It was 2001. Low-rise jeans were a personality trait. Pop-punk ruled the airwaves. And Sony Pictures decided to take every single trope from the 90s teen movie boom—the paint-splattered overalls, the slow-motion stair descents, the "ugly" girl who was actually a supermodel—and set them on fire. The result was Not Another Teen Movie. While critics at the time mostly groaned, the film has aged into a bizarrely high-quality time capsule. Looking back at the Not Another Teenage Movie cast, you realize the scouts for this film had an almost psychic ability to spot future A-listers before they were "somebody."
Seriously. Think about it.
The movie was a relentless skewering of She's All That, Varsity Blues, and 10 Things I Hate About You. But beneath the fart jokes and the whipped cream bikinis, there was a cast that was, frankly, overqualified. They weren't just "parody actors." They were the next generation of Hollywood. Some went on to lead the highest-grossing film franchise in history. Others became cult icons. A few seemingly vanished, only to reappear in prestige TV years later.
The Unstoppable Ascent of Chris Evans
Long before he was Steve Rogers, Chris Evans was Jake Wyler. He was "The Popular Guy."
He spent a significant portion of this movie either in a football uniform or wearing nothing but strategically placed whipped cream. It's wild to watch his performance now. You can see the exact same earnestness he brought to Captain America, just applied to a character who is a total moron. Evans has been vocal about his time on the set, often acknowledging that while the movie was ridiculous, it was his big break. He told Esquire years ago that he felt like he had "won the lottery" just getting the part.
He didn't just play the jock; he played the idea of a jock. That requires a specific kind of comedic timing that many people overlook because of the absurdity of the script. After Not Another Teen Movie, Evans didn't immediately jump to stardom. He paid his dues in thrillers like Cellular and the (now forgotten) Fantastic Four movies of the mid-2000s. But the foundation was laid right here at John Hughes High.
Chyler Leigh and the Janey Briggs Effect
Chyler Leigh had the hardest job in the movie. She had to be Janey Briggs—the "ugly" girl who is actually just a stunning woman in glasses and a ponytail.
👉 See also: Christopher McDonald in Lemonade Mouth: Why This Villain Still Works
If she didn't sell the sincerity of the parody, the whole movie would have collapsed into a heap of cheap gags. Leigh brought a weirdly grounded energy to the role of the rebellious artist. Honestly, the scene where she tries to be "edgy" by painting her feelings is still one of the sharpest takedowns of She's All That ever filmed.
Leigh didn't stay in the comedy lane for long. She pivoted hard into drama. Most fans know her as Lexie Grey on Grey's Anatomy, a role that cemented her as a TV powerhouse. Later, she took on the mantle of Alex Danvers in Supergirl. It's a massive career arc that started with her being mocked for having "paint on her overalls." She’s one of those actors who proves that doing a spoof movie isn't a career killer if you actually have the chops.
The Supporting Players Who Stole the Show
You can't talk about the Not Another Teenage Movie cast without mentioning Jaime Pressly.
As Priscilla, the "Nasty Cheerleader," Pressly was a comedic hurricane. She had this incredible ability to be terrifying and hilarious at the same time. She basically refined this "mean girl" persona and took it all the way to an Emmy win for My Name Is Earl. She understood the assignment perfectly: play it so straight that the audience can't help but laugh at the sheer aggression of the character.
Then there’s Eric Christian Olsen.
He played Austin, the "Cocky Blonde Guy" (a direct riff on Paul Walker in She's All That). Olsen has spent the last decade-plus as a mainstay on NCIS: Los Angeles. If you watch him today, you can still see flashes of that high-energy, slightly unhinged charisma he brought to the parody.
✨ Don't miss: Christian Bale as Bruce Wayne: Why His Performance Still Holds Up in 2026
And we have to talk about Mia Kirshner.
She played Catherine, the "Cruelest Girl." Her character was a pitch-perfect send-up of Sarah Michelle Gellar in Cruel Intentions. Kirshner went from this gross-out comedy to The L Word and Star Trek: Discovery. It’s a testament to the range of the people they hired. They weren't just hiring "funny people"; they were hiring actors who could inhabit a trope and then subvert it.
