Nolan Arenado just got traded again. This time it's to the Arizona Diamondbacks for the 2026 season. If you follow the hobby, you know exactly what happens when a future Hall of Famer changes jerseys: everyone starts digging through their shoeboxes.
Honestly, the nolan arenado rookie card market has been a bit of a roller coaster lately. He’s 34 now. The power numbers dipped in St. Louis during that 2025 season where he hit just .237. But does that actually matter for his long-term card value? Probably not as much as the "doom and gloom" crowd thinks. We are talking about a guy with ten Gold Gloves and over 350 home runs. He’s basically a lock for Cooperstown, and in the card world, "buying the dip" on a legend is usually the smartest move you can make.
Which Nolan Arenado Rookie Card Actually Matters?
You've got two main camps here. You have the "True Rookie" collectors who want the 2013 stuff, and the "First Bowman" purists who go back to 2010.
Most people starting out get confused because Arenado was a "late bloomer" in terms of his cardboard. He was drafted in 2009 but didn't get his main Topps rookie cards until 2013. If you want the absolute "holy grail" for a nolan arenado rookie card, you’re looking at the 2010 Bowman Chrome Prospects Autograph. This isn't technically a "rookie card" by the strict definition (since he was still in the minors), but it's the one that moves the needle for big-money investors.
A PSA 9 of the Red Refractor version of that 2010 card sold for $34,500 back in 2023. Yeah. Serious money.
The 2013 Topps Update #US259
If you aren't looking to spend the price of a mid-sized SUV on a piece of cardboard, this is your target. The 2013 Topps Update #US259 is the "standard" rookie. It's affordable, iconic, and has a million parallels.
👉 See also: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
As of early 2026, a base PSA 10 of this card is sitting around $70. That’s actually a steal when you compare it to other guys with similar resumes.
Why is it so cheap?
- The 2013 Topps Update set was printed in massive quantities compared to early 2000s sets.
- Arenado’s 2025 stats were underwhelming, leading to a temporary cooling of the market.
- Third basemen historically don't get the same hobby love as shortstops or center fielders.
But look at the parallels. The "Walmart Blue" border variation has been popping up in recent auctions for about $190 in a PSA 9. If you can find the Sapphire version (limited to /25), you’re looking at a $7,000 card.
Understanding the "First Bowman" Factor
If you tell a hardcore collector you bought a nolan arenado rookie card, they’ll immediately ask, "Is it the 2010 or the 2013?"
The 2010 Bowman Prospects (#BP91 for paper, #BCP91 for chrome) is technically his first appearance on a major brand card. This is where the 1st Bowman logo lives.
✨ Don't miss: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
- 2010 Bowman Chrome Autograph: This is the blue chip. If you have the budget, this is the one to hold.
- 2010 Bowman Paper: Kinda the "budget" entry. You can find these raw for under $5.
- 2013 Topps Heritage: This one is cool because it uses the 1964 Topps design. The "Real One" Red Ink autograph (limited to /10) is a monster, once selling for over $6,100.
It's a weird quirk of the hobby. The 2010 card is more valuable, but the 2013 card is the "official" rookie. I usually suggest getting one of each if you're building a "HoF Portfolio."
Is He Still an Investment Grade Player?
Let's be real for a second. The trade to Arizona is a massive wildcard. The Diamondbacks are trying to contend in 2026, and if Arenado finds that desert air suits him—remember how he used to crush in the NL West—his card prices will spike.
He currently has 1,921 career hits and 353 home runs. If he stays healthy for three more seasons, he cruises past 2,000 hits and gets very close to 400 homers. Combine that with the 10 Gold Gloves? He's a first-ballot guy.
The biggest risk isn't his talent; it's the "St. Louis Hangover." Collectors were frustrated that he didn't win a ring with the Cardinals. But now that he's moved on, the narrative shifts back to his individual greatness.
The Condition Rarity Trap
One thing you've gotta watch out for with the 2013 Topps Update is the centering. Those cards are notorious for being shifted to the left or right. If you're buying raw on eBay, look closely at the borders. A "Near Mint" card with bad centering won't get that PSA 10, and the price difference between a 9 and a 10 is huge.
🔗 Read more: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
Spotting Fakes and Reprints
Luckily, we don't see a ton of sophisticated fakes for the nolan arenado rookie card base versions because the price point isn't high enough to justify the effort for scammers.
However, the 2010 Bowman Chrome Autographs are a different story. Always look for the "Topps Certified Autograph Issue" text. On the Chrome cards, the signature should be on-card, not a sticker. If you see a 2010 Arenado with a sticker auto, run away. It's either a weird aftermarket creation or a flat-out fake.
Buying Strategy for 2026
If I were putting together a "Nolan Stack" today, here is how I'd break it down.
First, I'd grab a couple of 2013 Topps Update #US259 base cards in PSA 9. They are liquid. You can sell them in an hour if you need cash.
Next, I'd hunt for the 2013 Topps Chrome #78. It’s the shiny version of his rookie. The Refractor version of this card is currently trending up, with recent sales hitting the $60-$80 range for ungraded copies in good shape.
Lastly, if you're a "gambler," look for the 2013 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects. It's often overlooked but carries a lot of weight with Bowman-only collectors.
Actionable Next Steps for Collectors
- Check the Pop Reports: Before overpaying for a PSA 10, check how many exist. The 2013 Topps Update has a high population, so don't feel like you have to jump on the first one you see.
- Focus on the "1st Bowman" Logo: If you're looking for long-term appreciation, the 2010 Chrome (with or without the auto) usually outperforms the base 2013 Topps flagship over a 10-year window.
- Monitor the Diamondbacks Start: If Arenado starts April 2026 with a .300 average and a few homers, the "Arizona Hype" will drive prices up 20% overnight. Buy now while the St. Louis "down year" is still fresh in people's minds.
- Verify the "Walmart Blue": Many sellers mislabel the 2013 Blue borders. Ensure it’s actually the Walmart variant and not just a trick of the light in the photo.
The window to buy a nolan arenado rookie card at "non-Hall of Fame" prices is closing. Once he hits that 2,000-hit milestone or announces his retirement, the prices will stabilize at a much higher floor.