Finding a good plate of pasta shouldn't be a mission, yet here we are. You’ve probably seen the name Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen popping up in local conversations lately, and it's not because they have a massive marketing budget. It's because the food actually tastes like someone’s grandmother—specifically, Faye—spent all morning standing over a boiling pot of salted water and simmering tomatoes.
Authenticity is a buzzword that people throw around way too much in the restaurant industry. It’s basically lost all meaning. But when you walk into a place that smells like toasted garlic and slow-cooked veal, you kind of just know. Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen manages to capture that specific, nostalgic vibe without feeling like a theme park version of Italy. It’s just food. Really, really good food.
The Reality Behind Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen
Most "Italian" spots in the suburbs are basically just heavy cream and pre-shredded cheese masquerading as "cuisine." It’s frustrating. You pay thirty bucks for a bowl of fettuccine that was pulled out of a plastic bag two minutes before it hit your table. Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen does things differently, and that’s why the wait times can get a little crazy on Friday nights.
They focus on the basics. Red sauce (or gravy, depending on which part of the East Coast your family is from) shouldn't be sweet. It should be bright, acidic, and rich from the fats of the meat it cooked with. At Faye's, the marinara has that specific zing that only comes from using high-quality San Marzano tomatoes. Honestly, if a place isn't using the right tomatoes, you might as well just eat at home.
The menu isn't some thirty-page novel, either. They keep it tight. You’ve got your staples: lasagna that weighs about five pounds, chicken parm that’s actually crispy, and meatballs that aren't dense enough to be used as lethal weapons. It’s refreshing.
What Actually Makes the Sauce Different?
It’s the time.
You can’t rush a ragù. You just can’t. If you try to finish a meat sauce in thirty minutes, it tastes like raw onions and metallic tomato paste. At Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen, the kitchen staff starts before the sun is even up. They’re browning the mirepoix—that’s the onions, carrots, and celery base—until it’s practically jam. Then comes the meat. Then the wine. Then the long, slow wait.
This process breaks down the collagen in the meat, which creates that velvety mouthfeel. It’s physics, really. When you take a bite of their Bolognese, you’re tasting hours of chemical reactions that simply don't happen in a fast-casual kitchen. This is why people travel across town for a table. It's not the decor. It's the science of slow cooking.
Why Fresh Pasta Isn’t Always the "Best" Choice
Here’s a hot take: fresh pasta isn't always superior to dried pasta.
💡 You might also like: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
People think "fresh" means better, but that’s a total misconception. If you’re eating a heavy, chunky meat sauce, you actually want a high-quality dried pasta (pasta secca). Why? Because dried pasta has a firmer structure and can hold up to the weight of the sauce. It also has a rougher surface—if it’s bronze-die extruded—which helps the sauce actually stick to the noodle instead of sliding off into a puddle at the bottom of the bowl.
Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen understands this nuance. They use fresh egg pasta for their delicate ravioli and fettuccine, but they stick to high-end dried semolina for their spicier, heartier dishes. It shows they actually care about the mechanics of the meal, not just the marketing fluff of saying everything is "made fresh today."
- Fettuccine: Fresh egg dough, best for Alfredo or light butter sauces.
- Rigatoni: Usually dried, perfect for trapping bits of sausage in the tubes.
- Spaghetti: The universal soldier, works for almost anything but thrives with a simple marinara.
The Secret to the Perfect Chicken Parm
We have to talk about the Chicken Parmigiana at Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen. It’s a polarizing dish because everyone has a "best" version they remember from childhood.
Most places mess this up by drowning the chicken in so much sauce that the breading turns into a soggy, mushy mess within thirty seconds. It’s gross. At Faye's, they seem to follow the "moat" philosophy. They put a layer of sauce on the plate, nestle the crispy, pan-fried cutlet on top, and then do a light strip of sauce and melted mozzarella over the center. This keeps the edges of the chicken crunchy until the very last bite.
Also, they use veal or chicken that has been pounded thin. Consistency is key here. If the meat is an inch thick in one spot and a quarter-inch in another, it’s going to cook unevenly. One side will be dry, and the other will be raw. It’s basic cooking 101, but you’d be surprised how many "professional" kitchens ignore it.
The Bread Service
Let’s be real: the bread is usually a filler. At most places, it’s a cold roll with a foil-wrapped pat of butter.
At Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen, the bread is an event. It’s usually a crusty Italian loaf that’s warm enough to melt the herb-infused oil they serve it with. You shouldn't fill up on it, but you definitely will. It’s unavoidable. The crust has that shatter-crisp texture, and the inside is airy. It’s the perfect vehicle for cleaning up whatever sauce is left on your plate.