Why This Cast Worked When Others Failed
Most parody movies from that era—think Epic Movie or Date Movie—are borderline unwatchable today. They relied on pop culture references that expired within six months. Not Another Teen Movie was different. Why? Because the cast treated the source material like Shakespeare.
They didn't wink at the camera.
They played the drama of the "big prom" or the "big game" with 100% commitment. When Ron Lester (who played Reg Ray, parodying his own role in Varsity Blues) collapses on the field, it’s funny because he plays it with the same gravity he did in the original film. It’s a meta-commentary on the genre itself.
The Surprising Cameos and "Before They Were Famous" Faces
Keep your eyes peeled during a rewatch. You’ll see faces that make you do a double-take.
🔗 Read more: Chris Robinson and The Bold and the Beautiful: What Really Happened to Jack Hamilton
- Josh Radnor: Long before How I Met Your Mother, he was "Tour Guide." It’s a tiny role, but he’s there.
- Lacey Chabert: Coming off Party of Five, she played the "Perfect Girl" Amanda Becker. She’d go on to star in Mean Girls, effectively moving from the parody of the genre to the definitive movie of the next generation.
- Sam Huntington: He played Ox. You might recognize him from Being Human or as Jimmy Olsen in Superman Returns.
- Miley Cyrus (Wait, what?): No, she wasn't in it, but her dad Billy Ray Cyrus makes a weirdly specific cameo.
The film also leaned heavily into the "brat pack" legacy by including Molly Ringwald herself. Her appearance as the "Flight Attendant" was the ultimate seal of approval. It signaled that the movie wasn't just making fun of teen movies; it was part of the lineage.
The Legacy of the 2001 Ensemble
Looking back 25 years later, the Not Another Teenage Movie cast represents a specific turning point in Hollywood. It was the tail end of the "teen scream/teen dream" era. The industry was about to shift toward gritty reboots and massive superhero universes.
In a way, this movie was the graduation ceremony for the 90s.
Most of these actors moved on to massive things. Chris Evans became a global icon. Chyler Leigh became a TV staple. Jaime Pressly became a decorated sitcom star. They survived the "spoof movie" stigma because they were genuinely talented. They weren't just playing a joke; they were playing a character who didn't know they were in a joke.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Viewer
If you’re planning a rewatch or diving into this for the first time, here is how to actually appreciate what this cast did:
- Watch the "Originals" First: If you haven't seen She's All That, Varsity Blues, Can't Hardly Wait, and Pretty in Pink, half the jokes will fly over your head. The cast is doing specific impressions of archetypes, not just being "random."
- Focus on the Background: Some of the best performances in this movie happen in the background of scenes. The "Slow Motion Guy" and the "Foreign Exchange Student" (played by Joy Bisco) are doing incredible physical comedy while the leads are talking.
- Track the Career Trajectories: It’s a fun exercise to see how many actors in this film ended up in the Marvel or DC universes. It’s a surprisingly high number.
- Ignore the Rotten Tomatoes Score: This is a cult classic for a reason. Critics in 2001 hated it because they were tired of teen movies. Viewers today love it because it’s a nostalgic fever dream.
The reality is that Not Another Teen Movie shouldn't have been this good. It should have been a disposable, straight-to-DVD cash-in. But because the cast was filled with hungry, talented actors who went on to define the next two decades of entertainment, it remains the gold standard for how to do a parody right. They took the tropes, leaned into the absurdity, and somehow came out the other side as superstars.
To truly understand the impact of the film, look at the credits. You aren't looking at a list of "where are they now" has-beens. You're looking at the roster of people who would go on to run Hollywood for the next twenty years.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out the 20th Anniversary "Director's Cut" or retrospective interviews with the cast on YouTube.
- Compare Chris Evans' performance as Jake Wyler with his portrayal of Johnny Storm in Fantastic Four to see his early comedic range.
- Track down the soundtrack, which features 2000s-era covers of 80s classics (like Marilyn Manson’s cover of "Tainted Love"), which perfectly encapsulates the film's "old meets new" vibe.