We need to talk about that kiss. You know the one.
In the middle of a Los Angeles street, the light is hitting just right, and Adam Brody—playing a rabbi, of all things—leans into Kristen Bell with the kind of intensity that makes you forget you're watching a Netflix sitcom. It’s the "big" moment in Nobody Wants This, and honestly, it’s the reason half the internet spent late 2024 and 2025 obsessed with these two.
But here is the thing: what looks like effortless, electric chemistry on screen is actually the result of two people who have been orbiting each other’s professional lives for over a decade. If you think they just met on set and sparked, you’ve got it all wrong.
The Weird, Decade-Long History You Missed
Kristen Bell and Adam Brody aren't just co-stars who happen to be good at "eye-fucking" (as critics so eloquently put it). They are old friends. Like, "sharing a ride in a tiny two-seater car after a Scream 4 screening" levels of old.
Adam actually remembers that car ride vividly. Kristen? Not so much. She apparently "folded herself" into the back of his car because she needed a lift to an afterparty. She’s admitted that sounds exactly like something she’d do, even if the memory is a total blank.
They’ve popped up in each other’s work for years:
- They played exes in the 2013 indie film Some Girl(s).
- They had a brief, weird romantic arc in House of Lies.
- Adam is literally married to Leighton Meester, whom Kristen "voiced" for years as the narrator of Gossip Girl.
When Erin Foster, the creator of Nobody Wants This, was looking for her Noah, Kristen didn't just suggest Adam—she basically insisted on him. She knew that to sell the "Greatest Kiss of All Time" (which was literally how it was written in the script, talk about pressure), she needed someone she was already comfortable with.
Is It Actually A True Story?
People keep asking if a rabbi really fell for a sex podcaster. The answer is: sort of.
📖 Related: Kate Middleton Astro Chart Explained: Why She Was Born for the Crown
The show is a "love letter" to Erin Foster’s real-life marriage to Simon Tikhman. Simon isn't a rabbi—he’s a music executive—but the cultural friction was very real. Erin was the "shiksa" (her words) who didn't grow up with religion, and Simon came from a traditional Russian-Jewish family.
That scene with the sunflowers? The one where Noah shows up to meet Joanne’s mom with a bouquet so big it looks like a weapon? That actually happened to Erin. She thought it was a "weakness" that he cared so much.
Wait, what about the Rabbi part? That’s where the fiction kicks in. Turning Noah into a rabbi upped the stakes. It turned a "my parents might not like you" story into a "my entire career and community might reject you" story.
Why the Chemistry Feels Different in 2026
By the time Season 2 dropped in October 2025, the conversation around the show shifted. It wasn't just about the "will they, won't they" anymore. It was about whether they should.
Season 2 brought in Leighton Meester (Adam’s real-life wife) to play Joanne’s middle-school nemesis. It was a brilliant, meta move that leaned into the fans' parasocial obsession with these actors. Seeing Leighton and Kristen go head-to-head while Adam caught in the middle? That’s peak entertainment.
But there’s a nuance here that most people miss. Adam and Kristen aren't trying to pretend they’re 22. They’re both 45. They’re playing characters in their late 30s who have baggage, icks, and established lives.
"Adam can stare longingly into someone's eyes for an extended period of time—and so can I," Kristen told Harper’s Bazaar. "If someone can hold it with you... you are going to crack a lens."
👉 See also: Ainsley Earhardt in Bikini: Why Fans Are Actually Searching for It
That’s not just "acting." That’s two veterans who know exactly how to manipulate the camera. They aren't "shippable" in the way teenagers are; they’re "shippable" because they represent the terrifying reality of choosing a person over a lifestyle.
The "Ick" Factor and Modern Romance
One of the reasons Nobody Wants This blew up on Google Discover is because of the "icks."
Joanne and her sister Morgan (played by the incredible Justine Lupe) spend half the show deconstructing why they can’t find love. The icks—running with a backpack, chasing a ping-pong ball—were pulled directly from Erin and Sara Foster’s real-life podcast, The World’s First Podcast.
It resonates because it’s cynical. We live in an era where we look for reasons to leave. Then comes Noah, who is "emotionally available" and "old-fashioned" but also "really funny." He’s the antidote to the ick.
But as we saw in the Season 2 finale and the lead-up to the 2026 Season 3 premiere, "being a good guy" isn't enough when your partner has to fundamentally change who they are (convert) to fit into your world.
What’s Actually Happening with Season 3?
Netflix renewed the show for a third season in late 2025 after Season 2 hit #1 globally. If you’re looking for a release date, the rumors and production schedules point to a late 2026 window.
Here is what we know for sure:
✨ Don't miss: Why the Jordan Is My Lawyer Bikini Still Breaks the Internet
- The Core Cast is Back: Kristen and Adam are locked in. You can't have the show without them.
- The Tension is Real: Season 2 ended on a bit of a cliffhanger regarding Noah’s new position at a progressive temple (led by Seth Rogen and Kate Berlant—an inspired bit of casting).
- Conversion is the Key: The show is heading toward the big question: Will Joanne actually convert? In real life, Erin Foster did. But in TV land, a happy ending can sometimes be the death of the plot.
Critics have been a bit more divided on the second season, with audience scores dipping on Rotten Tomatoes compared to the near-perfect first season. People felt the drama was a bit "contrived" to keep them apart.
Honestly? Who cares. We’re here to see Kristen Bell be acid-tongued and Adam Brody be the "Hot Rabbi."
How to Lean Into the Nobody Wants This Vibe
If you’ve binged both seasons and are currently staring at a void until Season 3 arrives, you don't have to just sit there.
First, go listen to The World's First Podcast. It is the literal DNA of the show. You’ll hear where the dialogue comes from, and you’ll realize that the banter between Joanne and Morgan isn't scripted—it’s a lifestyle.
Second, check out the actors' actual lives. Kristen’s husband, Dax Shepard, has a podcast (Armchair Expert) where Adam Brody has appeared. Hearing them talk about the "chemistry" from a husband’s perspective is hilarious and incredibly grounded. Dax is the first person to joke about how "hot" his wife's co-star is.
Finally, keep an eye on the 2026 Emmy nominations. After Season 1 grabbed three nods, the industry is watching to see if the "rom-com revival" has staying power.
The reality is that Kristen Bell and Adam Brody didn't just give us a show; they gave us a reminder that the most interesting part of a relationship isn't the meet-cute. It’s the "light of day" where you have to decide if the person is worth the chaos they bring into your life.
Whether you're in it for the Jewish cultural nuances or just the way Adam Brody looks in a tallit, one thing is certain: everybody actually wants this.
Your Next Steps:
- Watch the "Essential" episodes again: Specifically Episode 1 ("Pilot") and Season 2, Episode 10 ("When Noah Met Joanne") to see the full arc of their chemistry.
- Follow Erin Foster on Instagram: She’s the most reliable source for behind-the-scenes Season 3 updates.
- Check out 'The River Wild' (2023): If you want to see Adam Brody and Leighton Meester actually working together in a completely different, much darker genre.