You’ve seen the commercials. Some guy is pulling a perfectly roasted whole turkey out of a box that looks like a oversized toaster, and suddenly your old oven feels like a dinosaur. But here’s the thing about the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Air Oven. People buy it thinking it’s just a bigger air fryer. It isn't. Not really. If you treat it like a standard bucket-style fryer, you’re going to hate it.
It's massive. It’s loud. It takes up more real estate on your quartz countertop than a microwave. Yet, for a specific type of cook, it’s basically the only appliance that matters. I’ve spent months watching people struggle with the "Smart" part of this machine, specifically that Integrated Smart Thermometer that everyone forgets to use until their chicken is already dry.
The Size Paradox: Why XL Doesn't Mean What You Think
When Ninja slapped the "XL" label on this, they weren't kidding about the footprint. We are talking about a unit that is roughly 17 inches wide and over 20 inches deep. If you have those trendy low-hanging cabinets, forget it. You need clearance. The heat that rolls off the back of this thing during a 450°F roast session is no joke. I’ve seen people melt plastic containers they left too close to the exhaust.
But inside? That’s where the math gets weird. The Ninja Foodi Smart XL Air Oven utilizes two-level cooking. Ninja claims you can cook a whole meal at once, and technically, you can. You put your protein on the bottom and your veggies on the top. But here is the reality: airflow is king in an air oven. If you crowd those racks, you aren't air frying anymore. You’re just crowded-roasting, which is a fancy way of saying your food is getting soggy.
To get that shatter-crisp skin on wings, you still have to give them space. The "XL" capacity is best utilized for height and surface area, not for stacking food like a game of Tetris. If you want a tray of fries and a tray of nuggets simultaneously, you’re going to have to swap those racks halfway through. It’s a bit of a dance. Honestly, if you don't swap them, the top tray gets scorched while the bottom stays pale.
👉 See also: Why People That Died on Their Birthday Are More Common Than You Think
That Integrated Smart Thermometer Actually Works
Most "smart" kitchen gadgets are gimmicks. I usually toss the probe in a junk drawer and never look back. However, with the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Air Oven, the probe is the entire point.
The system uses a leave-in thermometer that plugs directly into the side of the unit. You select your protein—say, "Beef"—pick your doneness (Medium-Rare), and the oven does the rest. It doesn't just stop when it hits the target temp; it accounts for carryover cooking. This is a nuance most home cooks miss. If you pull a steak at 135°F, it’s going to end up at 145°F after resting. The Ninja software knows this. It tells you when to "Get Food" before it actually hits the final temperature.
I’ve tested this against a professional-grade Thermapen. The Ninja probe is surprisingly accurate, usually within two degrees. For someone who consistently overcooks salmon—which is easy to do in a high-velocity air oven—this feature is a literal lifesaver. It turns a high-stress dinner into a "set it and forget it" situation.
Why Your Air Fryer Recipes Might Fail Here
There is a fundamental difference between a bucket air fryer and a toaster-style air oven. In a bucket, the fan is directly above the food, inches away. In the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Air Oven, the "Pro Power" convection fan is on the side.
✨ Don't miss: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
This creates a different wind pattern.
- The Velocity Factor: The air moves fast. Really fast. If you’re making something light, like toasted parchment paper or thin slices of kale, it will fly around the oven.
- The Rack Placement: You have four positions. Position 3 is the sweet spot for air frying. Go too high, and the heating elements will incinerate your breadcrumbs before the inside is hot.
- The Pre-heat: Unlike small air fryers that heat up in 60 seconds, this XL unit needs a solid 90-second to 2-minute pre-heat. Don’t skip it. If you put food in a cold oven, the fan starts blowing cold air, and you lose that initial sear.
One major gripe people have is the "Air Fry" vs. "Whole Roast" settings. They seem similar, but the fan speed is the differentiator. Air Fry is max velocity. Whole Roast drops the fan speed slightly to allow the center of a chicken to cook without the outside turning into carbon. If you’re doing a 5-lb bird, use the Roast setting. Trust me.
Maintenance: The Part Nobody Wants To Talk About
Let’s be real: cleaning this thing is a nightmare if you’re lazy.
Because it’s a large oven with exposed heating elements (four on the bottom, two on top), grease splatter is your enemy. In a bucket fryer, you just throw the basket in the dishwasher. Here, you have a crumb tray, a wire rack, a sheet pan, and the air fry basket.
🔗 Read more: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
If you let grease bake onto the back wall of the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Air Oven, it will smoke. The next time you turn it on to 400°F, your kitchen will smell like a burnt diner. The "stay clean" strategy involves wiping the interior down with a damp cloth after every—yes, every—use once it cools. Also, avoid using aerosol cooking sprays like Pam. The lecithin in those sprays creates a sticky residue that becomes permanent under high heat. Use a pump sprayer with avocado or grapeseed oil instead. Higher smoke points are your friend.
Is It Better Than a Breville or Cuisinart?
This is the big question. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro is often cited as the gold standard, but it’s significantly more expensive. The Cuisinart version is analog and feels a bit flimsy by comparison.
The Ninja wins on raw power. It gets to temperature faster than the Breville. It also feels more rugged. However, the Breville has better "Element IQ" technology that moves heat around more precisely. If you are a hardcore baker who makes delicate macarons or soufflés, the Breville might have the edge. But if you want to air fry two pounds of chicken wings or dehydrate beef jerky, the Ninja's fan power is superior.
Real-World Performance: What to Expect
I’ve seen people complain that the toast function is slow. It is. It’s a giant oven; using it for two slices of white bread is like using a sledgehammer to drive a thumbtack. But for a family of four? You can toast nine slices of bread at once. That changes the breakfast game entirely.
The "Dehydrate" function is also a sleeper hit. Because of the XL surface area, you can actually make a decent batch of dried fruit or jerky without it taking three days. It maintains a steady low temp (around 105°F to 150°F) which is something many cheaper ovens struggle with—they often spike too high and "cook" the fruit instead of drying it.
Actionable Steps for New Owners
- The Toast Test: Before you cook a real meal, do a "toast map." Fill a rack with cheap white bread and toast it. This shows you exactly where the hot spots are. Every unit is slightly different.
- Calibrate the Probe: The first time you use the Smart Thermometer, use a secondary hand-held thermometer to check it. Ensure you’re inserting the probe into the thickest part of the meat, avoiding bone and fat pockets.
- The Tin Foil Rule: Never, ever cover the crumb tray with aluminum foil. It blocks the airflow and can cause the bottom elements to overheat. If you’re worried about mess, place a foil-lined sheet pan on the lowest rack position below your cooking rack, but leave space for air to circulate.
- Lower the Temp: If you’re converting a recipe from a traditional oven to the Ninja Foodi Smart XL Air Oven, drop the temperature by 25°F and check the food 20% sooner. The convection power is significantly more aggressive than a standard wall oven.
- Clean the Fan: Every few months, check the fan intake. Dust and kitchen grease can clog the mesh, reducing the "Air Fry" effectiveness. A quick vacuum or a wipe with a degreaser keeps the motor from burning out prematurely.
This machine isn't just an appliance; it's a replacement for your full-sized oven for about 80% of your cooking tasks. It saves energy, it doesn't heat up the whole house in the summer, and it makes better roasted potatoes than any range I've ever owned. Just make sure you have the counter space before you pull the trigger.