You’ve seen the red and white signs. Maybe you’ve even pulled into the lot at 2400 Broadway Street when you needed a specific bolt or a gallon of paint. But there’s a weird thing happening with True Value Anderson Indiana right now that most people aren't tracking.
People think "corporate" when they see the logo. Honestly? That couldn't be further from the truth.
While the national True Value Company made massive headlines in late 2024 and early 2025 for filing Chapter 11 bankruptcy and eventually being bought by Do it Best Corp., the actual store in Anderson—specifically Northgate True Value—is a different beast entirely. It’s locally owned. It stayed open while the corporate giants were duking it out in court. And in 2026, it’s basically the last stand for high-level expertise in Madison County.
The Local Reality vs. The National Headlines
Let’s clear the air. When the news broke that Do it Best (based over in Fort Wayne) was buying True Value, local regulars got worried. Would the Broadway Street store close? Nope.
The beauty of the hardware world is the "independent" part. Northgate True Value has been a staple in Anderson since 1974. That’s over fifty years of surviving economic shifts, the rise of big-box giants like Lowe’s and Menards, and the digital takeover.
🔗 Read more: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
They aren't a franchise in the way McDonald’s is. They are a member-owner. This means the folks running the store live here. They pay taxes here. When you walk in, you aren't talking to a corporate drone—you're talking to people like "the key guy" (a local legend at Northgate) who has been there for over a decade and can save you $400 on a dealership key replacement just because he knows his stuff.
What You Can Actually Get Done Here
Most people treat True Value Anderson Indiana as a backup plan. That’s a mistake. If you’re only going there because you forgot a washer at Menards, you’re missing the point of the shop.
The Services Nobody Realizes Exist
- Kerosene Heater Repair: Try finding a big-box store that will actually fix your heater. They won’t. They’ll just try to sell you a new one. Northgate actually does the repairs.
- Screen and Window Repair: If your cat shredded the screen door, you can drop it off here.
- Propane and Kerosene: They still do the heavy lifting for seasonal heating needs.
- DNR Licenses: You can literally walk in and get your hunting or fishing license while picking up a box of nails.
The Tool Game
They are a verified Milwaukee dealer. If you’ve spent any time on a job site, you know the "Red vs. Yellow" (Milwaukee vs. DeWalt) debate is basically a religion. Having a local spot that stocks the high-end M18 fuel lines means you aren't waiting three days for shipping when a drill dies mid-project.
Why Location Matters: 2400 Broadway St
Location is everything in a town like Anderson. Being tucked away at 2400 Broadway Street makes it the go-to for North Anderson, but it also pulls people from Alexandria and Chesterfield who don't want to deal with the chaos of the main retail drags.
💡 You might also like: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
The store hours are surprisingly accessible for a local shop:
- Monday - Friday: 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- Saturday: 7:00 AM - 7:00 PM
- Sunday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM (usually)
Note: Hours can shift slightly on holidays, so it's always worth a quick ring to (765) 642-2400 before you head out.
The "Expertise Gap"
There is a specific kind of frustration that happens at a massive home improvement warehouse. You find a "team member," ask them about a plumbing fitting, and they point you to an aisle they aren't even sure about.
At True Value Anderson Indiana, the staff usually knows the inventory by heart. This isn't just nostalgia; it's efficiency. If you're working on an old Victorian house in the West Eighth Street Historic District, you need someone who understands why your 100-year-old pipes don't match anything on the shelf. The crew at Northgate has seen those houses. They know the weird quirks of Madison County construction.
📖 Related: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
Addressing the Do it Best Merger
As of 2026, the transition under Do it Best is largely invisible to the customer. For the store owner, it means better buying power. For you? It means the shelves stay stocked. True Value operates as a subsidiary now, but the brand name remains on the building because it carries weight.
Some people thought the quality would dip. Kinda the opposite, actually. The merger stabilized the supply chain that was getting shaky in 2024. You’re seeing more "Meat Church" BBQ supplies, more Traeger grills, and a better selection of bulk garden seeds than we saw a few years back.
Actionable Tips for Shopping Local in Anderson
If you want to get the most out of your trip to the hardware store, stop treating it like a museum.
- Bring the Part: If you are trying to match a bolt or a plumbing seal, don't guess. Bring the old, grimy one in. They have thread gauges and experts who can identify a metric vs. standard pitch in seconds.
- Ask for the Rental List: Most folks don't realize they rent heavy equipment. Need a roto-tiller for the backyard? Rent it here instead of buying a $600 machine you'll use once a year.
- Check the "Bargain" Endcaps: Because they are independent, they often run local specials that aren't in the national flyer.
- Key Programming: Before you go to a car dealership and pay $300 for a new electronic key fob, check with the Northgate team. They have the tech to program many modern keys at a fraction of the cost.
True Value Anderson Indiana isn't just a place to buy a hammer. It's a resource for the DIYer who is tired of the "self-checkout" culture of the 2020s. Support the places that actually know your name—or at least know exactly which aisle the 1/4-inch hex bolts are in.
Immediate Next Steps
- Audit your seasonal gear: Check your kerosene heaters or lawnmowers now. If they need repair, drop them off at Northgate before the "rush" hits in late fall or early spring.
- Verify your keys: If you only have one copy of your car or house key, head to the Broadway location this week. It’s the cheapest insurance policy you can buy against a lockout.
- Plan your garden: Instead of buying pre-packaged mystery seeds, look at their bulk selection to see what actually grows well in Indiana soil.