If you’ve spent any time on the weirder corners of the internet lately, you’ve probably seen the name popping up. People are digging. They are looking for a Nick Contino criminal record, and honestly, the results are a bit of a mess. You find a mix of legal documents from a decade ago, viral TikTok drama from 2025, and some local hero stories from upstate New York. It’s a lot to sort through.
Basically, there isn’t just one "Nick Contino." That’s where the confusion starts. When you search for a criminal record, you’re likely hitting three very different people, and confusing them can lead to some pretty big factual errors.
The Disney World Bathroom Investigation (2025)
The most recent and viral reason people are searching for a Nick Contino criminal record involves a TikTok creator. This is Lilly Tino, who was born Nicholas Contino.
In June 2025, Tino became the center of a massive controversy after posting selfies from inside women's restrooms at Walt Disney World. The issue wasn't just the location; it was the fact that other women and children were visible in the background of the photos. They hadn't consented to being there. They were just trying to use the facilities.
Florida law is pretty strict about this kind of thing. Under the state's privacy statutes, taking unauthorized photos in a place where people have a "reasonable expectation of privacy"—like a bathroom—can be a felony. Specifically, it can fall under video voyeurism or invasion of privacy laws.
As of early 2026, the Florida Attorney General’s office has reportedly looked into the matter. There have been petitions to ban Tino from Disney parks and TikTok entirely. While social media "detectives" often claim there's a long rap sheet here, the reality is that the 2025 Disney incident is the primary legal focal point for this specific individual. There have been talks of civil lawsuits from the women in the background, but a formal criminal conviction for this specific event hasn't been finalized in public records yet.
📖 Related: Is there a bank holiday today? Why your local branch might be closed on January 12
The Case of Constable Fortunato Contino
If you go back further, you’ll find a completely different set of legal papers. These involve a Fortunato "Nick" Contino Jr., who was a Pennsylvania Constable.
This is a totally separate guy. He wasn't the one arrested; he was the one doing the arresting—and then he got sued for it. Back in 2012, there was a nasty altercation at an office in Camden, New Jersey. Contino was there to serve court documents. Things got heated. A man named Hammond was arrested and charged with aggravated assault on a law enforcement officer (Contino).
But here’s the twist: Hammond was found not guilty of those charges.
After he was cleared, Hammond turned around and filed a federal lawsuit against Nick Contino. He alleged:
- Assault
- Malicious abuse of process
- Deprivation of property
This case, Hammond v. Contino, dragged on for years in the District of New Jersey. It’s a civil record, not a criminal one for Contino, but because it involves "assault" and "arrest," it often clutters up search results when people are looking for a Nick Contino criminal record.
👉 See also: Is Pope Leo Homophobic? What Most People Get Wrong
The "Other" Officer Nicholas Contino
Just to make it even more confusing, there is another Nicholas Contino who is actually a police officer in the Town of Chester, New York.
In June 2025—right around the same time the TikTok creator was getting into trouble in Florida—this Officer Contino was being hailed as a hero. He responded to a rollover car crash on Kings Highway. The car was on fire. The driver was trapped. He smashed the sunroof and pulled the woman out just in time.
If you’re looking for "bad" records, you won't find them here. This is a case of name collision. One Nick Contino is under investigation for privacy violations, one was a Constable involved in a civil rights lawsuit, and one is a decorated cop in Orange County.
Why the Records Are Hard to Pin Down
Public records aren't like a Google search. They're boring, bureaucratic, and often stuck behind paywalls.
- Redactions: Even if you find a police report, 90% of it might be blacked out.
- Jurisdiction: Records are split between Florida, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania.
- Name Variations: Nicholas, Nick, Fortunato, and Lilly are all used across these different cases.
People often see a headline and assume the "criminal record" is a mile long. Kinda like how a game of telephone works—one person mentions an investigation, and by the time it reaches Reddit, someone is claiming there's a 20-year history of felonies.
✨ Don't miss: How to Reach Donald Trump: What Most People Get Wrong
Actionable Steps for Verifying Records
If you're trying to dig into this for a background check or just out of curiosity, don't rely on TikTok "tea" pages. They get things wrong constantly.
- Check the County Clerk: For the Disney incident, you'd look at Orange County, Florida records.
- PACER for Federal Cases: If you want to read the lawsuit against the Pennsylvania Constable, you need a PACER account to look at the District of New Jersey filings.
- Verify the DOB: This is the biggest mistake people make. Always check the date of birth. The Constable from 2012 is much older than the TikTok creator.
Honestly, the "Nick Contino criminal record" is a prime example of why you can't trust a single source. You have a social media influencer, a law enforcement officer, and a local hero all sharing a name. One is facing potential charges in Florida, one was cleared of civil rights violations years ago, and one is just doing his job in New York.
Before you share a post or make an assumption, make sure you've got the right Nick.
To stay updated on the Florida investigation involving Lilly Tino, you can monitor the Florida Attorney General’s public press releases or search the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) database for any newly filed charges.