green monsters. But Gizmo is a Christmas gift. The movie is a scathing critique of consumerism—the "must-have" toy that turns out to be a nightmare. It even has that devastating monologue from Phoebe Cates about why she hates Christmas (if you know, you know). It’s dark. It’s messy. It’s absolutely a holiday movie.
And then there's Stanley Kubrick’s Eyes Wide Shut. It’s probably the least "family-friendly" movie ever made. But there is a Christmas tree in almost every single scene. Kubrick used the festive lights to create a dreamlike, hazy atmosphere that contrasts with the dark, secret world Tom Cruise’s character wanders into. It’s about the distance between the "perfect" family image we project at Christmas and the messy reality of marriage.
The Psychology of the "Non-Traditional" Watch
Why do we do this? Why do we insist on watching The Nightmare Before Christmas in December when half the world thinks it’s a Halloween movie?
Psychologists actually have a few theories.
👉 See also: The Name of This Band Is Talking Heads: Why This Live Album Still Beats the Studio Records
Movies like Home Alone or The Holiday are "comfort food." They’re predictable. We know the ending. But not Christmas Christmas movies offer a different kind of catharsis. They acknowledge that the holidays aren’t always perfect. They’re often stressful, lonely, or just plain weird.
Watching John McClane crawl through a vent or Edward Scissorhands carve an ice angel feels more "real" to some people than a Hallmark prince finding love in a small town. It's about finding a sense of belonging in the unconventional.
How to Build Your Own Not-So-Festive Marathon
If you're tired of the same old rotation, you've got to branch out. Don't just stick to the obvious ones.
- Start with the Atmosphere: Look for films where the weather is a character. The Hateful Eight is basically three hours of people trapped in a room during a blizzard. Is it a Christmas movie? Probably not. Does it feel like winter? 100%.
- Check the Calendar: Some movies like Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone have such iconic Christmas scenes that they’ve become "holiday by association."
- The "Vibe" Check: If a movie deals with themes of redemption, family reunions, or even just high-stakes parties, it’s eligible for the list.
The reality is that "Christmas movie" is a vibe, not a genre. If a movie makes you feel that specific end-of-the-year melancholy or provides a snowy escape from the world, it counts.
Next Steps for Your Holiday Viewing
If you want to settle the debate for good this year, start by watching Die Hard and Batman Returns back-to-back. Pay attention to the background details—the music, the decorations, and the specific ways the holiday drives the plot forward. You’ll find that these films aren't just using Christmas as a gimmick; they’re using it to tell stories about loneliness and redemption that the "standard" classics often ignore.
From there, you can move into the deeper cuts like In Bruges or Trading Places. Just be prepared to defend your choices when the "purists" start complaining. After all, the argument is half the fun.