You’d think a guy like Nicolas Cage would’ve been born in a pair of spurs. He’s got that specific kind of intensity, that "nouveau shamanic" energy, that feels like it belongs in the dust and the heat of a frontier showdown. But weirdly enough, despite making over a hundred movies across four decades, Cage didn't actually lead a traditional Western until very recently. It’s a strange gap in a filmography that includes everything from treasure hunters to literal sorcerers.
Honestly, it’s kinda wild. We’re talking about a man who grew up in California, lives in Nevada, and spent his childhood watching Charles Bronson in Once Upon a Time in the West. He’s gone on record saying he always felt he’d be a good match for the genre. He basically felt he could "fill those boots" without much acting required. Yet, the invitation just never came. Until it did.
Between 2023 and 2025, Cage didn't just dip his toes in; he went full Cowboy. From a classic revenge tale to a gritty, bald-headed buffalo hunt, the Nicolas Cage Western movies era finally arrived.
The 40-Year Wait: Why so late?
Cage has been acting since he was fifteen. Think about that. 1981. Fast Times at Ridgemont High era. He’s done noir, sci-fi, horror, and high-octane action. But the Western remained his "final frontier."
Why?
The industry is a fickle beast. Westerns aren't the box office juggernauts they were in the 50s. Unless you're Kevin Costner or Taylor Sheridan, getting a Western made is an uphill battle. Plus, Cage’s career has been, well, eccentric. For a long time, he was the guy you hired for "The Cage Experience"—the shouting, the eyes, the manic energy. Traditional Westerns often demand the opposite: a quiet, stoic "man of few words" vibe.
He finally got his shot with The Old Way in early 2023. It wasn't some reinventing-the-wheel masterpiece. It was a straight-up, old-school oater. Cage played Colton Briggs, a retired gunslinger turned family man who has to dig up his old life when his past catches up to him.
💡 You might also like: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Critics weren't exactly kind. It sits with a 32% on Rotten Tomatoes. But here’s the thing: it found a second life. By 2025, it was hitting the top of the charts on streaming services like Tubi. People actually like seeing Cage in a hat. Who knew?
The Transformation in Butcher’s Crossing
If The Old Way was Cage playing it safe, Butcher’s Crossing (2023) was him playing for keeps. This isn't your grandfather’s Western. Based on the 1960 novel by John Edward Williams, it’s more of a "frontier deconstruction."
Cage plays Miller, a buffalo hunter with a shaved head and a singular, terrifying obsession. He’s not a hero. He’s barely even an anti-hero. He’s a force of nature that represents the sheer, destructive ambition that built (and broke) the American West.
To get into the headspace of Miller, Cage apparently combined two very different inspirations:
- Michael Jordan: He wanted that "need to win" at any cost, that relentless competitive fire.
- Marlon Brando: Specifically the Kurtz version from Apocalypse Now.
Watching Cage in this movie is uncomfortable. It’s gritty. It’s bloody. It’s about the senseless slaughter of thousands of buffalo and the slow descent into madness when winter traps the hunting party in the mountains. It shows a side of the West that isn't about honor or justice—it’s about greed and the hollowness of "victory."
A Quick Reality Check on the Genre
Most people think of Westerns as John Wayne riding into the sunset. Cage’s recent run is much closer to "Revisionist Westerns." These movies look at the myth of the West and poke holes in it. They ask: Was it actually glorious, or was it just a lot of mud and bad decisions?
📖 Related: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
The 2025 Wild Card: Gunslingers
Then we get to 2025. This is where things get truly "Cagey."
Gunslingers (released April 11, 2025) is an action-heavy Western where Cage plays a character named Ben. He’s basically a Bible-quoting sidekick to a former outlaw played by Stephen Dorff. If you like your Nicolas Cage movies "over the top," this is your holy grail.
Critics absolutely trashed it. We’re talking a 5% on Rotten Tomatoes. It’s one of those movies that is objectively "not great" by traditional standards, but is endlessly fascinating because Cage is in it doing… whatever it is Cage does. He yells. He quotes scripture. He makes choices no other actor would make.
It’s currently streaming on Netflix, and it’s become a bit of a cult "hate-watch" or "ironic-watch." Sometimes a movie is so weird it becomes mandatory viewing for fans of the actor. Gunslingers is that movie.
What Most People Get Wrong About These Movies
There’s a misconception that Cage is just "phoning it in" for a paycheck in these smaller Westerns. That’s usually not the case with him. Even in a 5% rated movie, he’s making choices.
In The Old Way, he specifically modeled his hat and his quietude after Charles Bronson. He wanted to pay homage to the stars he loved as a kid. There’s a sincerity there that gets lost if you only look at the IMDb score. He’s a fan of the genre living out a childhood dream.
👉 See also: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery
How to Watch the Nicolas Cage Western Cycle
If you want to actually appreciate this specific era of his career, don't just pick one at random. There's a trajectory here.
- Start with The Old Way: It’s the "entry-level" Cage Western. It’s traditional. It’s easy to follow. It’s a "popcorn" movie that lets you see him in the classic tropes.
- Move to Butcher’s Crossing: This is the "prestige" pick. It’s the one where he’s actually doing heavy-duty acting. It’s dark and philosophical.
- Finish with Gunslingers: Only if you’re a Cage completionist. This is the "Late Night Cinema" pick where things get weird.
Practical Next Steps for Fans
If you’re looking to dive into the world of Nicolas Cage Western movies, start by checking the availability of The Old Way on free-with-ads platforms like Tubi or Pluto TV—it’s frequently there. For the more cinematic experience of Butcher’s Crossing, you’ll likely need a rental on VOD or a subscription to a premium service like Hulu or Paramount+.
Keep an eye on his upcoming 2026 slate too. While he’s moving back into horror and thrillers (like the Madden biopic and The Carpenter’s Son), the success of his Westerns on streaming means he likely isn't done with the spurs just yet. Once an actor finds out they look good in a Stetson, they usually come back for more.
For now, the best way to experience "Western Cage" is to embrace the inconsistency. You’re going to get some brilliance, some weirdness, and a lot of dust. And honestly, isn't that exactly what we want from a Nicolas Cage movie?
Key Takeaways:
- Nicolas Cage’s first lead Western was The Old Way in 2023.
- Butcher’s Crossing is his most critically respected entry in the genre.
- Gunslingers (2025) represents his most "unhinged" Western performance.
- His Western movies often perform better on streaming than they did at the box office.
Data and release dates current as of early 2026.