Nick Kroll grew up in a mansion, but he felt like he was living in a hole.
That sounds dramatic. It probably is. But when you’re 14 years old and standing five feet flat while your best friends are sprouting mustaches and hitting 5'10", the size of your house doesn't matter. You’re small. You’re a "late bloomer." You are, essentially, waiting for your life to start while everyone else is already at the party.
Most people know Nick Kroll as the mastermind behind Big Mouth, the Netflix show that turned puberty into a literal monster. But nick kroll as a teenager wasn't the confident comedy mogul we see today. He was a kid in Rye, New York, navigating the weird, high-pressure world of elite private schools and a body that refused to cooperate with the calendar.
The Westchester Bubble and the Solomon Schechter Days
Rye is beautiful. It’s on the water. It’s 45 minutes from Manhattan. For Kroll, it was the backdrop for a childhood that felt "idyllic" but also strangely isolating. He was the youngest of four. His dad, Jules Kroll, basically invented the modern corporate investigation industry. Wealth wasn't the issue; the issue was being the "baby" in a family of high achievers.
He spent his middle school years at Solomon Schechter of Westchester. This is where he met Andrew Goldberg.
If you’ve watched the show, you know Andrew. In real life, Goldberg was the one who hit puberty first. He was the one dealing with the "biological chaos" while Nick was still looking for any sign of a growth spurt. They weren't just friends; they were a duo forged in the fires of awkward Jewish day school talent shows. They used to do Wayne's World sketches at summer camp. Kroll was the loud kid, the brash one, the one fighting for attention at a dinner table full of older siblings.
💡 You might also like: Dale Mercer Net Worth: Why the RHONY Star is Richer Than You Think
The Rye Country Day School Transformation
By the time he hit high school at Rye Country Day, things got... complicated.
Imagine entering 9th grade at 5'0". You're tiny. You're looking at the "trajectory" of the other boys and realizing you aren't on it. Kroll has talked about this "compare and despair" phase—looking at friends with underarm hair and feeling like a total failure of a human being.
It wasn't all misery, though. He was a "sports kid" before he was a "theater kid." He played:
- Little League at Disbrow Park.
- Basketball at the Osborn gym.
- Soccer at Midland.
- Hockey at Playland Ice Casino.
Sports were his way of staying connected to the town kids who didn't go to his private school. But let's be real—when you're the smallest guy on the pitch, you have to be either the fastest or the funniest. Nick chose funny.
The "Mountain School" Pivot
In a move that feels very "upper-middle-class New York teen," Kroll spent a semester at The Mountain School in Vermont. It’s a specialized program on a working farm. It was there he discovered hiking, but more importantly, it was a break from the Westchester pressure cooker. Sometimes you need to go milk a cow to realize that not having a beard isn't the end of the world.
📖 Related: Jaden Newman Leaked OnlyFans: What Most People Get Wrong
Why the "Late Bloomer" Tag Still Matters
We talk about nick kroll as a teenager because it is the DNA of his entire career.
He didn't hit his growth spurt until he was 17. He shot up ten inches in a single year. That kind of late-stage physical transformation leaves a mark. You spend three years being the "little guy" and then suddenly you're a "man," but your brain is still stuck in that 5'0" frame.
That's why his characters—from Nick Birch to the insecure Ruxin on The League—always feel like they're one insult away from a total meltdown. It’s a specific kind of Westchester trauma. It's the "Soft Daddy" energy of his fictionalized parents versus the reality of growing up with a billionaire father.
Kroll's sister, Vanessa Kroll Bennett, actually hosts a podcast about puberty now. The whole family is basically the world's leading authority on being an awkward teenager.
The Georgetown Shift
Everything changed when he got to DC. At Georgetown University, the "teenager" version of Nick finally died, and the "comedian" version was born.
👉 See also: The Fifth Wheel Kim Kardashian: What Really Happened with the Netflix Comedy
He wasn't just a history and Spanish major. He was a guy cleaning out the milk section at Vital Vittles and hanging out at Uncommon Grounds. This is where he met John Mulaney and Mike Birbiglia. This is where the improv started.
But he credits a teacher back in Rye, Cary Fuller, for actually pushing him toward the stage. It takes one person to tell a late bloomer they’re good at something to change their entire life path.
What you can do next:
If you're interested in how these teenage years actually looked on screen, go back and watch the first season of Big Mouth. Look for the episode where Nick gets "pantsed" in front of his crush. That actually happened to him. It’s not just "funny content"—it’s a memory he’s been carrying since the 90s.
You should also check out Vanessa Kroll Bennett’s book, This Is So Awkward. It gives a lot of context to the "expert" advice the Kroll family was passing around during Nick's actual adolescence. Understanding the real-life family dynamic makes the show's "gross-out" humor feel a lot more like a survival mechanism than just a bunch of dirty jokes.