Navigating the Wine List Without Looking Like an Amateur
Italian wine is confusing. Between the regions, the grape varieties, and the confusing labeling laws, it’s easy to just point at the second cheapest bottle and hope for the best.
📖 Related: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
If you’re at Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen, you want to match the weight of the wine with the weight of the food.
- Eating Seafood or Light Pasta? Go for a Vermentino or a Pinot Grigio. You want high acidity to cut through the salt.
- Going for the Red Sauce? Chianti is the classic for a reason. The Sangiovese grapes have enough tannin to stand up to the tomatoes.
- Heavy Meat or Steaks? Look for a Barolo or a Montepulciano. These are "big" wines. They’ll make your tongue feel a bit dry, which is exactly what you want when you’re eating rich, fatty meats.
You don't need to be a sommelier to enjoy the meal. Just ask the server what they’re drinking. Usually, the staff at Faye's knows the menu inside out because they actually eat the food. That’s always a good sign. If the servers don't like the food, you shouldn't eat there.
Common Misconceptions About Italian Dining
People often walk into a place like Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen and expect "Italian-American" tropes that don't actually exist in Italy, or even in high-quality kitchens here.
For one, garlic bread isn't really a thing in Italy. It’s an American invention. Real bruschetta is just grilled bread rubbed with a clove of raw garlic and drizzled with oil. Another one? Fettuccine Alfredo. In Italy, it’s just pasta with butter and parmesan (al burro). The heavy cream version we love is a very specific evolution of the dish.
Nonna Faye’s leans into the Italian-American heritage. They aren't trying to be a Michelin-starred spot in Rome; they’re trying to be the best version of the kitchen Faye grew up in. That means big portions, plenty of garlic, and a feeling of "eat more, you look thin."
The Atmosphere Factor
It's loud.
If you're looking for a quiet, candlelit spot to break up with someone, this isn't it. Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen is built for groups. It’s built for families passing plates around and kids accidentally dropping noodles on the floor. The acoustics are lively, the kitchen is humming, and there’s a general sense of organized chaos.
That’s part of the charm. If an Italian restaurant is too quiet, it feels sterile. It feels like a hospital. You want to hear the clinking of wine glasses and the sound of someone laughing three tables over. It adds to the flavor.
👉 See also: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
How to Get a Table (The Practical Stuff)
Since Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen doesn't spend much on ads, they rely on word of mouth. And the word is out.
If you try to walk in at 7:00 PM on a Saturday, you’re going to be waiting at the bar for an hour. Minimum. Your best bet is to go on a Tuesday or Wednesday. The kitchen is less stressed, the service is faster, and you can actually hear yourself think. If you have to go on the weekend, go early—like 4:30 early. Or late, after the first rush has cleared out around 8:30.
Also, check their specials. They usually have a "Family Style" option on certain weeknights that saves you a ton of money if you’re bringing a group of four or more. It’s basically a massive platter of whatever the chef felt like making that day, usually accompanied by a mountain of salad and bread.
The Verdict on Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen
Is it the most revolutionary food you’ll ever eat? Probably not. It’s not trying to "deconstruct" the lasagna or serve you foam made of basil.
But it’s consistent. It’s honest. In a world where every new restaurant feels like it was designed by a corporate committee to be "Instagrammable," Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen feels like a real place. The chairs might not match perfectly, and the lighting is a bit bright, but the food has soul.
You go there when you’ve had a long week and you just want to feel full and taken care of. You go there because you know the eggplant parm will be exactly as good as it was last time. That consistency is the hardest thing to achieve in the restaurant business, and Faye’s has it figured out.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Visit
If you’re planning a trip to Nonna Faye’s Italian Kitchen, here is how to maximize the experience:
- Order the Meatballs as an App: Don't wait for the main course. Get them early. They set the tone for the whole meal.
- Ask About the "Off-Menu" Pasta: Sometimes they have a specific shape or a small-batch sauce that didn't make the printed menu.
- Take the Leftovers: The lasagna tastes better the next day. This is a scientific fact. The flavors have more time to meld in the fridge.
- Budget for Dessert: The cannoli shells are filled to order. This is vital. If they’re pre-filled, the shell gets soggy. Faye’s fills them when you order, so they stay crunchy.
Skip the chain restaurants this weekend. Go somewhere that actually cares about the salt level in the pasta water. Your stomach will thank you.
Next Steps:
- Call ahead to check their current wait times, especially if it's a weekend.
- Check their social media for daily specials; they often post "Secret" dishes that sell out by 6:00 PM.
- Bring a bottle of your favorite wine if they have a corkage policy—sometimes it's cheaper than buying from the list.