When people talk about North Carolina soccer, the conversation usually jumps straight to the Tobacco Road college rivalries or the massive crowds at Bank of America Stadium. But honestly, the real grit? That lives in the match-ups where the local hierarchy is actually on the line. I’m talking about North Carolina FC vs Charlotte. It’s a matchup that basically defines the different eras of soccer in this state—the old guard vs the new powerhouse.
If you’ve spent any time at WakeMed Soccer Park in Cary, you know it feels different. It’s intimate. It’s loud. It’s where North Carolina FC (NCFC) has held down the fort for years. On the other side, you’ve got the Queen City, Charlotte, which transformed from a minor league hub into a Major League Soccer (MLS) juggernaut almost overnight.
The 2025 Open Cup Heartbreak in Cary
Let’s get into the most recent drama because this one still stings for the folks in Cary. On May 6, 2025, the two sides met in the U.S. Open Cup Round of 32. This wasn't just some preseason kick-around. It was a "winner takes the bragging rights" kind of night.
For 90 minutes, it was a stalemate. A total defensive grind. NCFC, playing in the USL Championship (the second tier), was hanging tough against the MLS roster of Charlotte FC. Then, extra time hit, and the wheels just sort of fell off for the home side.
- 97th Minute: Liel Abada breaks the seal for Charlotte.
- 98th Minute: Rafael Mentzingen answers immediately for NCFC. The place went absolutely nuts.
- The Collapse: Patrick Agyemang, who has basically become a nightmare for lower-division defenses, headed home a cross in the 104th minute.
- The Final Blows: Nikola Petkovic and Kerwin Vargas added two more late in the second half of extra time.
A 4-1 scoreline looks like a blowout on paper, but if you were there, you know it was a 1-1 game until the 103rd minute. That’s the thing about North Carolina FC vs Charlotte—the gap in resources is huge, but the gap on the field is often paper-thin until the very end.
👉 See also: Ohio State Football All White Uniforms: Why the Icy Look Always Sparks a Debate
North Carolina FC vs Charlotte: Why the Rivalry is Weird
See, "Charlotte" in this context can mean two different things depending on who you ask. Most fans today think of Charlotte FC (the MLS team). But for the die-hards, the real history is with the Charlotte Independence.
Before the MLS arrived, NCFC and the Independence were the two big dogs in the USL. They played for the "Southern Derby" trophy. It was messy, physical, and deeply personal. Even now, with NCFC in the USL Championship and the Independence in USL League One, that local friction hasn't totally evaporated.
Charlotte FC changed the math. Suddenly, NCFC wasn't just competing for players; they were competing for the soul of the North Carolina soccer fan. Charlotte has the glitz, the 70,000-seat stadium, and names like Wilfried Zaha (who joined on loan) and Ashley Westwood. NCFC has the heritage, the academy that produces guys like Finn Sundstrom, and a community-first vibe that money can't really buy.
Tactical Breakdowns: How They Match Up
When these teams meet, the tactical battle is pretty predictable but fascinating to watch. Dean Smith (the Charlotte coach, not the basketball legend—though the name is poetic for NC) usually wants his team to dominate the ball. In that 2025 cup match, Charlotte held 67% of the possession. They probe. They wait for the smaller team to tire out.
✨ Don't miss: Who Won the Golf Tournament This Weekend: Richard T. Lee and the 2026 Season Kickoff
NCFC, under John Bradford, plays a much more pragmatic game. They sit in a 3-4-3 or a 5-4-1 and look to kill you on the counter. Guys like Oalex Anderson and Rodrigo Da Costa are specialists at this. They only need one mistake to make an MLS defense look silly.
What to Expect Moving Forward
As we look at the 2026 landscape, the rivalry is only getting more complex. Charlotte FC is currently solidifying its spot as a top-five team in the Eastern Conference. They’ve been aggressive in the transfer market, recently bringing in USMNT midfielder Luca de la Torre. They are built to win trophies now.
NCFC is in a different phase. They are the "development" kings. They just sold 19-year-old center back Finn Sundstrom to the Philadelphia Union after he nearly won USL Young Player of the Year in 2025. Their goal isn't necessarily to outspend Charlotte; it's to out-think them.
If you’re planning on catching the next North Carolina FC vs Charlotte match, here is the reality:
🔗 Read more: The Truth About the Memphis Grizzlies Record 2025: Why the Standings Don't Tell the Whole Story
- Don’t trust the league tiers. The USL/MLS gap is closing. NCFC players are often auditioning for MLS scouts during these games.
- Watch the late subs. As we saw in 2025, depth is where Charlotte wins. When they bring on fresh international-caliber talent in the 75th minute, that's when the "magic" of the underdog starts to fade.
- The atmosphere is better in Cary. Sorry, Charlotte fans. Bank of America Stadium is impressive, but a packed WakeMed Soccer Park for a derby game is the purest soccer experience in the state.
Your Next Moves for the Season
If you want to keep up with the next chapter of this rivalry, keep a close eye on the 2026 U.S. Open Cup draw. It’s usually the only time these two play meaningful minutes against each other. Also, check the preseason schedules for the Coachella Valley Invitational or local friendlies.
For the tactical nerds, go back and watch the 2025 highlights. Pay attention to how NCFC’s midfield of Collin Martin and Raheem Somersall managed to stifle Charlotte's billion-dollar midfield for nearly 100 minutes. It’s a masterclass in defensive shape.
The "Soccer State" isn't just a marketing slogan. Whether it’s the blue and white of the Crown or the red and blue of NCFC, the talent level in this corridor is at an all-time high.
Actionable Insights for Fans:
- Tickets: If the match is at WakeMed, buy tickets early. Capacity is only 10,000 and these games sell out weeks in advance.
- Scouting: Keep an eye on NCFC's academy players. Most of the "homegrown" talent Charlotte FC covets actually starts in the NCFC youth systems.
- Broadcasts: Most of these regional clashes end up on CBS Sports Network or the Golazo Network rather than the standard MLS Season Pass, so check your listings before kickoff.